In 2000 I replaced original wood windows in a 1969 cape cod home. I got Pella because at the time they had true divided lite windows that matched what I was replacing. They are wood interior aluminum clad. Andersen did not. Now doing some remodeling and using Andersen 400 series. I much prefer the Andersen to the Pella.

Double and single hung look the same, with double being more widely available and more coveniently for cleaning on the second floor.

The design of your home lends itself to colonial grids.

Generally speaking I like Andersen more than Pella, but I'd agree with the comments above about getting more specific about the model. In my opinion there are better windows than out there than either of them especially for the needs and wants of most customers.

Nothing Pella ever. Double or Single Hung's will look the same, so function here is up to you. No grids. Just my .02. As above, what series Andersen?

We have had good luck with Andersen.

I agree that the bright blue shutters look cheesy.

By the way, finding a skilled is important too

What if we did no shutters and windows without grids?