Software
Houzz Logo Print
jnjplus6

Mr Stripey Toms

19 years ago

Anyone grown the hybrid "Mr Stripey"? Just wondering how they come out and taste.

Thanks in advance!

Jen in TX

Comments (17)

  • 19 years ago

    How something tastes is entirely subjective. Having said that I grew Mr. Stripey one and only one year. They were among the worst tasting tomatos I ever ate. They were really, really awful. Gross actually. Bland while at the same time being bitter and vomit worthy is how I would describe them.

    Please do remember that taste is entirely subjective. ;-)

    Seriously though my subjective impression was that they were the worst tasting tomatos the earth was capable of growing and my wife agreed with me (and she picked the plant out).

    Doesn't mean you won't love them, just means they are awful according to me.

  • 19 years ago

    Jen, my objection to them was not the taste (just fair coming from my garden. It is hard for me not to like a home grown mater!), it was that they were totally non productive the first two years that I tried them, finally producing a few tomatoes the third year.

    My conclusion was that it was certainly not worth wasting space on them again. Your mileage may vary, all gardens are different (just like taste buds) with different micro climates, soil, elements and conditions. All of those things may contribute to how a certain plant does and the final results.
    Good luck with yours.
    Bill P.

  • 19 years ago

    Save your money! I planted a few last year and they were terrible.

  • 19 years ago

    I was really, really excited to find one of these as a seedling last year. I babied that plant all summer, and harvest one, yes ONE tomato. The slices were indeed pretty, very stripey. It tasted OK. Not bad, not good. Every other plant I planted produced like crazy except Mr. Stripey. Never again.

  • 19 years ago

    a good alternative may be striped german, my first year growing them last year and all worked well. BTW, I think the yellow toms have generally a blander taste than the reds, but I may be wrong, as my only yellow/striped variety I've tried in the striped german, which is much blander then a brandywine. (my favorite red tom)

  • 19 years ago

    There are quite a few bi colored as well as yellow or gold tomatoes around. I was pleasantly surprised last year with one called "Amish" Big Rain Bow. It caught my elderly neighbors attention in an ad on the back of a magazine and he ask if I could order some. I ordered a packet of seed, kept half and gave him half. I found out later in posting about it that the "Amish" part was probably just advertising hype and not true, but the thing impressed me by producing quite a few {{gwi:36748}} with a pretty fair taste. Another thing was that they hung in there and kept on producing long after many others had thrown in the towell in the severe heat and drought that we had last summer.
    Bill P.

  • 19 years ago

    Bill I just droodled all over my keyboard looking at that sandwich!!!!!It's a blizard out side and were suposed to get a foot of snow by morning. Watch you don't get sun burned working in your garden!!!LOL
    YOPPER

  • 19 years ago

    ":^) Thanks Yopper. I really have not felt much like getting outside much for the past few days, did stick a few (3) tomato plants in the ground and potted up about 25 little ones into 16 oz styrofoam cups, but now our "Easter Spell" is upon us now as this forecast indicates. Probably not much in comparison to the cold in your area, but enough to concern me about my little seedlings that I potted up and now can't get into the hotbed. I will bring them in for a few nights.
    Best regards.
    Bill P.

  • 19 years ago

    My Mr. Stripey would split long before they were ripe, however, the few a got tasted good. They are kind of cool looking.

  • 19 years ago

    I have grown Mr. Stripey for a couple years now.. and it was a decent tomato for me each time. Granted, it's not the most full-flavored tomato, but it's got a decent taste, it's very meaty, and fairly sweet. I found it was quite nice for fresh eating or on a sammitch. :) I grow them every year...at least so far.

    Just keep in mind, also, that there are two varieties of tomatoes known as "Mr. Stripey"..

    ..one (the one I grew) is a large, yellow-red bicolor beefsteak-style tomato that is meaty mild and sweet.

    ..the other is a medium round tomato, red with yellow streaks that is apparently quite tart

    Hope this helps.

  • 19 years ago

    The Mr. Stripey I grew had several huge faults:
    It is a MONSTER plant that no amount of pruning and staking could keep from flopping over in the garden.
    The toms split before getting ripe.
    The core of the tomato is HUGE.
    The fruit was mottled in color, not striped as advertised.
    The taste was ok...in the little tiny crescents you'd have left after trimming out the cracks and the huge core.

    I tried the first three or so for my table at home. After that I took all of 'em to work and gave them away. I ate the pink tomatoes (German) and better boy and Celebrity and Grape tomatoes. Much more civilized plants than the HUGE MONSTER that Mr. Stripey produced. I have the same complaint with Brandywine...huge untameable plant with cracked tomatoes.

  • 19 years ago

    I grew it once or twice and it was a huge disappointment, as I recall. Very low yield, and not much taste. I now grow Striped German and I love that one, although it's not a huge producer, either. Huge slurpy fruits with great flavor, however, and completely gorgeous in their bi-coloriffic-ness.

  • 19 years ago

    Sirtanon,

    Do you have a seed source you could share for the good Mr. Stripey? I wasn't aware there were 2 varieties going by the same name.

  • 19 years ago

    I currently am trying my first Mr. Stripey that I purchased at Lowes this year. The fruits aren't that big yet, but they're growing fast, so far. I have a few buds that have never blossomed, not dropped, never had flower to begin with. That doesn't bother me as I pinch off the smallest of the 3 buds that typically appear anyway. Since I'm not a real big tomato eater (DH is tho), I do like to grow one plant in a pot each year. I'm sure hoping this is the yellow/red beefsteak variety, which it appears to be so far, judging by the shape. The tag said it was a heirloom variety with a high sugar content. I guess only time will tell. I've been able to grow good tasting tomatoes, but last year's crop was not plentiful, due to the hot & then chilly weather. It's hot here now, but temps should be settling back down later this week here.

  • 19 years ago

    Mr. Stripey, the bi-color beefsteak is not a hybrid, but open pollinated. It was introduced in 90's by Shumway and seems to have gained some popularity. Bonnie plants seems to always offer it. Never did much for me as has a very thin skin, cracks at the drop of a hat and invites every bug in the neighborhood.

    The other Mr. Stripey is more properly called Tigerella, a small tart English tomato, also open pollinated. Available from Tomato Growers Supply.

    I don't reccomend either of them. As someone already posted Big Rainbow is about the most consistant bi-color.

  • 19 years ago

    I've grown about 20 bi-color tomatoes and my favorite is still Burracker's Favorite, followed by Virginia Sweets. Lucky Cross & Little Lucky are often recommended by many also.

    Some bi-colors:

    Burracker's Favorite
    Virginia Sweets
    Lucky Cross
    Little Lucky
    Big Rainbow
    Peaches & Cream
    King Pineapple
    Pineapple
    Hawaiian Pineapple
    Northern Lights
    Rhoades Heirloom
    Pearl's Yellow Pink
    Mary Robinson's German Bi-Color
    Mammoth German Gold
    Marizol Gold
    Old German
    Striped German
    Hillbilly
    Georgia Streak
    Mom's (orange & red)
    Hazel Mae
    Oaxacan Jewel
    Polish Pastel (a paste type/plum)
    Mr. Stripey
    Cherokee Bi-Color (one I'm working on...)
    Isis Candy (a cherry tom)
    Bi-Color Cherry (" ")

    I probably forgot a few, there's some I haven't grown. Most of these aren't available at the big box stores & only available as seed.

    Mark

  • 19 years ago

    I got my Mr. Stripey from Walmart. So it's a Bonnie plant. I hope it is the better variety. I paid almost $5 for that thing because it so intrigued me! It has several tomatoes growing on it, but none are turning color yet. We'll see. At least I have other tomato plants to make up the difference if it doesn't work out.

Sponsored
High Point Cabinets
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars21 Reviews
Columbus' Experienced Custom Cabinet Builder | 4x Best of Houzz Winner