Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_41409242

Saving a countertop color mistake

3 years ago

Family members had new countertops installed. Home Depot solid surface. The color selected is Midnight Pearl: https://www.buildasurface.com/midnight-pearl-hi-macs?gclid=CjwKCAiA3KefBhByEiwAi2LDHDQOwrwyE-kAT6Hi4VqhulUcSNQUaQPemw36-c1SjEUnDyVYfxgUohoCTo0QAvD_BwE


The sample size, a few square inches, showed a color that was dark, with smokey shades and swirls of dark blue, gray and black with a few white flecks and overall a bit closer to the blue soapstone that had been an earlier preference.


The actual countertop as installed - which Home Depot did a great job in terms of quality, is much bluer. There is no mistaking it as anything but a blue countertop. Slightly on the darker blue side but still indisputably blue. However, it is the same Midnight Pearl. It is one of those instances where something that appears darker in a smaller sample is actually much lighter and bluer when a full countertop. Even photos I took on my phone come out darker than it really is in real life. And the 14'' square extra cutting board in Midnight Pearl and included with the countertop does even appear darker and smokier when it's placed against their center island, which is wood.


Husband is indifferent, countertops are countertops and he knows HD didn't make a mistake. Wife is very unhappy.


Are there options for toning down or darkening a solid surface countertop? There are some knowledgeable countertop people on here and I thought I'd ask around to see if anything can be done short of ripping the countertops out.



Comments (19)

  • PRO
    3 years ago

    No. This is why full slabs or minimally installed photos should always be viewed.

  • 3 years ago

    I agree with the previous comment that one should not make such a big purchase by just looking at a tiny sample. In addition, all the photos online of this Midnight Pearl LG Hi-Macsshow a color that is, as you put it, “indisputably blue”. So even with just online photos, there is no mistaking this counter for anything but blue. There is nothing that can be done other than replacement at your friends’ expense. They should have spent another couple minutes looking at the photos online.





  • 3 years ago

    what is the kitchen composed of? the space had no other changes??? so you have to work with this. New hardware/ backsplash yet to choose? some floor mats/ window treatments ?? counter accessories. isnt there a new sink? what faucet tis there? / light fixture...under cab lighting? solid surface is a nice material / she knew it would be dark certainly.... I dont think it's that much of an issue that it didnt end up dark steel or black. Maybe it doesnt work with her other elements but thats a different issue...sometimes new counters in old spaces can make the "whole" show it's obvious shortcomings. If brave..post pictures / maybe simple solutions to help.

  • PRO
    3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    I need to see the space to offer any suggestions but the lighting in the store is usually horrible and testing a counter from a tiny samplle never good That is blue even in the pic you posted . Now they change it or work with it. But I need pics of the space . Post the pics here in a comment do not start another post . Then we can maybe help. Make sure the pics show the floor and as much of the kitchen as possible.

  • PRO
    3 years ago

    "Are there options for toning down or darkening a solid surface countertop?"


    No, however, the finish can be changed from a semi-gloss which is darker to a matte. Half an hour job.

    Tom S thanked Joseph Corlett, LLC
  • 3 years ago

    Color is relative, so I'm wondering if the other finishes in the room exaggerate the blue by being warm or by having a yellow or orange undertone. Painting the walls and matte-ifying the the counter finish as recommended by Joseph seem like the least expensive and disruptive choice.

  • 3 years ago

    I tried taking pictures but the countertops come out darker in the pictures so they don't seem like much help.


    I can tell you the kitchen cabinets are your 1950s plywood cabinets, nearly indestructible. Painted off white and have been off-white for at least the last 40 years, which is when they have owned the house. All the kitchen walls are also the same off white. No backsplash, it's painted off white! House is a handsome 1920s stone house in a neighborhood where most houses are now usually on their third or even fourth expensive kitchen remodels. Family members had long debated redoing the kitchen but never got around to it and plan to downsize/move to a retirement community in five or so years, which was another reason for not doing a big remodel knowing new homeowners are likely to just gut and redo it anyway. So they decided to "freshen up" the kitchen with new wood flooring and new countertops. For a large house it's actually a fairly small space and doesn't get much direct sunlight.


    The countertops are not ugly, just more startling blue and by current fashions, an unexpected color.


    Sounds like having contractors come back to "mattefy" the countertop is probably the best path forward. I gather it's straightforward? If tiles are added to the backsplash, what colors or sheens would help darken the countertop?

  • 3 years ago

    I am thinking a lot of off whites have a yellowish cast which is only going to make the blue look more blue. It's time to consider repainting at least the walls.


    Look at the Benjamin Moore site at the blue colors. Many of the lightest tints will appear almost white/off white when compared to the countertops but will work better with the countertops.


    You aren't going to be able to compensate for the blueness or try and ignore it, you are going to have to work with it.

    Tom S thanked palimpsest
  • 3 years ago

    Carrera marble tile looks good with dark blue.

    The cabinets may look white, but they probably have an undertone. Chantilly Lace by Ben Moore might be the best and truest white option for cabinet paint.

    On the walls theymight condider the palest of blue gray. Use caution as gray undertones of violet or green will surprise you if youre not careful.


  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    I would just replace with a neutral (like white or off white) laminate, if the money is an issue. Or, butcher block. it would be beautiful and can be sealed with coats of Waterlox. i would not like that blue at all. For us non-decorators, it is best to make all hard surfaces/finishes neutrals….that complement each other. chalk it up to a life lesson. We all have them. You can try to sell the material on Craigslist.

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    if the plan is to sell the home... kitchen can be spruced up at that time....polished nickel hardware to give a little polish/ maybe a new light fixture in a metal/ is there a kitchen wall that can handle some art/ green plants ? some blue green patterned floor runners/ table decor [eat in space?] she probably has her countertop things there but wooden bowls / fresh white cansters etc / a new faucet...these are small things that when people walk through make it less glaring or whatever she sees as the problem.... dark counters w white cabinets generally is a classic combo so even tho she got a shock i'm not sure its going to be horrible considering their plans. If someone convinvces themself something is all wrong thats tough...usually with kitchens there are numerous things in the mix. When able... provide a photo here and people can be quite encouraging /see things a bit differently.

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Seems that the matte finish may help a bit, but the color is the color. Also they shouldn’t be worrying about resale, as it’s a good bet kitchen will be gutted. Sometimes a mistake can grow on you so they should live with for a bit and if still hating, suggest butcher block for its price and easy to incorporate style wise.

    Given the blue (and potentially butcher block), decorate to suit either and the kitchen would take on a new life with counter becoming an asset. Without seeing kitchen, hard to know what would suit, but imagine below as an example of how kitchen could benefit.

    Suggest using peel and stick backsplash tiles and there are endless choices. Easy to do!

    New hardware can change cabinetry and a rattan blind is an inexpensive addition.

    A mat or runner adds warmth and can help pull a look together.


  • 3 years ago

    — i agree they should try to lean into the blue - any chance you could post a few photos of the kitchen? i would imagine this group could absolutely help make it better :)

  • 3 years ago














  • 3 years ago

    Great examples palimpsest!

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    I am impressed by the photos palimpsest provided. I am now going to find a time to take some proper pictures of the kitchen and provide a bit more context too. It's an odd kitchen and much smaller than you'd expect given the overall size of the house and does have some real limitations any designer would have to work with. I'll try to get photos uploaded probably this weekend as that's the only time I can take pictures in full daylight. Stay posted!

  • 3 years ago

    These are all Houzz photos, so you may find more.

  • 3 years ago

    Please do post photos of the kitchen. The Houzz photos provided by palimpsest are very motivating and I predict by the end of next week your family member might be looking at her kitchen a bit differently!