I like the current colcr and would adjust it.

Don't cover the stone completely.

I removed the corbels, shutters, and window box to take some weight off and simplify.

No dark garage doors for the same reason.

Added a blue enamel front door.

Thank you-I appreciate the advice and your time!

White shutters, change the color on the gables to match the siding and limewash the stone.

Thank you! I was stuck on dark accents, but really like the look of the lighter color. Would a darker/medium tone garage door look ok with this or should it stay light?

Like this or darker?

I would say keep the stone base and paint or replace garage doors in a darker grey or muted grey-blue. Just my opinion!

I like the colors in your "like this or darker" post. I'd remove the shutters. You only have them on two windows, because they don't fit on most windows. I think your problem is a cool gray with a warmer stone. I think a color will look lighter than that gray.

Here is your home with and without a color on the garage doors.

The mockups showing the lightened stone look great.👍🏻

More mockups

I agree with Patricia that there are a lot of warm tones in your stone and they don't work with the cool gray. Even if you really want to limewash them, they're still going to be a bit warm. I would look at a greige like SW Mega Greige lightened by 25 or 50%. I'm definitely on board with removing the shutters. I have cream trim and my house is SW Mega Greige at 75%. I think you could paint your garage doors the same color as the siding.

Some inspro to go warm

or cooler and no shutters

Thank you all so much-this is extremely helpful!!

I like this one from @tracefloyd the best. I would consider a natural dark wood front door when you have the funds.

I like the mortar wash idea.

right now the gray w/the reddish stone and off white doors all clash w/each other.

I was going to suggest what celery did. Especially the dark garage doors. looks so much better

I am so impressed with the ideas and help! I cannot remove the shutters (the trim would need to be redone) I also cannot remove the corbels because the siding is constructed for them. I am leaning towards darker garage doors and lime washing the stone (it is too red for me). I think I will also have the corbels the light trim color and the garage door, flower box and shutters the darker color.
Thank you to everyone for all of the ideas & help!

Post a photo when it’s done.