I need second opinions please! We need to replace our windows and I'm stuck on whether or not to jump on the black bandwagon. Our brick is a mixture of yellow/beige/red. I'm worried the contrast of our house colour to the new windows is going to be too much.

We're also going to paint the eaves, soffit and fascia after the windows are installed and I am leaning towards iron ore or smoked timber to avoid black overload.

First photo below is before and the second and third are my rough photoshopping skills with different window styles.

The window on the top left has a false one above it so we plan on filling that in with brick from the existing porch pillars and altering those to a combo of brick, cap and post.

Would love your thoughts!! Love it? Hate it? What would you do in this situation?