Check out Reddit for some threads over there on the subject. I also suggest posting specifically on the plumbing reddit thread and asking plumbers there what they think of the products you are considering and how they hold up over time and what the implications are for repairs.

In my (limited) experience, chrome and polished nickel fixture finishes from a good manufacturer will have the most longevity in a bathroom.

Unlaquered brass is a living finish that will darken etc., especially with bathroom moisture. So while it’s lovely, you have to be okay with its changing look as it ages or commit to spending time cleaning/maintaining it.

Life is choice. I’d want a PVD finish on brass.

Chrome fixtures became available in the 1930’s …. and its 2025 and they’re still the least maintence. Most before that? Nickel.

You could consider polished nickel, a warmer tone than chrome and also be willing to accept the spotting and higher maintenance.

You know your tolerance:) and style is as suggestive of age as is finish.

A need for perfection , acceptable for maintainence is personal, and no other person is YOU.

Agree it’s personal taste - I don’t see chrome as sterile, I see it as classic and it adds bit of sparkle, which feels clean in a bath

FWIW, we’ve lived in 3 different homes built in the 20s and had chrome in all the baths with never any issues

Chrome. If you spend time cleaning the white haze of mineral deposits off your current kitchen or bath fixtures, you would spend even more time removing it from the unlacquered brass. Unlacquered brass is a good choice for hardware that does not get wet or, for that matter, exposed to the outdoors.

Why don't you consider chrome for your plumbing fixtures and bring your brass in with lighting, mirror etc?