Those are old pictures of the house.

New window

Oatmeal for your stucco. Then I would add a nice stone planter in front.

The stucco and the wood under the stucco were in very bad condition so we had to take it down.

Just to clarify, you are getting cement siding? I think you should drive around the neighborhood and see if any house colors are appealing to you. Grays are popular right now.

Sorry, Oatmeal for your siding. It's going to look great! I would add a beautiful Lompoc flagstone walkway from your front door to your drive way. Do a natural, soft winding shape.

The style of your bungalow makes me want to suggest a classic craftsman tone - an earthy / camoflauge green neutral - great with the white windows and eaves, but warm enough to work well with the beautiful brick. Here's one http://www.benjaminmoore.com/en-us/paint-color/raintreegreen
I always think that stucco looks best in a tone that could be a real stone - this one is really nice with the new windows - use a match for the windows for your fascia eaves and braces and then a deeper shade of the same green around the doors and windows - like this http://www.benjaminmoore.com/en-us/paint-color/armygreen
and then a red front door keyed to the brick - cheerful and welcoming . . .

If you like the oatmeal tone idea, go warm like bm richmond gray - too light and an oatmeal looks like a dirty white - on outdoor - going one tone deeper usually works well . . .

Love your eave hips! My home is a new craftsman. I did oatmeal colour for my siding, stucco, and garage door and then a little darker for my facia and eave hips and French doors in the back garden. Then dark wood door. It made the house look larger and clean. I used the Lompoc flagstone on my courtyard wall and pillars along side the garage door. It's a great colour scheme. Whatever you decide , it will turn your already darling home into a gorgeous one! Congrats!

I would think you want those great windows to be noticeable, so shouldn’t the siding be lighter than the windows?

This is one AWESOME ! looking house.