Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_846379184

Half round gutter installed incorrectly ?

3 years ago

Hi,


I am replacing my 22 year old roof, and need to address how my gutters were installed by previous owner.


They are half round hanging gutters with the fascia on a 45 degree angle, and were installed by hanging them from the top of the roof shingles.


Do these need/should be re-hung by attaching to the fascia board, or is it ok to reattach directly to the roof, but under the shingles ?


Is there any way in which the current installation is ok ?


Thanks !



Comments (3)

  • 3 years ago

    Thats a good question. The roofer said I should talk to a gutter person. I called a number of them, therer are few who do half round. I spoke to one company that specializes in installing and repairing gutters, and they do handle half rounds, however, he has never done one on angled fascia. This is from a company that does a of of gutters in Metrowest Boston (Wellesley/Newton/Weston). He said they should probably be attached to the fascia, but would need custom wedges based on the angles. He cannot even come out for an estimate until late October. I am trying to find another company that does this type of work.


    I have seen on the web diagrams of putting half round on anged fascia, they do have fastners and wedges. Others have said (on roofingtalk) that hanging them is the way to go.


    I have also walked by literally hundreds of houses in my surrounding neighborhoods, and have not seen any with angled fascia, let alone with half rounds.


    I will probably havethem removed, roof taken off, and then put back on like they are, but under the shingles. They have not been the source of any problems for 22 years, and I don't want to get involved with a complete replacement.




  • PRO
    3 years ago

    You don’t have a fascia designed for gutters. To attach the gutters without the roof attachment you would need to rebuild the fascia (yuck) or add blocking periodically.

    Andrew thanked HALLETT & Co.
  • 3 years ago

    @HALLETT - Thank you, kind of seals my fate. Since the existing system has worked and has not caused problems, rebuilding the fascia or what sounds like a lot of blocking work will be too expensive for what I would get. It will also be next to impossible to get gutter work done in my area this year, let alone finding someone who has actually done this before.