Software
Houzz Logo Print
christi_jensen

Sherwin-Williams Yellow Color for Exterior

2 years ago

Hi, I am owner-building a new house on a farm in Utah. We are ordering LP Smartside from our contractor, who will have the siding painted with a company that offers all Sherwin-Williams colors. I'm panicking because I live too far from a Sherwin Williams store and I don't have a way to get paint samples in time! I am having a hard time finding pictures of houses painted in Sherwin-Williams colors that I'm considering. I am looking for a soft, creamy yellow that is actually yellow (not almost white) but not too bright. Our house is two story and very exposed to the sun, so I'm also concerned about not getting something that is going to be too bright!

I really like Benjamin Moore's Windham Cream. I have been thinking Sherwin William's Full Moon, and I've seen a picture of a house in Banana Cream that I liked. Does anyone have photos of a house painted in a soft yellow Sherwin Williams color?

Comments (14)

  • 2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    You can go to Home Depot and purchase small samples of the colors (obviously, they are put into HD paint jars/cans).

    Is this perfect? Um, maybe not? But as a homeowner, I have done my own painting a lot. A lot. And I've never had an issue with color matching, nor from using another paint manufacturers' colors in Home Depot paint.

    Home Depot has all the codes at their fingertips from S-W. And this is a better option for you than asking people what they have used on their homes.

    I have fan decks for some of the manufacturers, like S-W. You might want to invest in a fan deck. I find it helpful.

  • 2 years ago

    We‘ve also bought sample cans of SW at Lowe’s.

  • 2 years ago

    You know Benjamin Moore colors. Check out their Hawthorne Yellow. And get a sample of it. Then get it matched at SW. It is a true yellow, but not garish. Also, not crème. I have seen it on an exterior in Minnesota AND I have it as my interior guestroom color (north facing) in Ohio. Give it a try.

  • 2 years ago

    If I were buying LP Smartside siding, I'd be inclined to buy one of the 16 prefinished colors, assuming that a factory-applied finish was best even if I couldn't get the color I preferred most.

    You might research Cool Exterior Walls and select a yellow paint color with a high solar reflectance from the directory. Here are six in order of reflectance:

  • PRO
    2 years ago

    I agree with selecting a color from the standard LP Smartside. They have tested these colors for durability. I would select this one. Sand Dunes





  • 2 years ago

    Thank you! I went to a local hardware store and got them to make paint samples color-matched to Sherwin Williams colors for me!

    (Wdccruise, the siding company we are going with has a company that applies its own factory finish using Sherwin Williams colors).

  • PRO
    2 years ago

    The fact is factory prefinished will last longer and any color will fade in the intese sun . I find most yellows on large homes too much yellow but we have no idea what your home looks like or wahy out of all the colors yellow . So post a pic of the house , does it have stone or brick anywhere what are the windows so many things drive exterior color I need context .

  • 2 years ago

    "the siding company we are going with has a company that applies its own factory finish using Sherwin Williams colors"

    Oh, I thought you were buying LP Smartside siding whose factory options are 16 standard colors or prime-only.

  • 2 years ago

    Our contractor is taking the primed smartside to a place that does the finishes, not buying it prefinished from LP.

    Here is a photo of the house. Patricia Colewell, it is small or a 2-story - only a little less than 1700 square foot above grade. We are going for a historic farmhouse (definitely not Modern Farmhouse) look. why yellow of all colors? Because my husband and I both love yellow houses. There is no brick or stone on the house.

    I got samples of Lemon Meringue and Full Moon before realizing hey were i terior colors. Full Moon looks like exactly what I want. I think I will try banana cream, but I’m aftaid it will be too bright.


  • 2 years ago

    Trying again to post the photo, because I don’t think it posted last time.


  • PRO
    2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    I would get 2 huge boards primed and apinted with the samples 2 coats and then see how they look in the bright light I think both those coloors will wash out in the soutern sun Check out Venetian Yellow

  • 2 years ago

    Kay Smith, do you happen to have a photo of your house with the Banana Cream you’d be willing to share?

  • 2 years ago

    When I search for SW matches with BM's Windham Cream I get Buff, Classic Ivory, Friendly Yellow and Glittery Yellow.