I would go with a dark blue or dark sage green

Agree with something that relates to 'nature' for the siding color given the setting of the house.

Are there any red houses close by?

I love the colors in this A-frame: deep brown red with light sage, looks like an olive brown on the window and door trim and dark brown on the wood posts.

If you have stain on your house now keep the stain. You can get semi-solid or solid stain in just about any color from Benjamin Moore.

This is an attractive pine green: Although I would do the trim in a dark red or dark brown. Dark brown in the deck.

No, there are no red houses nearby. A beige brick next door and the rest is golf course and all sides.

Thanks everyone for their color ideas and specific paint names. Really great options.

Sorry, one more. :) Ben Moore Copley Gray with Elephant Tusk Trim; brown roof, pitched gable.

I vote red. Without the additional colors shown.