Software
Houzz Logo Print
susancol_gw

Sprawling Melons in Raised Beds

16 years ago

Ok, I'm going to try melons for the first time. Charentais and minesota midget primarily. I'm planting in a 4x8 raised bed, and usually go by square foot gardening spacing guidelines, but as far as I can tell, the 1 per 2 square foot guideline for melons assumes that one will use a trellis and that the spacing is for how much room the melon will take up on the trellis, not necessarily how much ground space it needs. And recommendations for ground sprawling melons is usually quoted for hills.

So if I'm going to let the melons sprawl out into the yard as much as they like, do I still need to give them 2 square feet in the raised bed for nutrient/root purposes? Or could I plant them closer? The raised bed is on very hard clay/rock and roots will not likely penetrate below the 12 inch depth of the bed.

Thanks in advance!

Susan

Comments (5)

  • 16 years ago

    susancol

    Last year I tried that, to grow melons in a raised bed and let them sprawl.

    It was a disaster!

    I had weed problems that I just couldn't deal with (maybe you could if that happened), some sort of mold or fungus, plants that would not thrive, probably in large part because of the weather, but I won't do that again. I'll make sure they are returned to the vertical this year!

    Why don't you want to trellis them? It's a lot more efficient use of space. I didn't trellis mine last year because of the arthritis in my hands (difficult for me to tie them to the trellis), but daggone if I want to have no melons at all again. That's what I had, though my entire garden was pretty much a failure except for onions and lettuce and a few tomatoes in June.

  • 16 years ago

    Last year I grew about five Min-mig in a 3x5 ft mound and they were spaced a little over a foot apart. The vines get about 6 ft long and are not very robust so they don't need alot of root space. One per square foot might be just fine. I'm going to try four in a 30" tomatoe cage this year.

  • 16 years ago

    For me it's a matter of making do with what I've got. I have only 4 4x8 beds. I already have the north side trellis space spoken for by cucumbers and other vining squash. I have a partly shady yard, so spots in the sun are precious, and more trellis on any side other than north lead to more shade issues. I have lots of yard room for the vines to sprawl. So for my specific conditions, this seems to be the best idea. I'm just trying to figure out how to get the most bang for my buck.

    I agree that I'll have some weed issues. I grew a couple of butternuts this way last year. My plan is to spread pinestraw in the sprawl area to try to keep the weeds to a minimum. I have no grass, so mowing isn't a problem.

    I will place the growing fruits on top of an upside down plastic plate or bowl with drainage holes in, to keep the fruit from bottom rot or bug issues that might occur from direct ground contact.

    And I'm going to bring out the big guns on the powdery mildew problems that have plagued me with all of my curcubits. I bought a copper based fungicide. (I used milk/baking soda last year, but with the wet weather, the organic solution just wasn't enough.)

    So now my main concern is how many plants in my limited space will give me the best possible results. Hence my question. Can I plant them 1 per square foot with reasonable success, given that vine spread isn't an issue.

    Thanks again for any advice anyone can give.

    Susan

  • 16 years ago

    Hi Susan,
    Technically... Damn near anything is feasible ;-)
    You sound like you have a great battle plan ! !
    The Vine is 1" diameter at the soil penetration spot,and since you are going to "work the sprawl" , the only question is one that only you can answer...how rich is your soil,and will the nutrients be available to your melons...you don't actually need a whole square foot in the garden,just feed and water that root system and 1" stem and you are golden ;-)

    {{gwi:22425}}

  • 16 years ago

    Susan,

    Re: weed control

    You might want to consider a layer of cardboard and/or newspapers. This is the usual start for a lasagna bed and may help to soften your soil.