Take a photo of your kitchen as it is. Looks like you aren't a minimalist, which is fine, but you might want to edit some things. I would need less visual clutter if it was my space.

What is motivating you to replace the ones you have? helps to know what you don’t like about the current set up

of the options shown, the first solid cone... it appears to be number 5.

definitely not an exposed bulb or a ball of light. The room is already very busy with the glass doors and window design. Keep it simple.

If keeping the chandelier, I chose #6.

If that’s a photo of your kitchen, I prefer what you already have.

For practical reasons no clear glass, too much glare & a PITA to keep clean

For practical reasons no clear glass, too much glare & a PITA to keep clean.

I like no. 1, the final photo. The globe shape echoes the sphere of the dining table chandelier, and the black metal does as well. No. 3 also has the black, but I think it could be too much when repeated three times. No. 6 is just right.

Seems like keeping a black metal finish would be necessary

The round shape of the globe reinforces the round shape of the chandelier.

The only issue is ......how large in diameter the globe light should be? 17" is too large for the pendants.

I prefer the solid cone for the same reason as Lyn. There's so much other movement in the room that the others just add to the busyness.

I think we all want to avoid adding busyness, but our perception of busyness varies. To my eye, add adding another shape and a shiny gold surface makes the solid cones more busy. There’s probably the beginnings of a lab study in psychology here! Meanwhile, it’s a very pretty kitchen and dining area.

Seeing the same kitchen with different pendants really shows how much the shape of the fixture can change the whole space. I’d focus on proportion and silhouette first — especially how the pendant relates to the island and the open space around it.

I recently explored 8 designer pendant lights with different shapes and visual effects. Since you’re already comparing options, you might find a few additional ideas worth considering before making your final choice:

https://youtu.be/nKEcEzpYHhk