Software
Houzz Logo Print
sudimari

Another soil question...sorry...specifcs given I hope

17 years ago

Okay, I am totally out of my league with the soil issue. I am on an extremely tight budget. Will be growing a dozen, maybe 2 dozen medium-large containers of various flowering plants. In the past I've used basic MG potting mix, but I have had issues with it either being too wet or last year due to watering issues in my new location (which I think I found a solution too in another forum)drying out too completely then not retaining the water.

My first thought was to take what is left in the pots with the dead plants in it and reuse it. I'll still need more, but I have no idea if I need to amend the old stuff and what to buy new.

I attempted to read the Container Soil thread but my eyes started glazing over (due to insulin reaction more than content) and I realized quickly I don't have space (or money) to get the ingredients (not to mention what the heck is pine bark fines?!)and probably not the energy to do it up correctly.

What is the bare minimum I need to look for on a bag of soil/mix? I'd also like to avoid big market fertilizers (truthfully in the past I rarely fertilized...only keeping plants 1 year) but figure if I'm using old soil it'll need something. I have some really OLD (several years, maybe 5-6) containers of MG fertilers (one 10-52-10 and one 18-24-16) but I am assuming they go bad after being opened at some point...in which case I guess I should find the proper way to dispose of them.

Most of my containers will be sitting directly on the concrete patio so water drains out, saturates the patio and overflows into the mulched, so called landscape border around the patio. I did see something about wicking to better ensure draining...what kind of material would be good for that?

Thanks in advance...I know this is one of those topics that has been covered over and over again, but with my daily cluster headaches I'm finding it impossible to get through the searching and come out of it with anything. Also I see the abbreviation HD in posts a lot...is that Home Depot? (I kind of figured MG is Miracle Gro).

Suz

Comments (6)

  • 17 years ago

    I will let others advise you on what some of the better store bought mixes are as I haven't used any in years. It is primarily air porosity that you are concerned about in a mix along with water retention. It is a balancing act between the two. Here is a link to an article that discusses this. It is a bit shorter than the excellent thread Tapla has here so hopefully your headaches will leave you alone long enough to get through it.

    I explained in your thread about Morning Glories why I think mixing the old mix with new mix is counter productive so won't rehash that here.

    Wicking is an excellent way to partially compensate for mixes that hold too much water and not enough air. Since you have had problems finding stuff with the search function I will direct link and here too.

    Your fertilizer is likely to still be fine, but I wouldn't bother using any fertilizer where the middle number is the highest. Of the two you have I would prefer the 18-24-16 over the 10-52-10. I won't get into specifics as to why unless you really want to know in which case read this.

    Good growing to you this season.

  • 17 years ago

    Not much I can add, so I'll just agree & reinforce what JaG said. I think the 10-52-10 and the 18-24-16 are both too high in P to be a good choice for anything but a P deficient garden soil and are counter-productive for containers.

    Hopefully you'll find something in the wicking thread to help. Too bad you don't have room for a bag of pine bark fines and a little perlite. You could prolly use those to help you build a very good soil from what you have already.

    HD = Home Depot
    MG = Miracle-Gro
    GLTYS = Good Luck To You, Suz ;o)

    Al

  • 17 years ago

    Thank you fellas! I really thought I posted last night, but I guess the pain med played with my memory...I hit a wrong key or something!

    I've decided to Freecycle the fertilizer...just get rid of it and let someone else use it!

    The more I read and understand...making my own "soil" doesn't sound terribly complicated...and as far as space I have to clean out, reorganize the storage "closet" off the back patio to get my gardening gear organized and make room for potting mix bags...so working around space for what 3 or 4 bags/containers and a mixing container to work with shouldn't be too overwhelming as long as I can find smallish quantities of ingredients (no small feat from what I'm hearing!)

    Wicking...I totally get and am looking forward to trying! But I do have a few of questions...since most of my containers sit on the concrete do I need to find a way to move them up an inch or two for the wick to come out? Will the wick need to dangle over the edge of the patio to the mulched area since normal drainage will keep the concrete wet for a few hours? Am I right that if I use pre-made potting mix, the wick can stay in for the entire season, unless it disintegrates in which I replace it?

    Now the ingredients I'm looking for are?

    1)Pine Bark Fines (what IS this? How is it labelled? Where do I look for it? I'm getting the understanding it is NOT mulch... Any rough ideas on how much to buy to start off?)
    2)perlite...again what is this? where do I look for it? Approx what sizes does it come in? Any rough ideas how much to buy?
    3)Peat...NOT peat moss?
    4)Dolomite Lime...small container...seems to me I've come across dolomite in some retail situation in the past 35 years of working...is it availabe in nutritional supplements? or maybe it was just in one of those big box stores I worked in.

    I called the closest nursery to me yesterday..didn't sound like he had the ingredients but he had something I wanted to get more info on, so I may have questions about that later.

    Once mixed can this mixture be stored long-term? Does it need to be temp protected? Air tight? Does it break down during storage or is that only a watering process?

    You might regret not just telling me to buy MG and be done with it! LOL

    Suz

  • 17 years ago

    "since most of my containers sit on the concrete do I need to find a way to move them up an inch or two for the wick to come out?" That works best, yes. If the wick dangles in a puddle, it doesn't work as well - unless the water is free to flow away from the container. "Will the wick need to dangle over the edge of the patio to the mulched area since normal drainage will keep the concrete wet for a few hours?" Your call, but it would be helpful if the wick was in contact with soil under the container. "Am I right that if I use pre-made potting mix, the wick can stay in for the entire season, unless it disintegrates in which I replace it?" It CAN, but you'll probably find that as the planting matures and uses more water, that you'll appreciate the additional water-holding ability that removing the wick altogether affords.

    1) You'll find PB fines labeled as many different things - mulch, soil conditioner, composted pine bark, ..... You'll need to look at it to determine whether or not it's a good choice.

    2) Perlite - white - nonporous, except on the surface - made by expanding a light mineral. Do a search for more info if you need it. It's very common in most container soils.

    3) Sphagnum peat. Comes in a cubical bale (usually). Not MI (reed/sedge) peat or peat moss (the whole sphagnum moss).

    4) Look for 'garden lime' or 'dolomitic lime' comes in small bag by Espoma or really big bags in the fertilizer display area of most big box stores or farm supply places. It should mention on the bag that it's a source of both Ca AND Mg.

    Yes, you can store it long term if you want. Store it dry if you don't want it to break down further and moist if you do. Allow some air to the bag if you store it in a bag.

    Al

  • 17 years ago

    You can leave the wick in all season, but if you make the 5-1-1 mix (mostly pine bark fines) you aren't likely to need it. If you use MG potting mix you may or may not wish to use it the first season. If you reuse the mix you have on hand you will absolutely want to use it. The wick simply helps compensate for mixes holding too much water, it helps pull water out of the saturated, soggy layer of mix.

    Given your containers are on the patio I would suggest using whatever you have on hand to elevate them an inch or so. I typically use wooden stakes that are approx 12" long and 1" thick. I have a bunch on hand, but most anything will work. I think you will find that your patio doesn't stay wet too long, particularly in the summer so it should be fine if the wick is in contact with the cement, but you are correct that it's value is limited when it is sitting on/in water.

    Pine bark fines are often sold as soil conditioner. sometimes 'aged pine bark'. Check your nearby big box stores first and if you strike out there post back with your general location and it's likely there is another forum member nearish you who knows of a source.

    Perlite is a common potting mix ingredient. It's the light weight, white 'pebbles' in your MG mix. It is used primarily for aeration.

    Peat is sphagnum peat moss, should be available darn near anywhere.

    How much to get of each depends on how much you need ;) You will want 5 times as much bark as perlite or peat. All these ingredients will be sold in 1 cubic foot bags or larger. One cubic foot of mix will fill a 5 gallon bucket with some left over. Hopefully that helps you get a feel for how much you need to buy based upon the size and number of containers you will fill.

    Dolomite lime is often labeled as such and sometimes as agricultural lime. Just flip the bag over and look to see if it has both calcium and magnesium listed. That is what you want. If it only lists calcium, it is not what you want. Also stay away from hydrated lime. It can be used, but is much stronger and very caustic. Not something you want to work with on a windy day.

    You can store the mixes, yes. To avoid their breaking down prematurely try to keep them away from water. Wouldn't worry much about temp protection or air tightness. You might regret not just telling me to buy MG and be done with it! LOL

    Not at all. While making one's own mix can seem confusing at first and locating the ingredients can sometimes be a pain, it is always worth it to see another person report back how pleased they were with their results and to see first hand how much better they can do for their plants than just buying a store bought mix.

  • 17 years ago

    Let me reinforce the good advice given above and definitely raise your containers off the concrete to keep them cooler.

    I used to use leftover wooden stakes from concrete forms, but now I use leftover knockout tabs from a concrete block wall I built - they are smaller, stronger, don't stay wet, and catch less stuff blowing around underneath - and that makes fewer critters for the MIL to complain about.

    And definitely store mix in a bag, to reduce the chance of fungus gnats or other little critters finding it. We have a container in the garage labeled 'potting soil'.

    Dan