Thank you for your response. I worry that the galvanized wouldn’t match the aesthetic of the surrounding homes and could create a glare. I’m hoping to find a color that works well with the sailcloth siding.

IMO the house does not suilt galvanized meta and I like the green it works with the style and color of the house if that color is not available I think the old town gray

I think the Mocha Tan would compliment your siding color.

My house color looks similar to yours- an “ivory” which leans slightly yellow, especially in AM sunlight. Our metal roof is galvalume. It is very neutral, usually reads a soft grey, and is not shiny. I am posting pictures from this morning, and an older one from early evening. ( Hmm can’t attach all at once, will post today’s separately.)

This morning.

I'd vote for mocha, too. It goes well with your stone trim. If you think you might want to paint your house some other color, like blue in the future, then you might want to go with a neutral

like the burnished slate.