I'm trying to choose a backsplash tile so that I can pick a paint color and get this kitchen finished! Still some details that need to be finished up…paint, recessed lights, corbels on island, etc.

I have narrowed it down to three…two of which fit the bill of what I was originally looking for…glossy, lighter tone, crackle tile. The other is more of a natural look that provides more contrast. I want it to be warm and would like to avoid being too matchy. The darkest tile matches the darkest grays in the counter, the gray crackle matches some of the other grays, and the taupey crackle tile matches some of the beige/taupe color in the counter which is hard to see in photos.

I have soft white perimeter cabinets, gray stained island, calacatta quartzite counters, and a brown wood floor. I'm providing a pic of the whole kitchen and some close ups so that you can get some perspective…