Are you painting everything that is now black?

of colors offered at Dulux Perma-Crete,

I would choose a light aqua like Cameo Green PPG 1147-1 or Rainsong PPG 1136-2 to compliment your stone work.

If you post a photo showing your roof color that would help

Exactly what areas are getting painted? Thanks for the clarification. Nice home.

Nice house. Trim here is a darkish taupe. I like the light ceiling color of the overhang, which will affect the color below the overhang. Think about orange door like this, which looks amazing.

Mid Century Modern Re-Visit · More Info

Grayish taupe like this garage door could work. You may have to try a few colors.

Mid-Century Mollica Front Landscape - Wauwatosa, WI · More Info

Think about more interesting, well designed landscaping: grasses, straight rows of shrubs.

Mid-Century Front Landscape - Fox Point, WI · More Info

@Lyn Nielson nothing is black. only brown. I do like the color you have suggested. thank you!

@thinkdesignlive I have attached some more information about the shingle color - thank you!

@Beerpocketbook Just the peach colored stucco. We didnt plan on paitning any of the brown, but are open to it (aside from the brown fascia which we woudlt need to replace). I haver attached more photos as well.

If that is the roof that is already on the home I’d suggest painting large foam core sheets in the 2 you are considering. This way you can move them around to be by the stone, roof, other elevations, etc. look at both on a cloudy day and a sunny day. You definitely don’t want to go too peachy and the aqua might be nice for a front door but definitely not all the painted stucco.

And I’m confused about the windows - some white /some black?

I think milk would be better. They both go well with the stone, but the Milk is a tad warmer and better match for your trim. That said, they are pretty similar and I'm sure you'd be happy with either.

And your garage is black too? I think you might have a more cohesive look if you went dark (not necessarily black but close - a warm charcoal) like the last image that housegal posted.

And all windows should be consistent.

Some visual with Urbane Bronze SW

or lighter

I would go with something like BM's Kendall Charcoal with touches of dark brown wood stain to relate to the brown roof.

Just read the roof is black, all the better! I suggested a wood front door (can be black or white or even a flashy colour) and a good stain job on the retaining planter wall.

@thinkdesignlive they are white PVC, but the exterior has brown wood trim as well. The large older windows in front are wood frame and painted brown. but this year they will be replaced with white as well

@thinkdesignlive and there is no black on the house. only brown. See attached for a closer look at the trim color. However - as I noted above, we are replacing this large window in the summer so the trim could be anything (but likely white to match the rest of the house)

@Celery. Visualization, Rendering images thank you for doing that. Both options look really good for sure.

Dark Charcoal Gray for stucco

Stain the landscape timbers

Gosh darn it I was hoping you’d say all the windows can be dark brown. Sigh.