Gutters are not a design feature. They should blend in not stand out as black will.

I guess I’m just looking at something different since they need replacing. But I agree with you.

Gutters aren’t a feature, they are part of the trim. If you are getting white windows paint all the trim white including soffit and gutter

What stands out to me is the entry door with the curved window above. It just doesn’t fit with the peaked roof of the porch entry. If any room in the budget for closing the half-circle and a different door then spend money there.

White windows, doors, trim (all trim including door frame & sidelites) & gutters. If you can get rid of the half round transom I would do that in a second as it is out of place. Lose the shutters, at the very least on the two wide windows. Clean up the landscaping by cutting back some of the bushes. What type siding is on the home currently? What type might you be thinking of changing it to?

I’m afraid it’s not in my budget to change above my door window. I would think that would be very expensive and honestly I like it. It may be out of style but it is what made me fall in love with the house in the first place. I’m mostly looking for color choices and porch railing ideas. The siding is vinyl and I probably will have to stay with vinyl but change color when I replace it.

Then I would do this:

" White windows, doors, trim (ALL trim including door frame & sidelites) & gutters. "