Marianne and her pet both look terrific! Your Barden roses must be very hardy, too.

Beautiful!!

I love your Marianne, Deborah!

Looking real good!

Exquisite.

Thank you all for your comments, and yes, BenT both Oshun and Marianne have been hardy to the tips so far.

Your Marianne looks wonderful, Deborah!

I cant wait until mines that big in my Twin Cities garden! Umbra does well here too. Do you get winterkill?

What else does well for you here?

It's beautiful. I'm really glad to hear it's hardy to the tips that far north. It also looks very healthy. I bought three plants of it last year from Paul Barden and got one in the ground so far. It's growing very well and had a few blooms but they were white. I fully expect they'll have the beautiful colors as the plant matures.

Josg, Marianne has been hardy to the tips through the past 4 winters. I have Umbra as well, but just beginning to bloom, second summer. I have two rose gardens and have planted well over 100 varieties, losing only one, Gloire Lyonnaise. Those with no or very little winter dieback include: Celsiana, William Lobb, Above and Beyond, Hansa, Snow Pavement (constant bloom all season), Blanc Double de Courbet, Nevada, Aicha, Applejack, Captain John Ingram, Charles de Mills, Duchesse de Montebello, Henry Kelsey, John Davis, Queen of Denmark and best of all the Geschwind’s that I managed to snag. They include Josephine Ritter, Himmelsauge, and Gypsy Boy. These are completely cold hardy and vigorous growers. Most of these are once bloomers and I think I may prefer them in MN, as they beat the Japanese beetles which have been terrible. If you are up for another list of repeat bloomers that grow well with some dieback just let me know. Happy gardening!

Erasmus, my Marianne is producing mostly white blooms, as is my Madame Ernest Calvat. I am not sure what to attribute that to, both have been in the ground for 4 years and get plenty of sun.

@Deborah MN zone 4 - I would really appreciate a list of the repeat blooming roses that do well for you in zone 4. I send roses to my sister in northern Iowa every year and am always on the hunt for roses that will survive well in her climate. She's not a big fan of once-blooming roses, so that limits my options... Thanks in advance!

I would also like a list of the repeat bloomers although I'm in a much warmer zone I hate winter. Back. Die back. I'm most interested in John David Davis repeat and any thing else about him you care to share.

Yes, I would as well… thanks for the list of once bloomers.

John, Vaporvac and Josg, I will try to post a list of repeaters later today. Thanks for the interest.

Here is my list of repeat blooming roses that have done well with die back, some significant. This was a relaxing falling asleep thought process.

Fool proof, continual bloom, most are semi doubles, that grow to about 3 by 3 during the season.
All the Rage
Funny Face
Nearly Wild
Hot Cocoa
These are very modern looking, with the exception of Nearly Wild (Brownell, 1941), which is sprawling in the shade under a crabapple tree.

Polyanthas
I love this class and planted several, these are the best performers.
The Fairy
Pink Pet/Caldwell Pink

Austin’s
All have survived winter with varying degrees of dieback and come back strong and bloom well. These are the best.
Wollerton Old Hall - great rebloom and little dieback. So far a decent climber in zone 4.
Heritage - little dieback, but not a bloom machine
Crown Princess Margareta - excellent, but not quite as good as WOH.
I have other Austin’s, but too early to evaluate.

Buck
Freckles
Winter Sunset
Both have some dieback but come back strong and rebloom very well, actually continual bloom. Freckles is a lovely pink with a charming stippled bloom.

Sorry about what Houzz did to my careful formatting. I hope it is still understandable.

Thank you.. I agree with you especially those that I grow also. John Davis is not in that group? I've been considering this road. Rose

Vaporvac, I meant to answer your question about John Davis, sorry. I haven’t had enough time with that one to speak about rebloom. I should know more later in the season.

Thank you!

There were several surprises in your list, @Deborah MN zone 4 - thank you so much for sharing it!

I noticed Wollerton Old Hall was a rather big and healthy rose at the Lyndale rose garden a couple weeks ago.

Soo glad to see someone growing Marianne in MN! Rvr has this one and I just ordered! Was wondering how big to expect this roses to get large to expect it to get

Ah! Wondering how large to expect this rose to get as most roses here don’t get very big..,aside from a spreading pink Gallican I grew

6 by 6 ft the OP says in Minnesota.