Software
Houzz Logo Print
becky_dean98

Complete Kitchen redo

2 years ago

I'm trying to decide whether to spend twice as much for custom inset cabinets over outside set doors and drawers. I love the look of inset custom ones and am wondering if I could cut corners somewhere else in my kitchen? Wondering if I'll regret not getting them later or if I won't even notice after awhile.

My house was built in 1928 and has a lot of the original woodwork, etc. I want to retain that look in my kitchen.....

Comments (12)

  • PRO
    2 years ago

    I think it depends on your style not the house age or style . This kitcehn was in a 1905 house our style contemporary but we loved the exterior of the house and kept it true to the original . I have no problem with interiors done differently from the exterior. I do not like inset cabinets they waste space are expensive to build and really for very little improvement in any part of a kitchen reno BTw the DR pic shows where we actually kept the ceiling and replaced all the trim that had been removed we had removed a wall so I spent hours trying to replicate the ceiling it cam out pretty good I think



  • 2 years ago

    I went with custom inset, and we don't even have a historic home! All the kitchen photos to which I was drawn had inset cabinets. It involved some loss of storage space, but it was worth it to me. I also prefer butterfly hinges that allow the doors to open flat.


    Apples to apples the cabinets should not be twice as much. Are you comparing stock full overlay to custom inset?

  • 2 years ago

    We did a mix of inset and frameless in our 1915 house. We used the frameless on an L where space was tight and we wanted lots of drawers so didn’t want to lose all that space to the frames. The inset cabinets are on a separate wall, modeled after a neighbor’s identical home where they have the same split except that their inset cabinets are original. (Our kitchen had been gut renovated in the early 40s so all of the original cabinets were gone.) We used different colors and counter materials to visually separate the space and I like to think that it has echoes of the period even while clearly being an updated space. We did match the Shaker door rail and stile widths to the original built-ins that still remained in the house.

  • PRO
    2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    You cannot take fancier stuff with you. Fancier stuff cannot make you happy if you are unhappy. More $$ on fancier stuff is not a decision that someone with lots of disposable income thinks about so much. They just buy what they want. Agonizing about it says that money is better saved than spent.

    Cabinets are just boxes that hold stuff. Having special boxes that hold stuff for a high price vs a really nice vacation somewhere for the family to make memories? The difference e betwen a 150K kitchen and a 300K isn't as large as you think. It's all in the small details that complete the whole. The difference between a 75K kitchen and a 150K kitchen is large. It's big details, not small details.



  • 2 years ago

    How you spend your money is your business, but if you are questioning the cost difference, you are not comfortable spending it. Look at doing inset cabinets from another source, like Medallion, Shiloh, Durasupreme, or Omega. Double cost difference sounds like the cabinet maker doesn't know what he is doing. There should not be that large of a difference. 15% price increase, sure. Even 20%. But not 100%.

  • PRO
    2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    What kind of company charges double for inset? Not any one I'd do business with!

  • 2 years ago

    I've never had inset, though I like the look. I would like to caution that you speak with the cabinet maker about how the cabinets will be put together. In this post from a few years ago, the poster was disappointed because their new inset cabinets weren't ganged but were instead separate cabinets installed side by side. This resulted in a seam and a wider space between cabinets than they expected. I'm not saying that's wrong, just saying to be aware of what you may need to specify to get the look you have in mind.

    Ganged inset cabinets:

    Separate inset cabinets showing the seam between:

    This might have some useful info: Everything You Should Know About Inset Cabinets.

  • 2 years ago

    Wow. This article above is very informative. Thank you!

  • 2 years ago

    I just want to know what company doubles their cost for inset? Even in a full custom line like Omega, it’s maybe 15%.

  • 2 years ago

    I am guessing from the post that it’s custom inset vs. stock overlay—that could easily be double the cost. If that’s the case, though, it’s worth noting that it’s not just the inset that you’re paying more for—custom also allows you to better fit cabinets to the space, and the construction quality is sometimes different, too. And, of course, the reminder that custom doesn’t necessarily mean quality—you need the specs of both cabinet options to compare.

  • 2 years ago

    Thank you artemis78. You are correct. Very good quality inset compared to stock overlay is a big cost difference.

  • 2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    There is a world of difference between stock and full custom. Lots of semi custom lines around to fit in between.