Software
Houzz Logo Print
granburyflowergirl

Concrete vs Hypertufa containers?

16 years ago

I need help ASAP Please!!! I have gotten mixed messages/conflicting info on the Hypertufa forum, so I need input from people experienced with actually using hypertufa containers before I embark on my planned mass production.

How long can they be expected to last?

Is it reasonable to think you could grow citrus or other small trees in a hypertufa pot for any length of time? (I am thinking at least 6-10 years).

How well do they hold up as compared to terracotta?

Would I be better off making concrete planters with a thin layer of hypertufa over it?

If I make concrete/hypertufa pots, will they still breathe?

Help! I was hoping to start today! :-(

Comments (9)

  • 16 years ago

    I leave mine out all winter w/no problems. Many are 10 years old +. They don't breath because they hold water indefinitely. You can grow in them for extended periods with the same attention to the plants' roots and other cultural needs as you would give plants in other containers.

    Al

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks Al,
    I was hoping someone would tell me they do last!

    Do you happen to remember what recipe you used 10 years ago? (I have portland cement, turface fines, sand, pine dust and perlite and maybe used coffee grinds available).

    Also, how thick are the pots you have that have lasted 10 years outside?

    Last question: If hypertufa doesn't breath, what is it that plants like so much about it? Is it better to use terracotta than hypertufa?

    Thanks!

  • 16 years ago

    I think I used
    3 parts portland cement
    3 parts sphagnum peat
    2 parts perlite
    1 part Turface fines
    Fiberglas reinforcement filaments
    I like to add some dry pasta shapes to it at the last minute.

    Al
    {{gwi:40945}}

    {{gwi:40946}}

    {{gwi:2014}}

    I have many others. None have broken yet.

  • 16 years ago

    Woah...pasta shapes?????...Why? A Spaghetti "welcome to your new home" dinner for the plants? ;-)

    Thanks for the pics, I love the cool looking little red guys in the last pic.

    I am still wondering if there any greater benefit to the plants in using hypertufa over terracotta or vice versa?

  • 16 years ago

    Both terracotta and hypertufa are going to be heavy to move to shelter during winters in your zone 7.

  • 16 years ago

    Microbes eat up all the pasta shapes after the tufa is dry, leaving pits & indentations exactly the shape of the pasta in the walls of the troughs.

    Al

  • 16 years ago

    Hahaha, that's hilarious Al! I took a closer look but I couldn't identify any pinwheels or butterflies or alphabet letters in your pics.

    I have someone on the hypertufa forum telling me she doesn't bother drilling drain holes because the hypertufa wicks water away just fine without them and her plants do great long-term in her pots.

    I wonder if different recipes have different effects as far as whether they "breath" or "wick"? I am trying to find out what recipe she is using to figure out why hers wick and mine don't seem to.

  • 16 years ago

    FWIW - I usually fill mine with vinegar water if I want to use them that year, & the only water they 'lose' is what evaporates. You can prolly MAKE them breathe by increasing the peat content and making the walls thin, but both will cause a loss of strength.

    I wouldn't even consider using them w/o holes. You NEED the flushing action you can only get with drain holes - otherwise, you ensure salt build-up. I don't think I have any pictures of the ones made with pasta shapes, but the pits are pretty rustic cool.

    Al

  • 16 years ago

    I've seen them made using baskets too.. I like the rustic look.

    JoJo