Never select colors from a computer screen. The two blacks look the same.

Mark, for sure. And will find a few nearby installs of both shingle colors. That said, do you really think they look the same? Cinder appears more monotone black - Moire more staggered black/gray. Regardless - thx!

Beverly - I see the images you added. Did you have a comment as well? Would love your POV.

Diana - thank you! Would love just a brief explanation on why you recommend more uniformity (Cinder). I don’t disagree! Rather, I know I’ll learn something from understanding your rationale. Thx!

Take the largest samples of the materials you are considering you can find in the colors you are considering to your building site and place them in the position they will be in (vertical for wall material, on an angle up high for roof material, etc). Look at them at different times of the day and follow your gut feeling. People will compliment you on your selection and you will tell them, "Ya, I picked them out myself".

Mark, thx once more.

As Mark says, get a bundle of each and have the roofer lay them out.

Anthony, to answer your question, I find the moire black shingles spotty and busy, and it calls too much attention to the roof. I much prefer a uniform color for a roof. That's just my opinion.

Diana - thxxxxx. 😌

Both options offer distinct advantages depending on the aesthetic you’re aiming for. Cinder Black provides a clean, modern contrast that makes the roof a standout feature without overpowering the rest of the design. It pairs well with the warm browns of your door and railings, adding a sophisticated balance. On the other hand, Moire Black leans toward a more traditional, craftsman-inspired look with its textured tones and softer finish. If you’re concerned about the roof blending too much into the siding, Cinder Black is a safe choice for contrast. However, if your goal is a cohesive and timeless design that complements the neighborhood’s style, Moire Black would be ideal.

I like a more uniform shingle color personally. I feel that you will never look at your roof and wish it was more busy but you might wish it wasn’t as busy if you go with a shingle with lots of contrast. Good luck on your project!

Anthony Elarth what color did you end up doing? We are down to the same two shingle colors.

We're also repainting our house a different color and have selected Ben Moore Soot.

Roofer has said that rarely does anybody here in our area do Cinder--we're across the water from you. He said it's almost all Moire for black tones, he said.

Curious what you chose and how you like it.