Because everything is in shadow it's hard to make out the color of the brick and pavers. I don't like the Dijon at all. It's far too yellow and too bright.

I think you should pick up the color of your pavers.

I would like to see a deep but bright teal color on your doors. Something like Avalon Teal by Benjamin Moore.

I love Avalon Teal and I picked it after scrutinizing over color swatches. However, my BM retailer told me that’s only available in interior.

I found Loch Blue by SW. similar to Avalon Teal.

My home is a midwestern MCM ranch

It's a mid century ranch, but not MCM.

The front door is a one piece insert with left sidelights. The light trim of the windows is very obvious; the front door/sidelight is recessed and it is dark in there. I would paint the door/sidelight/trim the same color as the windows....so white. Keep in mind the sidelight is part of the door, visually and structurally.

Paint the downspout the color of the brick. It is a sore thumb as is.

What ever you decide for a color, paint the entire door, sidelight, frame the one color.

I didnt know that Avalon wasnt available in an exterior paint. Sorry. However, I do like the Loch blue, and yes, it is fairly close.

I think a medium blue like Summer Day would work well. A yellow like lion heart would work well, too.

Thanks everyone. I chose BM Dark Harbor