No boarder, the lightest is the white tan charcoal pavers

Not the white tan charcoal but the the white tan

I agree with Lyn

What about between these 2 color pavers in the picture

Why are you not keeping all the existing pavers? The appearance is so much more interesting than what you are proposing. The gray/blue on your home was a poor choice IMO and all the Colonial details with doors and iron lanterns just adds to the architectural confusion of your home. I'd figure out a way to replace all those arched windows.

You're in Florida with a house that leans Mediterranean. I would capitalize on that style and select details that enhance that style.

You asked why we aren’t keeping the current pavers, so I wanted to explain our reasoning.

The pavers in the shower area of the pool are a mix of different pieces. We had to replace several broken ones in the past, and since matching replacements were no longer available, we used whatever we could find at the time. Because of that, the area now has an inconsistent look.

We’re also planning to add pavers to the equipment area, and it seemed like the right time to update the shower area as well for consistency. Since we still can’t find an exact match to the original pavers, we felt it would be better to choose something new that looks intentional and cohesive.

Additionally, the front of the house has tiles—some of which are broken—and we’d like all the exterior hardscape areas to follow a consistent style that complements the home.

We purchased the home a few months ago, and the previous owners had just painted it. We don’t want to change the exterior color right now, but we might consider it in the future. With that in mind, we’d appreciate your input on which paver color and style would work well now, and what exterior house color you would recommend for the future to keep everything cohesive.

Thank you,

Paint the house/stucco a soft white and pave the pool and walkways with the lightest, largest pavers available to you. Let the pool add the color and focal point.

That is beautiful, I love it! Can I keep my Owen Corning sand dune color roof ?

Find a light, single color paver that matches your "white" simple pool coping.

The ones you picked have too much color variations and won't look great with your current pavers.