Software
Houzz Logo Print
allyde

Truly General Questions about Controversial Posts

6 hours ago

I just posted this on FOAS's thread about where's the thread - and realized since I'm looking for input from a lot of people, it would probably be smarter to make it stand out.


If you know me, you know I like a good verbal sparring every now and then. I don't generally hold a grudge if someone disagrees with me, and usually forget whatever the ruckus was about by the next day. I am also usually involved in most of the threads which seem to get disappeared about here. So I am as guilty as the next person.


I have been thinking about some of the broader discussions we've had on some of those contentious posts, and I am looking for input on 2 issues.


A. Whether our repeated flouting of the site's rules run a higher risk of them just shutting it all down?

  1. Yes I know any thread CAN turn contentious. But we all know what is almost guaranteed to start it, and no surprise it is the topics the powers that be have ixnayed.
  2. I like it here. I don't want to see this place shut down.
  3. There are other places to have deeper discussions, but it seems this place just isn't going to generally be it, for many reasons.

B. How many regulars wish we would just follow the site's rules? And if it is more than 1 or 2, does that matter?

  1. It does to me. It is why I struggled so with all the complaints about going off topic. I have tried harder to be respectful of not veering too wildly. That is hard for me. 😆 But it is a fair request, IMO.

I don't know, I am pondering it all FOR ME. I am not the boss of you. 😆


Ultimately I really like it here, don't want to see it shut down, and don't want my behavior to make other people suffer. So rather than continue to debate with myself, I thought I'd ask everyone here what you think.....


Lastly, please for the love of squirrels don't turn my truly general discussion about contention into something contentious. I am soliciting OPINIONS from everyone, because I am trying to decide whether to change MY behavior. That's it, that's all I'm trying to figure out here....

Comments (11)

  • 5 hours ago
    last modified: 5 hours ago

    What do I think? I think the same people start threads that are thinly-veiled attempts at political commentary or manage to make almost every.single.post about something (or someone) political, no matter how non-political the post started off being. It's tedious and frankly I don't want to hear it. Yes we can all scroll on by, but sometimes there are good discussions that get derailed because some people just can't help themselves and have to start with the political commentary. On some level I am surprised that the KT hasn't been shut down yet.

    Not related to the KT forum but the board in general, it is starting to get over-run by bots. It's getting worse week by week. I have noticed a lot less traffic on the Kitchens and Design Dilemma forums lately. IDK if it's because of the bots or declining interest in this type of internet chat board in general, but IMO it's only a matter of time until no-one is here anymore. It's happened to some other really great discussion boards -- this site is not immune.



    ETA: I spouted off without answering your questions...


    A. Whether our repeated flouting of the site's rules run a higher risk of them just shutting it all down?


    Yes.


    B. How many regulars wish we would just follow the site's rules? And if it is more than 1 or 2, does that matter?


    IDK exactly what the site's rules are about veering off-topic. Sometimes the road trip down the side road turns into a good discussion. My gripe is with the nonstop side-veers turning of everything political, which is my rant above.


    Ally De thanked porkchop_z5b_MI
  • 4 hours ago
    last modified: 4 hours ago

    I would enjoy and like to have regular deep conversations about certain non-political things-but a few ALWAYS take it to politics. I am thinking about changing my icon so I won't trigger so many people-even though I'm not "triggered" by others on here-maybe...just maybe we can have a really good conversation that doesn't involved the orange man LOL. Although, I still love him. But, y'all know that already.

    eta: But, to answer your question...yes, I do think the more this happens on here...we are at risk of losing the forums. The political reactions on here...is a great excuse for Houzz to "table"-no pun intended-The Kitchen Table especially, if not all.

    Ally De thanked OllieJane
  • 3 hours ago

    OJ, from what I've read here, you mostly seem to post in threads where you *can* add a political spin. Your hat doesn't trigger me--wear it with the pride you feel in doing so. But when I question some of your statements, you rarely respond. That in itself doesn't offend me, but to claim that others always go to politics, and not you, isn't what I read from the majority of your posts at all.

    My frustration is when I personally invest time and thought in a discussion that then gets pulled. I wanted to go back to Annie's original thread where I was exchanging perspectives with others, and I find it's gone. That's a waste of my time.

    But what I really don't understand is why people can't just scroll on by. I don't have a vested interest in every discussion here because much of it either doesn't relate to me, or I have nothing to say. So... I scroll on by.

  • 3 hours ago
    last modified: 3 hours ago

    Feathers, you seem to have ODS-OllieJane Derangement Syndrome. I do post on threads that start out as not political-but then if someone-or someone by the time I read it-as made it political THEN sometimes I join in with "political" talk. I never start it. I make a point to NOT START it! If a thread goes political-I do feel free to chime in at that time, on some subjects if I choose to do so. So there. Get me out of your head please-because you are one of a few that always have something very negative to post TO ME on most everything I post-and a lot of nasty things to write and ask of me...I DO scroll on by...and I mostly ignore you. P.S. I do think the red hat triggers you.

  • 3 hours ago

    Oh for Pete's sake, the exchanging of barbs is starting on this thread too.


    Just **stop it already** --- ALL OF YOU!

  • 3 hours ago

    OllieJane, have you given much thought as to why you would want to trigger people you are trying to form an online friendship with?

  • 3 hours ago
    last modified: 3 hours ago

    I think posters here have different objectives, and fostering friendship isn't necessarily the goal of everyone. I play the NYT games daily but I share my results with family members. I don't feel a need to share here. I sometimes have a cooking question, and the cooking folks are helpful. This is a pasttime for me, and I occasionally gain some wisdom and knowledge from others that make it worth my time once in a while. But I'm not seeking friendship in a forum in which I'll never likely meet any of you in person. Others may have very different incentives for being here.

    When threads turn controversial, I'll participate if I have something to share, I'll read if I'm interested in the topics, or I'll scroll on by if it's nothing I want to read.

    OJ, you flatter yourself. :-)

  • 1 hour ago

    I see a lot of "tit for tat" behavior happening here. And yes, I'm guilty of that. I'm going to do better. It's unfortunate that a few need to personally attack others, then defend / explain why they did. No one cares why someone does that, it's rude and obnoxious.

    If we all make a vow to restrain ourselves from those kind of comments that personally attack others, that kind of behavior will become less frequent. Those that do that won't get the fight they're looking for and will hopefully stop. It's okay to have a difference of opinion but to attack, denigrate, or disparage others is what makes a thread spiral.

    So I'm vowing to not engage in comments like that.

  • 1 hour ago

    I am trying figure out why I keep coming here. I think I enjoy the conversations and photos and the majority of the people contributing. It is difficult to keep conversations light and fluffy with everything that is going on the world. Sometimes topics get heated.


    I still disagree with flagging people and their posts. In my opinion, if you are so disturbed by someone’s opinion that you need to silence it, this is probably not the place for you. It is an anonymous forum!


    I can also understand the desire to run someone off who repeatedly insults people but would you want a bully running you off? Can’t we try to be grown ups? I am working on my words and my judgement. I hope to get better and better as I age.


    I do have one request though.


    Please, please, please… Stop calling people with different opinions deranged.

  • 12 minutes ago

    I'm in agreement with keeping things civil and I hope the flagging of posts/threads stops.

Sponsored
Hope Restoration & General Contracting
Average rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars35 Reviews
Columbus Design-Build, Kitchen & Bath Remodeling, Historic Renovations