I love the dark. I have walnut butcher block on my white island

it's a personal choice, I like the dark with light cabinetry.

I have natural in my laundry room with green cabinetry.

The dark would look great with your floor... the light might look golden over time.

Natural. The dark will show the stray lint more.

dark. the other one is too yellow

Dark

the natural fights with your floor

They both fight with the floor, which looks grayish.

I like the dark with the white cabinets - more contrast. And dark will look much better with your floors.

Dark.

Dark

I much prefer the natural.

And this was the ”before”

I love it!!!

Thank you!

Very nice!. I would have voted dark in the before vote.

It's always so nice when people come back and show the finished room.

Thank you!

Looks great! Is this birch wood? What color stain did you use?

Thanks! I used the dark walnut (oil-based).

Nice job!