Software
Houzz Logo Print
anney_gw

How much bone meal for onions?

17 years ago

Tomorrow I'll get my onion transplants into two bins using ProMix BX as the planting soil. I'll also be adding two teaspons Dynamite (Red) fertilizer per surface square foot of soil. It's a 13-13-13 9-month time release with micronutrients. I don't believe the ProMix includes any fertilizer.

Since I have some bonemeal left over from last year and many websites recommend adding it to the planting soil for root crops, I've been trying to find a surface application rate for bone meal. I must be searching wrong or something -- I can't find it.

I want to set these onions up and not have to bother with anything other than watering them until they've matured, so does anyone have a suggestion about how much to use?

Comments (8)

  • 17 years ago

    I would say none :)

    First, it is very slow to release any nutrient (the fine ground stuff releases faster than the more coarse stuff) so probably won't have much of an effect this season. Second, it primarily supplies phosphorus and calcium.

    You don't need any phosphorus since the Dynamite fertilizer already has more than enough.

    Calcium is helpful, but the ProMix will have been limed by the manufacturer and this will supply a season's worth of calcium. Thereafter, if the mix is to be reused, adding more lime will supply both calcium and magnesium (The dynamite has Magnesium, but not Calcium).

    I don't see the bone meal adding anything necessary to what you are already doing.

  • 17 years ago

    Thank you, JAG!

    I'll save the bone meal for something else. I think I used it in my tomato planting holes last year. It's probably still there! Maybe my melons can make use of it this year.

    This will be my first year using Dynamite and I sure can't use it on everything since it ain't cheap. But the long time-release alleviates some anxities I have about never getting around to adding fertilizer to plants that need it later in the season. My poor tomatoes! I'll make sure they get fed while they're adolescents now. And the micronutrients are a nice backup if needed.

  • 17 years ago

    Just a thought, Anney,

    After years and years of doing so-so in the onion patch, I finally finally got my head around the fact that onions are not root crops. At least, I had better not think of them as root crops.

    You can see the roots, those long stringy things we cut off after harvest. The base of the leaves are what we want as a bulb. The top of the leaves are, well, leaves!

    They have green chlorophyll and require adequate nitrogen to grow well. Onions and early feeding of nitrogen go together because we are growing leaves. (Hold off on later applications so that they can mature & cure.)

    Steve

  • 17 years ago

    Steve

    That IS a change of mind, isn't it, for someone who's always thought of onions as a "root crop" in need of what other root crops need.

    I did read some research pointing out that onions seem to thrive on good amounts of nitrogen fertilizer, though the author didn't say anything about the bulb possibly just being the bottom of the leaves. He just mentioned that the nitrogen seems to encourage the production of more leaves and healthier and larger onions.

    So maybe we need another category for the garden onion (garlic/leeks, etc.) instead of including it with root crops in discussions.

  • 17 years ago

    "...nitrogen seems to encourage the production of more leaves and healthier and larger onions."

    That's right. Growing as many leaves as possible is one of the secrets to growing large onions. If you look at the structure of an onion plant you will see that each leaf is associated with one layer of the onion bulb. The more leaves, the more layers and the bigger the bulb.

    Jim

  • 17 years ago

    And when you think about nitrogen needs, at first, onions don't seem like they'd be standing at the head of the line. First of all, they are not large plants. Also, they are not a long-season crop. And, they go in early when it is difficult for plants to make use of what nitrogen is in the soil.

    Out they go, first thing in the cold spring soil and then fading and pulled in July. Then add to those facts an understanding of the problems "root crops" can have with too much nitrogen. The onion plant just doesn't look like the heavy feeder it really is.

    Steve

  • 17 years ago

    Well, I'm in the process of transferring half those 192 onion transplants into two more bins so I can have decent spacing between them. I'll still have to pull a lot of spring onions to give the remainder their five inches to grow, but I charted it out very carefully on paper first.

    I also discovered that a two-liter soda bottle with the top and bottom cut off is the perfect five inch spacer. I have a bunch of them taped together in rows that I thought I might use in the front of the house for bottomless planters for small flowers, etc. They make perfect onion spacers if you're aiming for five inches. Each of them would make a perfect single onion home, too, if the bottoms were left on and drainage holes were punched in them!

    Anyway, I'm looking forward to the results of my onion bins with their guaranteed high-nitrogen diet, now that I know they might need more than I thought they did. Since I'm also using the Dynamite 9-month fertilizer, I'll have to be careful to not overdo any more fertilization.

  • 17 years ago

    I totally agree. Onion culture is no different from greens. In my acid soil site, I add wood ash (lime equivalent) and urea, and they do well.