Software
Houzz Logo Print
laska_leo

Is this backsplash too busy?

12 years ago
We are in search for our new backsplash. Main goal is to find something that complements our granite (called Hawaii), and tie in the grey floor with the rest of the space.
We have found a mosaic that in our minds was just perfect. We love how it picks up all of the colors from the counter - gray, dark greay, creme, and shiny gold - and also loved how the square shape coordinates with the square stone-like floor tiles.
However, when asking around for opinions, we have repetitively heard the same feedback over and over again: too busy. Some of the suggestions that our friends made were to use this mosaic as a strip/accent tile, and find something more neutral as a main backsplash.
Off the store again... We've visited every shop in town, and got a few quite contradictory opinions. Some were pushing for onyx (did not like because it looks too yellow next to our honey maaple cabinets), others for travertine (does not seem to be the right combination with the counter). After a dozen of rejected samples, we are back to the drawing board and want to ask for opinions in the talented Houzz community.
Is this backsplash REALLY that busy? Should we go ahead and install this beauty, or keep on searching?
Thanks!

Comments (29)

  • 12 years ago
    I don't think it's too busy as your granite isn't that busy, and I think the colors work well together.

    The thing about putting in a backsplash, floor or choosing a paint color is that different people will hold different opinions so you have to go with what suits you and your family. You need to be happy with what you go with so that you'll like your kitchen. I'm amazed at the number of dilemmas on here where people go with what they're supposed to so the room will have a certain look, and then don't know why they aren't happy with it. I can tell them in one sentence--the room doesn't reflect their personality or tastes. Don't make that mistake.
  • 12 years ago
    I don't think it is too busy. I think colors work well with granite.
  • 12 years ago
    I would put the backsplash I liked and not be concerned with other people's opinions. You are the person who is going to live in your house for years and don't need to please anyone else. It's a personal decision of what pleases you and what you want to see when you come into the kitchen in the morning to make breakfast or coffee. The decision is not for someone visiting who may only be in your kitchen for a few hours. At this point you don't need to consider what other people like unless you are selling the house. Your house should please you and if you love it go for it.
  • 12 years ago
    The colors are good, but I do think it's busy. It will certainly become what the eye sees if you put it in. The countertop will be secondary.
  • 12 years ago
    It's perfect. The crisp dark brown in the tile and countertop contrast well with the soft pink wall color. And I'm usually a cool color person.
  • 12 years ago
    I agree with others that your colors match nicely. I used a similar but even busier mosaic with my laminate counter. Some friends love it, others think it's too busy, but I'm happy with it. The appearance changes quite a bit once it's grouted. Be sure to have your installer do a detached sample beforehand so that you can run out for different color grout if necessary, or even abort if you really don't like the look. Also, if the white pieces are stone, as mine were, they should be sealed before grouting unless your grout is very close to the same color. My chocolate brown grout stained them badly in the sample, so I was able to get them sealed in time.
  • 12 years ago
    If you want your granite countertops to be the focal point in your kitchen, I would not use this backsplash tile because it will dominate your kitchen. You might want to use a small tumbled subway tile in a neutral shade with a stripe of these tiny tiles to
    add interest. Your granite is very attractive, so I would not choose a busy tile to compete with it.
  • 12 years ago
    I'd like the first kitchen posted by RE3Designs better without any of the accent. Just the light colored base tile in the backsplash is beautiful.
  • 12 years ago
    Did the retailer have complimentary sized tiles? Something interesting like a Versailles pattern with smaller squares being the mosaic could be interesting. Keep in mind, the smaller the tile the more grout you will need. Also, the smaller scale is less forgiving in level grout lines.
  • 12 years ago
    Kinda sorta like this http://houzz.com/photos/311129
  • 12 years ago
    I think the colors work, but a bit too busy. Perhaps the same colors but a larger tile of some type. Per:
    Palos Park Kitchen Renovation · More Info
  • 12 years ago
    Personally I think it's too busy. But if you like it, why not print of several sheets (like 10) of the pic you posted above and see what it looks like? It won't be exact, but it will give you a better feel for what it will look like in the end.

    I think the granite is beautiful and I wouldn't want to take away from that. I would go with a tumbled stone subway tile in a color that is similar to the floor.
  • 12 years ago
    Too busy
  • 12 years ago
    Too busy! Your granite is very pretty. Don't take away from it. Bedrosians has a decorative gray stone which you might want to give a try. This stone will give you a soft polish look.

    They have a glass one too but it is not showing on their website. I used one on one of my projects (Hidden) which you can view on my FB as my website is under construction. Using glass will give you a contemporary look.

    As a realtor too...your kitchen is what sells your house. Don't throw money down the drain. Might be worth getting a professional involved for an hours advice. You will save yourself lots of money down the road and you will be happy you did.

    Best of luck.
  • 12 years ago
    How
  • 12 years ago
    Sorry--I dropped the phone before I finished typing and it submitted.

    How much of the backsplash are you planning on installing? The entire area from countertop to cabinet or just 4-6 inches? If it is the entire area, I think it will be a very strong statement. If it is a smaller strip, I think it coordinates with your colors well.

    Also, it will look different grouted. It might be worth buying a sample sheet and grouting it to see what it will look like finished.
  • 12 years ago
    Thanks guys! I think we'll buy a few more samples of this one and see if we still like it as much, when there is a lot of it. Will explore the tumbled stone as well. Thanks, everyone have a great weekend!
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    I agree that either the counter or the backsplash should be the focal point, not both. In this case both of your choices are lovely, but on their own. The more classic the backsplash, the easier it is to live with long term and also remain more timeless. I would bring home tons of samples until you are sure, given that you are doubting your choice. You should feel 100% that it's perfect.
  • 12 years ago
    You will look at them every day, so if you love them, go for it. However, as they are quite distinctive, anything you put on your counter for display will be lost, and then it will look messy and busy. I do like them!
  • 12 years ago
    I had a similar problem. Everything I liked was too busy. I used it as a focal point surrounded by subway tile.
  • 12 years ago
    It is a lot of pattern happening right next to each other. Why not use just a ribbon of the tile as an accent with a solid color larger format tile?
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Yes very much toooo busy!
  • 12 years ago
    The colours in the mosaic look good but it would be too busy for me against your counters. It becomes too much of a focal point for me.
  • 12 years ago
    As others have noted, the mosaic colors match your granite beautifully. You have also gotten great advice to do a sample grout board as grout color can really change the overall appearance.

    Hambirg's suggestion to make color copies so you can see a really large dose is outstanding. I would also search Houzz for multiple pics of these counter-to-cabinet mosaic backsplashes. If you have anything other than a very positive reaction to that look I would continue your search for a different backsplash.
  • 12 years ago
    Good point about the counter-to-cabinet installation. My mosaic (above) is just a 15 cm (6") strip, essentially between two solids as the counter only has tiny flecks of copper.
  • 12 years ago
    I don't think it's it's to much, but dont know size of area? A safe choice would to do what was suggested. Use mosaic as a center run. Then do rest In Tumbled travertine. Timeless.
  • 10 years ago

    I don't think it's too busy.

  • 10 years ago
    Old post from 2014.