Lovely home! Subtle is #1 or #5. #3 says Hey, look at me! If you plan to be there for some time, I imagine the door color may get updated at some point so for now, choose the one that pleases you.

What does the door look like? What will the door be made of?

Is this what you mean by door is a 6 light Nantucket style door?

If so, remember, because of all of the glass in your door, there is not going to be a ton of painted surface and this might not pop as you are imagining. Find sample pics of painted 6 light doors so you can really envision the look and the impact it will or will not make.

What color is the siding - griege? Beige?I I would choose 5 or 6 based on your photos, but it's hard to tell.

For me a red

Thank you everyone! I did attempt to use a blue from Old Village Paints which is oil based and more historic but it was slightly dark. It is greige. The color on the siding is a stain that I made with the siding company. I’m thinking the lower of the two blue but I will look a little more. #5

#1 or #5, but the next darker color on the chip of one of those.

#5

I like the one on the right in the second pic.

#6 the glass will show black/charcoal, the trim white.

Would agree with a lighter color such as #1 or #5 as you mentioend there is quite a bit of shade on the door.

Another vote for 5, at least as it appears on my screen.

" Also door is a 6 light Nantucket style door under a portico so area does get some shade. "

Again, what material is the door?

The door is mahogany

And no one likes YELLOW?

From far away

" The door is mahogany "

Stain it a natural mahogany color (not deep red). No to yellow paint. Why spend the money on a mahogany door and paint it?

Mahogany holds up the best. I feel like stained is a bit too formal for my liking.

I like the yellow but prefer the other 2 more. You could play up the yellow with perennial flowers, pots etc. which would compliment nicely.

Number 5.

I would choose number 2 or 6. Will look nice.