Hi team! We're looking to replace the old aluminum frame windows in our 1969 classic tract home/ranch in southern CA. We're also planning to paint the stucco + wood trim—currently thinking to do that in a rust/adobe-ish color combo (attaching mock-up here!).

I assume we'll need to do fiberglass rather than vinyl; I'm leaning toward black, but I'm worried that will look too dark, or end up looking dated quickly.

I'd love any insights or thoughts! Thanks so much!

(color mock-up:)