I use sheers on my windows so I get light and privacy at the same time. I really like your current door configuration and I would not change it.

There are lots of window films that aren't foggy, but have various patterns or even colours like stained glass. Before you consider replacing the entire door, you may want to invest $50 and try a "non-foggy" window film with a pattern to see if you like it. https://artscape-inc.com/collections/window-film

No double door on that house, also no shutters on double windows and in this case just no shuuters at all. I have no idea about what the reason is for not wanting just glass in a door . I guess if you run around naked it matters but honestly what would someone see if they came to the door? I like as much light as possible in my home so the reeded glass IMO would be the best choice if you must have the privacy I hate window films always .

No double door on that house. The door that you have is fine. But it could stand for a dash of color.

Normally, I like shutters. But I would remove them on your house. Wrong size, wrong windows (double windows) and don't work with the board & batten siding. Distracting in a 'I, the shutter, don't belong here.'

i would paint surrounding windows same as door for cohesion.

I dislike double doors in general as they are just harder to keep locked and seem easier to break into.

Double doors are a waste--no one ever uses the both of them unless you're moving a grand piano into the house! (Ask me how I know.)

I have a single door with clear glass sidelights, no curtains, and have no problem with privacy. I can't imagine it would be a problem unless your front door opens onto your bedroom or bathroom, LOL.

As far as painting the door, you can either paint it the same color as the shutters, or a different one if you want to emphasize the front door. You could do a darker blue, or a contrasting color, like red, yellow or orange.

Lighter blue on gray house with dark shutters:

Nest in the Trees · More Info

Dark gray shutters and door:

Summer School (Cape Cod, MA) · More Info

Green door with darker green shutters:

Farmhouse · More Info

Yellow against gray is quite dramatic!

A door color to pop dark gray siding! · More Info

Light blue door with gray shutters:

Modern Farmhouse - Audubon Square · More Info

Red doors are quite popular and classic:

Restored Eating Club · More Info

Minneapolis Cape Cod Renovation · More Info

Orange is an attention-getter!

Fulton Bungalow · More Info

Your door and sidelights fit your home perfectly. I would do the seeded glass film or sheers on the windows first before investing.

Thank you so much for pointing out my current door is already looking great. Will drop the door replacement idea.