Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_911471135

Upgrade kitchen on a small budget

3 years ago

Hi guys! I’m wanting to upgrade my kitchen to make it a little nicer and fix a few things before we sell it, but I don’t have a big budget to work with so I’m trying to decide what is the most value producing.

The current countertops have some water damage and a few chipped off pieces.
I would like to upgrade those to granite or quartz or something. So far I’m liking the dark countertops with the paint and flooring we did a few years ago best.
Also considering cutting the half wall down to flush with the counters to make the left side into an actual island. The main level is an open floor plan with kitchen, dining room, and living room on the other side of the half wall. It that a good idea or not?

I’m thinking a little bit about the dark countertops and painting the cabinets white. Does anyone have an idea for ball park cost to paint them? Self or professional? What kind of paint is used? It’s a fairly small townhouse kitchen.

Also looking for ideas for dining room light fixtures.

Comments (31)

  • 3 years ago

    Save your money for your next house. Unless you're living in an area which has a large inventory of unsold houses (which would not be typical right now) your house will sell even if you do nothing. Just price it accordingly. Personally I wouldn't buy a house that had old cabinets with a new granite counter because I would feel bad about sending the granite to a landfill when replacing the cabinets. Painting them white isn't going to change the arched tops on the uppers and it doesn't look like you have many drawers which means they're clearly dated. There is probably a buyer out there who won't care about the condition of the kitchen because they want to rip it out and replace it with their dream kitchen. Declutter, clean, repair and list. You only need to repair the things the home inspector will turn up. Chipped counters are not a functional issue. Doing work will cause a delay in listing. Right now is the busy season for home selling. In my area the inventory is so low everything is selling in a week.

  • 3 years ago

    Your kitchen looks very clean and tidy. if the rest of your house is the same you are already ahead of 99% of people who post on here about what to do before they sell.

    I wouldn't do a thing to the kitchen. It is nice now and let the next owner pick the counters if they want to replace them. Same with the cabinets. Please do not paint them.

  • 3 years ago

    Thank you for the advice

  • 3 years ago

    This is great advice.

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Selling? When? It is too bad to make changes for someone else. If your planned sale is less than a year away, I wouldn’t do anything except continue to maintain & clear things out. Even tidy homes such as yours appears to be generally have too much stuff that one doesn’t want to pack up & move. IMO, ’small budget’ doesn’t include painting cabinets - a good job is professional & $$$. I wouldn’t paint those cabs - they look in decent shape & work with the flooring. Upgrading damaged counters would be $ well spent. The black you’re looking at is okay but not my taste & too high maintenance. Lighter - not necessarily white - is better. Cutting off the high bar & making that island all counter height is also a great idea. Can’t tell if there’s space for an overhang & counter stools but something to consider. If that’s done, be sure to have steel support bars installed under new counter. No change needed for flooring as no change to footprint. Doing that does increase the available flat work space so is a plus. Replace the sink too with an undermount single bowl stainless. Love the Elkay sink with 15 degree radius corners so not round but not tight square corners either. New faucet too of course.

    ETA - all the counter changes I describe are only worth it if done for yourself. My first question - selling & when - is the factor that determines whether or not any changes are worth your $$.

  • 3 years ago

    We’re just starting to look into it, but considering selling in the next few months.

    Nothing is set in stone at this point though. Brainstorming and seeing what we could get pre approval for getting into our next place.

    I’m definitely all about having a clean and tidy house and getting rid of extra stuff that doesn’t add to it or quality of life. My plants obviously go in the add to quality of life category 😜

    I picked the flooring a few years ago to match the cabinets and wall color and have been struggling with countertops colors to go with all that 😂

  • 3 years ago

    There is a little overhand on the other side of the half wall and that is part of what we were thinking with cutting the wall down to counter height. Add bar stools. It would cut into the living room space a little bit though.

  • 3 years ago

    If extending the counter to a sit at bar size cuts into LR space too much & makes a stool that’s pulled away from counter be sitting in the walkway then there’s not enough room to extend counter. The new counter should be just enough to cover the pony wall with the usual 1/2” - 1” counter overhang. But, considering selling in the next few months? Forget making any changes except painting if needed. You will likely not find a contractor to work on counter cutting for several months - they’re all busy & scheduled out. Just work on your exterior if needed - clean up winter & make entry pretty!

  • 3 years ago

    Please do not add stone countertops, someone is going to just rip it out and it will end up in a landfill. Just clean up and price accordingly, and save yourself the hassle and money for upgrades that aren’t fooling anyone.

  • 3 years ago

    Ok. We will see if things happen quickly or not.
    My husband works in construction and would be the one to cut the wall down, but it probably is too tights for bar stools with the walkway.

  • 3 years ago

    I would not find it worth doing anything as it seems you are wanting to do things that YOU would like to see in the kitchen not what the new owner will want. You could spend all that money and they will tear it all out. I have seen that happen many times and I have done it myself.

    Save your money for the next house.

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    It looks fine. Just clean it up and stage it well. Let the next homeowners decide. not everybody likes dark counters or granite, so changing anything like that could be a waste of time and resources.

  • 3 years ago

    Plants for sure add to quality of life. When we sold our home I made sure there was at least one plant in every room. For me it just gives the home another layer of "looks taken care of" and "can live in" feel.

  • 3 years ago

    Clean, clean, clean, stage, DONE


  • 3 years ago

    If you're selling in a few months, do not invest in expensive countertops. I do not think you will see a return on the investment. If there is a concern that buyers will not make an offer because of them, then you can always offer a seller credit towards countertops or something.


    It's difficult to make a choice for a prospective buyer when you don't know what they might like. For example, if I were buying the house, I'd want to knock down the pony wall and have the countertop all the same height by the sink. And I would choose a light countertop, not dark. But that's my personal taste and the actual prospective buyers might want something totally different


    Also, I would not paint the cabinets. Good quality, good condition wood cabinets are wonderful and many buyers, like myself, would love to have them. I would be far more disappointed to see paint over what looks like knotty alder. You're not going to get a nice smooth finish and I think you will devalue the kitchen in the process.


    Your home looks lovely and well maintained and I think if it's priced correctly, it will sell without any changes to the kitchen.

  • 3 years ago

    A neighbor across the street from me had their entire house ( large ) repainted inside & out, new windows throughout, & new flooring installed before listing their house for sale. Guess what? The buyer redid everything , including replacing all of the windows because they didn’t want white ! save your $ & do what others on here have suggested.

  • 3 years ago

    I wouldn't do a thing except clean and declutter.


    Some posters have said a future buyer will want to do their own remodeling. While this is true, there is also a market for people who would rather pay less and can live with a functional tidy kitchen even if it isn't on trend.

  • PRO
    3 years ago

    Wood stained cabinets are back in style but usually not with dark counters. I have to agree with everyone. Don't spend your money. Someone coming in will do as they please with the space. Most buyers are more concerned with updated heating/cooling systems, new roof, new water heater etc.

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Your house looks clean, and your cabinets appear to be in great shape. If you replace anything at all, it should be the countertops. NO, not granite, etc, new formica, would do just fine. That gives buyers a chance to live with it, and not think they have to tear apart right away, when funds are already low from buying the house. The new formica countertops are very pretty. You could install granite, your buyer might hate granite, but love quartz, you could put in quartz, and your buyer may hate quartz. It is better to spend less, and put in some great looking formica. No paint on cabinets, it wont make them look any different than they are now, and many prefer the wood over painting. Clean, and declutter, and you are ready for sale. If anything is actually broken, then replace. If your faucets are leaking, or not in good repair, then replace. Anything that is actually broken, or appears to be deferred maintenance, replace. or repair. Oh, and no dark countertops. Todays buyers want light countertops.

  • 3 years ago

    Thank you all for the great insights and experience advice! I’ll definitely be reconsidering plans and figure out simpler fixes.

  • 3 years ago

    I’m house hunting. I like clean and tidy homes and yours looks just that. I could move right in and change anything later if I wished. I’d rather have new plumbing, or electrical, for example, instead of an updated kitchen of bath.

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    I wouldn't spend a dime on the kitchen. quartz will cost over 4K. and quite frankly, against the dated cabinets, it's only going to make it look more dated (because of the cabinet style)

    Painting cabs is a huge DIY undertaking. if you don't do it correctly, the poor people will be dealing w/peeling paint. getting someone to do will cost over 4-5K. It's not going to make a diff.

    It looks very nice as is. I'd paint the walls a nice, brighter color, add some colorful accesories (like the fruit or flowers) and call it a day. New countertops are not going to get you another 10-20K !

    I would however think about trimming out the windows w/nice casing and removing the mini blinds. trimming them out, painting white w/a new wall color will freshen up the walls. the mini blinds tend to look very generic, so if you can do some faux roman shades, or find some decent blinds that don't cost a lot, I'd go that route


    the woven woods would actually compliment the wood cabinets and flooring. use a nice white semi gloss paint for the window trim. I'm sure your other half could do that as a DIY







  • 3 years ago

    Anyone have tips or ideas for how to touch up the knotty alder cabinets in a few places from wear or water damage taking off the protective glaze in a few places?

    It’s also possible we may keep the house for a while longer and turn it into a rental so I want it be able to work on some little things to make it nicer.

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    vera, show me the spot on the cab you're referring to.

    Did you like the window idea?

    what about switching out the hardware?


    you could also remove a few of the upper panels and insert some glass. change out hardware, do a cheaper granite (like this santa cecelia) a simple subway tile, (and I'd change your sink) for a complete make-over.


    Here's alder w/diff elements.


    matte black hardware. I'd do all handles


    You could go look at some granite in this color range. for 4K you should be able to get something that works w/the wood.





    the other option would be to use a matte charcoal quartz countertop and switch out the sink to an undermount or a drop-in farmhouse like shown in this pic w/the charcoal quartz


    Do a similar subway tile backsplash while you're at it. this one is oak, but you get the idea.




  • 3 years ago

    Don’t spend money on the kitchen unless your realtor says “ The countertops need updating.” Clean and uncluttered makes buyers think you cared about ALL of the house.

    Save your money for your next house. Your kitchen is nicer than most.

  • 3 years ago

    Beth H. - There is the one with the most damage (kids washing/playing in the sinks)

    I just found this Formica laminate today in the second picture and am thinking it would tie everything in beautifully. Not too dark but has all the key colors I’ve got going on.
    I’m thinking we could cut down the half wall ourselves switch out the sink and faucet and do a little backsplash by the stove.

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    you could take a 220 or 320 grit sandpaper (or sponge) and lightly go over that area to remove any flakes and discolored parts. do the entire face if you like. just go easy. you only want to remove the top clear coat.

    then get a clear satin topcoat varnish (not poly). I like General Finishes Urethane. they have a wipe on formula.


    Satin isn't glossy. I'm guessing the rest of your finish is satin? they also have a matte finish

    I've also used this one. satin is the finish you see in the pic


  • 3 years ago

    It’s probably something like that. Not super shiny. I’ll give that a shot. Thanks for the great ideas!

  • 3 years ago

    This forum will ALWAYS tell you not to do any upgrades to your house. They are convinced that because they all like renovations (hence, their participation in this forum), that all home buyers are fine renovating houses.


    In reality, sometimes it makes sense to upgrade your house and sometimes it doesn't. Depends on your market and your price point, and what the rest of your house looks like. You need to look at comps. Don't spend $5000 on new countertops if the rest of your house feels squarely in 1998. But if much of your house is fairly neutral, and you could make some superficial updates throughout and make it feel "2023-ish", then updating the counters might make sense. But again, also depends on your market and price point.


    Every market I've ever lived in, spending money on aesthetic improvements always reaps a return when it comes time to sell. These are higher end, urban and semi-urban markets, where people have money to pay for a more expensive house but don't have the time or inclination to renovate (2 busy working professionals). But there are lots of markets in the US where the same is not true.

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    H202 makes a good point that there are some high end markets where home buyers must have turn key. but is that really the case in this house? if it is, then update the kitchen with general crowd pleasing finishes that are on trend today (such as with bright finishes, neutral colors). I'm sorry to say it, but dark brown granite is not exactly a crowd pleaser these days.

    but what is a crowd pleaser anyway? what if you absolutely nail it with the new countertop choice, but the next homeowner hates the layout, or wishes you didn't paint the cabinets? tear it all out. it makes me cringe.

    for me, not every home choice is driven by money. I'm trying so hard to make thoughtful choices for sake of the environment. home flipping is basically the same as fast fashion. of course we should do what pleases us to our own homes. but when it comes to flipping for a few extra bucks, I wish people would slow down at least just a little.

  • 3 years ago

    Your realtor can honestly give you the best answer to the question of if the kitchen will prevent the home from selling or significantly impact the sale price. So much depends on your local and even hyperlocal market — and when you go on the market.

    If you end up renting, do not put a dime into the kitchen! Rental property and rental property maintenance requires a very different mindset. You have to think about as a business: what’s the least amount you have to spend to keep the property consistently rented at a rate commensurate with its size, beds/baths, garage bays, and location. It’s nearly impossible to significantly increase the rental rate with upgrades.

    Staying in the property is yet a different conversation—so much more fun—because these are choices you make for your needs and wants! I am no pro at design but would want to replace chipped countertops for sure, and a single level for the island/counter could be lovely.

    That island/counter layout is a very standard one for the era with the angle. I have seen (and unfortunately cannot find right now) some slight alterations of this layout that may be of interest to you. This would mean some reflooring but it could be worth it.

    The most dated of your cabinets look like the uppers. You could replace only those doors and paint just the uppers, leaving the lowers as is. They do work nicely with your flooring. Some people prefer uniformity in their cabinetry though. Just thought I’d throw that one out there!