Software
Houzz Logo Print
gardenerme_gw

Another Soil Question for St. Al Tapla

17 years ago

Al:

I am using your gritty mix with amazing success. My seeds are sprouting like crazy, the root balls of these tiny seedlings are huge, and the plants that have already been repotted in your mix are soooooooo happy.

I also rootpruned an evergreen Duranta "Golden Mound". I took 1/3 off the bottom of the soil ball, cut 3 wedges out of the side, refilled as much as possible with gritty mix, shaped the top, and waited for it to wilt and sulk and drop leaves. It didn't! It is very green and healthy! Yay! My first root pruning on an evergreen and it went perfect!

Now a new issue. I have some plants that love water and are declining in their old mixes, which are water soaked and totally compacted: Brugmansia, Red Banana etc. If they get dry they wilt terribly and all are sort of tropical shade lovers with big leaves so the transpiration rate is fast. When I repot, which I must do, will they do OK in your mix? Should I modify it to hold more moisture? Maybe just turface?

Thanks to you and anyone else that can help me. I can't wait for spring when all the repotted plants should take right off. Of course, right now it is 76 degrees outside and spring may begin next month . . . ahhhhhhhhhhhhhh California!

Comments (18)

  • 17 years ago

    I grow brugs in the ground here in MI - bananas, too. I think I'm the only gardener around with a 'tropical bed'.

    The bananas I treat as annuals, well - I guess the brugs are treated that way, too. In mid summer, I start next year's brug cuttings & overwinter the cuttings for planting the next year when the soil warms. Occasionally, I carry over a whole plant or two I didn't plant out (have 2 of those this year), and I can say that the root systems grow extremely fast/aggressively. In fact, they need repotting so often, that it's probably a waste of $ to use the gritty mix. ..... then you have the water retention thing, too.

    You certainly CAN use the gritty mix, and you CAN increase the water retention by upping the Turface component, but if you were asking for a recommendation, I'd say don't bother - even if you're willing to put forth the extra effort to water more often - use the 5:1:1 mix or something close. The brugs would probably do just fine in a commercially bagged soil (did I really say that?) because of their fondness for moisture.

    Al

  • 17 years ago

    OK, that's what I thought, but I really wanted to keep using the gritty mix to get the HUGE root growth. Ah well, in the desert here the air is so dry that the big leafed plants really need some help.

    Thanks so much for all you do for us acolytes. You have turned me into a science-lover and I never thought that would happen!

  • 17 years ago

    Nerd alert - nerd alert!!! Lolol I love the sciences and I'm glad you're feeling inspired.

    I guess I should be careful, hmm? - maybe shouldn't assume everyone is my pal (learned that from my silly dog) and will automatically figure the nerd thing was something good natured. It was. ;o)

  • 17 years ago

    Thank you . . . I work at it . . .

  • 17 years ago

    Al, I almost spit my coffee out when I began to read: "The brugs would probably do just fine in a commercially bagged soil..." but then I read the rest of that sentence, and chuckled instead! I love your sense of humor! :-)

    I'm really pleased to read about the success of others using your medium mix. It reinforces my own thoughts on the medium. Every single plant or bulb that I have potted in your mix is doing well. Every single one. That's amazing to me. I'm even thinking of re-potting my Cimbidium into the same mix. It needs re-potting, so why not? The bark it's currently in dries out way too fast in the dry heat of my apartment.

    While I wouldn't necessarily say I have a huge interest in science, I will say that you've made it easier for me to understand. I don't mind science, as long as it's easy to grasp and not too technical, and you have a very good way of making it easy to learn. Armed with the answers I now have to the science part of gardening, I'm doing much better at it... and that makes it even more fun!

    Happy Gardening!

  • 17 years ago

    Try Chocolate Tea. It's so good you'd never even entertain the possibility of spitting it out. Copy paste the address to your browser: http://www.harney.com/chocolatetea.html
    You'll need to cope with the fact that it's loose (a tea ball), but Mmmmmm it's good.

    Now I have to figure out a way to get back on topic so Gardenerme doesn't grow weary of my ramblings. ;o) I do kind of enjoy the departure from pedantics & find it fun to jabber away, though.

    I guess I'm fortunate enough to have a fair amount of factual info at my disposal, but I think the real blessing comes from an ability to apply the info. That's what I try to do when I write here - give you info that you can apply - not just forget or store in the archives. ;o)

    I've been realizing lately that I rarely depart from the 'teacher' mode. I think that probably seems presumptuous to some, and for the same 'some', goes against the grain, but my heart is in the right place, and that allows me to be mostly unconcerned about it. I'm not hear for the 'atta boys' and pats on the back, but they are appreciated.

    What really keeps me coming back are threads like this one. The 'St. Al' thing is embarrassing, but I know it's offered tongue-in-cheek and purposely over the top. It's the 'success' that you and Gardenerme talk about that thrills me; and it's not because it makes me feel special or puffy - it makes me feel like my efforts here have helped someone toward a better growing experience. That's my reward. ;o)

    Now back to the mix. It works so well because the consistent particle size of the Turface and granite allows a fair amount of leeway in the particle size of the organic component. Within reason, good aeration and drainage is guaranteed, while the 2/3 organic component guarantees structural stability and overall longevity.

    I had used the gritty mix for hundreds of plants long before I started talking about it on any forum, so I knew it was a keeper. It IS a fairly radical departure from what most of you are used to, so it took a fair amount of convincing to get a few to use it. I can say though, that the only negative comments I've heard have been from those who have never tried it, choosing instead to stand on the periphery of our conversations throwing stones. ;o)

    The keys to why I like it:

    It's adjustable for water retention.

    The ingredients are readily available to me.

    It's simple - 3 basic ingredients - equal portions.

    It allows nearly 100% control over the nutritional regimen.

    It will not collapse - lasts longer than what is prudent between repots.

    It is almost totally forgiving of over-watering while retaining good amounts of water between drinks.

    It gets good reviews. Lol

    I'm sure I forgot a few, but it has served me well for a long time & I'm very glad you guys are pleased with it.

    Thank you.

    Al


  • 17 years ago

    If somebody can parody the dixie land lyrics of St. James Infirmary for Senor Tapla the Vatican might not realize he is still with us.
    Otherwise the best this forum can do is to petition the Bonsai Emperor to accept him into the Royal Order of Masakuni Sprayers.
    Just don't expect your plants to turn away from the sun, either way.

  • 17 years ago

    Funny you should mention chocolate tea... I just happen to have some here that I've been saving... I may have to break it out! I'm just so used to guzzling pot after pot of Folgers that I never think about it!

    Personally, I'm glad that you're in teacher mode most of time... when here, I'm in student mode, which makes for a good forum experience! The best part is that the teachings are not on Dead Sea Scrolls that require translation... meaning, I can easily understand and retain the knowledge, and I don't need a Bachelor's Degree in Science to do so!

    I know you're not here to get pats on the back, but don't be surprised when you get them, anyway! You're doing us novice gardeners a great service, and we do appreciate it.

    Al, there are naysayers for every subject and idea, and I suspect there always will be. For some reason I can't fathom, some are most happy when they're trying to make others miserable. It seems to me an empty and lonely way to go through life, but we can't please all the people all the time, and that's just reality. Common sense and logic are not givens within our society, unfortunately!

    Know this: you have helped more than will ever stand at that periphery throwing stones... my advice is to just duck and keep on teaching! We're listening, your apt pupils!

    Yesterday, I re-potted a waning Christmas Cactus and a pot-bound Night Blooming Cereus into clay pots... using your mix, of course... and I swear they look happier today! Based on actual results since I've begun using Al's Mix, I'd like to extend another pat on the back! I'm pleased, and more importantly, so are my bulbs and plants!

    The days are finally getting longer, seed catalogs are rolling in, and it's almost time to dig back in and begin anew the quest for the healthiest and most beautiful gardens and container plants... I'm off to continue my wish list for spring...

    Happy Gardening!

  • 17 years ago

    DITTO for me too Jodik!

    I have two christmass cactus, and the one I did not find the time to pot in Al's mix looks like.... everyday!

    The other in Als' gritty 1 1 1 mix perked up right away. It stopped dropping soft wrinkly, almost sqashy sections of leaves,mixed with dehydrated ones, and the sections are always firm, unlike the other still potted in potting soil with collasped hard feeling peat in it. You know what potting soil feels like when you can't even push your finger through it to see if it is even wet. I wonder how the roots of that poor thing are suppose to even move through that pot. I will have to do emergency transplant as soon as I have time,and pot into Al's mix for this one too..
    I just brought those home from work, and they had only been growing in regular potting soil for a little over a year!
    Everytime I am looking around, when I see a sickly plant, I realize that I forgot to change over to the better gritty mix.. I never realized how many plants I really have..WOW:-)

    Thanks Al! No stones here..:-)

  • 17 years ago

    To the Louis Armstrong beat:

    I scrolled down to St. Tapla's posting
    Found my soil formula there
    Filling up a big container
    So sweet ... so cold ... so fair

    Let it grow, let it grow , god bless it
    Whatever it may be
    You can look the wide web over
    But never find the man like he

    When I die want you to water weakly weekly
    I wanna fast draining soil
    Put a Masakuni sprinkler on my garden hose
    So the boys'll know that I died standin' flat

  • 17 years ago

    Oh brother (rolls eyes)! You guys have way too much time on your hands - prolly cabin fever closing in, hmm? ... but thank you very much. It made me grin.

    Trees outstrip most people in the extent and depth of their work for the public good. ~Sara Ebenreck

    I guess I just never really felt like being a tree. ;o)

    PS I really do know the difference between 'here & hear', in spite of the error upthread (rolls eyes again & looks a little sheepish).

    Al

  • 17 years ago

    I still have several plants requiring re-potting into Al's Mix... but I have no doubt as to their health and happiness once I do so. The ones that have already been re-potted are showing marked improvement, and that tells me a lot about what I'm doing now vs. what I was doing.

    Looking at the whole thing from a plant's perspective, I think I'd prefer my shoes to fit properly, with a bit of wiggle room... and I'd like my socks to be comfortable and breathable.

    We are getting cabin fever, I think! This is the time of year when looking at the seed and plant catalogs for the hundredth time is not enough! With either spring or stir crazy just around the corner, I'm hoping for spring!

  • 17 years ago

    I have a question as well. Maybe I'm missing something, but if both the Turface and the pine fines are in the mix to hold moisture, but the pine fines will biodegrade eventually, why are they there? Do they perform another function?

  • 17 years ago

    It (pine bark) DOES help to lower o/a media pH of the gritty mix. I grow many plants in nothing but Turface & it works just fine. I use the gritty mix because it will remain almost forever stable, structurally. Since the bark component is only 1/3 of the overall volume, when/as it breaks down it doesn't destroy the porosity of the mix. That it breaks down so slowly is also a big plus. A major consideration might be that pine bark by volume is probably around 1/10-1/15 the price of Turface, so it makes good economic sense as well.

    Lol - almost no one believed me at first, when I touted how favorably plants react to the mix. It's hard enough to sell the idea that a mix with only a 1/3 organic component would even work, let alone one with NO organics in it. ;o)

    Even though the bark degrades eventually, it will still be around in the mix LONG after it would have been prudent to repot the planting.

    Al

  • 17 years ago

    It's not difficult for me to believe at all. Over the last two years, I've seen what compaction does to potted plants. I've grown plants hydroponically, and your mix seems very similar to the substrates used there. My main concern is with how quickly it will dry out. Where I live, it can get over 100 F in the summer and I am gone 10-11 hours during the day. Can you make any recommendations?

  • 17 years ago

    You could increase the Turface and decrease the granite. Maybe something like:
    3 parts pine bark
    4 parts Turface
    1 part crushed granite
    1 part vermiculite

    Al

  • 17 years ago

    I was under the impression that you weren't a fan of vermiculite do to its small particle size. Did you add it in for water-holding purposes?

  • 17 years ago

    Yes - it doesn't present much of a problem if you keep its presence in this soil to around 10%. It's not a coincidence that the ratio of ingredients in the recipe I offered was manipulated so the vermiculite only constitutes 11% of the soil's total volume.

    Al

Sponsored
The Creative Kitchen Company
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars52 Reviews
Columbus Area Kitchen Remodeling and Refacing Professional