Not a pro but… omg no! It’s so stinkin’ cute right now. The multicolor roof ruins it.

I mean… assuming the gray is current color🤓 the dark gray is perfect.

Black or the darkest Grey Blend available. Have your roofer pick up a full bundle and spread them out, no sample boards or visualizers, real shingles for color selection.

Don’t add anything busy - you already have a lot going on with the siding, shutters, peaks, stone, etc. Keep it simple up there, the house is wonderful.

I would stick with something similar to the current color. Simple…nothing busy.

I'd also stick with something closer to the current color - it looks great!

Thank you and i do sincerely appreciate your input and remarks, but,

ive attached finished photos of completed roof: i stuck with my gut instinct and chose Summer Harvest afterall. The shingle colors are amazing and it blends so well i coukdn’t be happier with the results. i am one to think out if the box and not do the norm Its just who I am ive received so

many complements already by neighbors and my roofing team

Your posting belongs in Before and After since you were asking for affirmation of what you already decided. This is a Design Dilemma forum for problems yet to be solved.

@millworkman: I think of somebody already made their choice, as she stated, then there's no Design Dilemma. That's why I thought it should be a Before and After, not a dilemma.