*** For reference, my bedding is a mix of dark gray, light gray and navy.

How about mirrored nightstands?

andj32 thanks for your comment. I have only seen a handful of mirrored nightstands that I have liked.. overall, Im not a huge fan. Its too "much" for me... for lack of a better word

I did the same thing, intentionally not ordering the nightstands, a long time ago, and lived to regret it, lol, as it was not that easy to find nightstands after the fact.

I was just on the crate and barrel website, so here are a few from there You will need to determine what height works best. If you have access to the size of the ones that were part of that set, see what height they were, as a guideline. I would recommend staying with something dark, given what you already have, although many will probably disagree with that.

Black, graphite...or go for color pop.

Smiley in person the wood is not that dark.. my ceiling fan is a few shades darker though and I do like the way they look together, so Ive considered a dark wood. River Valley any thoughts on color? I don't want to overwhelm the room with too much blue and gray.

I also like Bespoke Fine Interior's idea of driftwood color.

paint some stands navy.