We tried to match the yellow and clearly it didn't work!

Even if you had the original color, it's unlikely a fresh coat would match the older application.

Perfect excuse to choose a fun color instead.

Like choose a darker version of the body color. Or go bolder and do a coordinating, purple, red, orange.

I might consider painting the smaller surround section a different color…match the door or add a new accent color?…or white?

Or even the siding color?

The reason being it looks too big ..proportionately…if all the same color

Yeah, I see that too. Wonder if you took the body/siding color and just went a couple shades darker. I'd order a spray can of whatever color ends up around the door and change the bright white storm door too. myperfectcolor.com does custom spray cans in any color. I'd get two cans.

Suggest white for the entire trim and a welcoming color for storm and front door to draw the eye. If interested, I’d remove the two large cedars and add planters on the stoop. Consider at some point removing the bushes between the cedars to soften/layer/add interest.

I do not see shutters and I would not do them either . As for the trim I have no idea whay you wanted yellow and not sure what yellow you were trying to copy. I would redo the window trim in white and door frame in acolor you choose for the new front door and get a much nice front door then add the color there . I think you should be palnning some kind od cover over that door so maybe think about a bit of cahnge for the whole frsmework around the door to add a portico for protection for guests and aslo to protect whatever you choose for a door. To mee the door frame is too ornate for the house .I do agree about planters to replace those trees which are planted way too close to the house and really do nothing to enhance the home. Why do you need a storm door ? I use steel doors in cold climates and if you like to have to screen get a Phantom screeen so the nice front door shows.

The storm door frame needs to be the same color as the door behind it.

Here is a beautiful colonial green house with darker green around the front door: https://www.pinterest.com/pin/first-snow--633387424605530/

IMO the area could benefit by replacing the modern steel screen/storm door with a vintage wood door with replacement glass/screens.

Where are the grids on the windows. They appear foreign to this home.

Take out the overgrown evergreens and come up with a new landscaping plan for the front of your home.

https://www.vintagedoors.com/tscreenstorm.html

Wow - thank you so very much everyone!