Software
Houzz Logo Print
c_newby

what to do with 'old' dirt

19 years ago

Hi, I'm new to this forum and relatively new to cont. gardening, in fact all gardening. I had some lovely petunias this summer, until the budworms and aphids ate them....

I'm finally getting around to pulling them out and getting ready to store my pots to next year. What do I do with my leftover soil? I am assuming I can't just dump it in my other beds, as it may have seeds and/or larvae... do I just trash it? Can I put it in my composter?

Comments (11)

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Originally posted in '05:

    In my estimation, the only case to be made for reusing container soils is one of economics, and you'll never find me argue against making that decision. If you can't afford it, you can't afford it. That said and setting economics aside, you might decide to reuse soil for reasons other than economical. Perhaps the effort involved with acquiring (or making your own) soil is something you might not wish to go through or be bothered with. In any case, it would be difficult to show that soils in a more advanced state of structural collapse can somehow be preferred to a soil that can be counted on to maintain its structure for the entire growth cycle of the planting. So, if the economic aspect is set aside, at some point you must decide that "my used soil is good enough" and that you're willing to accept whatever the results of that decision are.

    All soils are not created equal. The soils I grow in are usually pine bark based & collapse structurally at a much slower rate that peat based soils, yet I usually choose to turn them into the garden or give them over to a compost pile where they serve a better purpose than as a container soil after a year of service. Some plantings (like woody materials and some perennials) do pretty well the second year in the same bark-based soil, and with careful watering, I'm usually able to get them through a third year w/o root issues.

    Watering habits are an extremely important part of container gardening. Well structured soils that drain well are much more forgiving and certainly favor success on the part of the more inexperienced gardeners. As soils age, water retention increases and growing becomes increasingly difficult. If your (anyone's) excellence in watering skills allows you to grow in an aging medium, or if your decision that "good enough" is good enough for you, then it's (your decision) is good enough for me, too.

    The phrases "it works for me" or "I've done it this way for years w/o problems" is often offered up as good reason to continue the status quo, but there's not much substance there.

    I'm being called away now, but I'll leave with something I offered in reply on a recent thread:
    "... First, plants really aren't particular about what soil is made of. As long as you're willing to stand over your plant & water every 10 minutes, you can grow most plants perfectly well in a bucket of marbles. Mix a little of the proper fertilizers in the water & you're good to go. The plant has all it needs - water, nutrients, air in the root zone, and something to hold it in place. So, if we can grow in marbles, how can a soil fail?

    Our growing skills fail us more often than our soils fail. We often lack the experience or knowledge to recognize the shortcomings of our soils and to adjust for them. The lower our experience/knowledge levels are, the more nearly perfect should be the soils we grow in, but this is a catch 22 situation because hidden in the inexperience is the inability to even recognize differences between good and bad soil(s).

    Container soils fail when their structure fails. When we select soils with components that break down quickly or that are so small they find their way into and clog macro-pores, we begin our growing attempts under a handicap. I see anecdotes about reusing soils, even recommendations to do it all over these forums. I don't argue with the practice, but I (very) rarely do it, even when growing flowery annuals, meant only for a single season.

    Soils don't break down at an even rate. If you assign a soil a life of two years and imagine that the soil goes from perfect to unusable in that time, it's likely it would be fine for the first year, lose about 25% of its suitability in the first half of the second year, and lose the other 75% in the last half of the second year. This is an approximation & is only meant to illustrate the exponential rate at which soils collapse. Soils that are suitable for only a growing season show a similar rate of decline, but at an accelerated rate. When a used soil is mixed with fresh soil after a growing season, the old soil particles are in or about to begin a period of accelerated decay. I choose to turn them into the garden or they find their way to a compost pile.

    Unless the reasons are economical, I find it difficult to imagine why anyone would add garden soils to container soils. It destroys aeration and usually causes soils to retain too much water for too long. Sand (unless approaching the size of BB's), has the same effect. I don't use compost in soils because of the negative effect on aeration/drainage. The small amount of micro-nutrients provided by compost can be more efficiently added, organically or inorganically, via other vehicles.

    To boil this all down, a container soil fails when the inverse relationship between aeration/drainage goes awry. When aeration is reduced, soggy soil is the result, and trouble is in the making."

    Al

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I agree with Al. I had to learn this the hard way. I now use my container soil in the fall in a compost bin that gets put in the flower beds in the spring as mulch to cool the ground. I add about 4 inches each year with a dose of fertilizer each year before spreading the "mulch" on top. I guestimate that the "new Mulch" is about 1/3 old container mix and 2/3 fresh compost that I have made during the winter. My roses seem to like it very well.

    If I thought that I needed to reuse it for economic reasons then I would use the "new Mulch" as the mulch in Al's mix and add the other items with it. I have had a couple of containers in which I did not get a good mix and had more of the "new Mulch" in it and the plants in it did not seem to do as well as it seemed to hold water more so it was almost swampy. Love to have some form of a mixer to try to get more uniform mix.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My soil is compost/manure with perlite and it's 'eternal' with perennials growing for over a decade. However, I do maintain about two inches of mulch in each container. In some containers I grow begonias but do the same thing, as with my vegetables. When I do plant something new I amend the soil with a cup of two of compost/manure. There are many theories and I see the value in most theory, but in the end it's what works for you. Good luck.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I've seen several of Paul's posts similar to the one he just left, but never felt too compelled to comment, but today, I think I'm going to take the liberty of having a conversational disagreement with Paul and invite him to respond - if it's ok with the original poster. Perhaps we'll gain some insight .....

    There is nothing even close to 'eternal' about an organic soil and there is nothing theoretical, speculative, or even hypothetical in the idea that organic soil particles eventually break down into increasingly tiny particles and cause soils to hold a higher % of water than is healthy for normal root function. Manure breaks down rapidly, and even completely finished compost breaks down much faster than conifer bark. That is why I never use them in container soils.

    To be fair, we must allow that perhaps Paul has hit on the perfect way to treat plants in this type of soil - perfect size container and soil volume, perfect watering technique, etc. He is obviously happy with the results:effort ratio. That's fine, and if it's what works for him and he's happy - I'm happy.

    I will say to other readers though, that a soil mix of "compost/manure with perlite" is going to be very difficult for a high percentage of growers to use effectively. Even if the soil was 'perlite with compost/manure', it would present it's own set of growing difficulties.

    So, "... in the end it's what works for you" is a good summation, but I would offer something in closing. Many forum contributors and readers alike, come here because they are frustrated or unhappy with the results of what they are using for container soils. They want to learn how to structure a good soil for containers, and feel that "what's good enough" isn't good enough.

    This has given me an idea for a thread. I almost never start one on my own, but I'm feeling a bit of a need to explain a few things.

    Remember please, Paul - there is no ad hominum attack here - I just disagree with the conclusions you draw from your observations.

    Al

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks Al. I agree with you, theory is the best place to start. However, after I did that, years ago, I started testing alternatives and arrived at "what works for me." Yes, I know that the regular decomposition of mulch and addition of compost/manure gives the illusion of 'eternal' soil. Given that it works for me, I'm just sharing the experience -- mainly because it's an example of the KISS principle and so many newbies are looking for easy solutions. Again, I totally agree with your approach; it's simply the right thing, but will continue to share "what works for me." Thanks for pointing out that we all should begin by doing the right things BEFORE we even consider testing alternatives. We are all in your debt.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    There are always exceptions and other considerations and alternatives other than the important issues of economics or structural support and aeration of a growing medium mentioned. Several long-term plants, containerized trees, and species of bulbs like peonies, roses, gardenias, hot peppers, for example, require not only well-drained, moist, rich, fertile, heavier potting mixes for proper growth, but yearly repotting, root disturbances, or transplant is also not advised for cultivation, bloom, yield, and productivity.

    Among other advantages and benefits, some nurseries and peony or tree specialists use root control bags (Pot Pruner and Smart Containers, etc.) to air prune roots automatically to keep the roots of these types of long-term plants and trees unbound and healthy on longer term(up to 5 years for peonies) regardless of the type or composition of the potting mix preferred, needed, or used.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Of course there are always exceptions and alternatives to what we will use as a growing medium for our plants, but the primary two are the amount of effort a grower will expend to insure optimum vitality (grower convenience) and economics. I hold fast to the fact that a soil should always be able to structurally support a high enough % of aeration to insure plant vitality for the life of the planting.

    Even if it says so on the label of plants we normally plant out, none of the plants you mentioned actually require " ... moist, rich, fertile, heavier potting mixes for proper growth." They may prefer that kind of soil in the garden or beds, but all they require in containers is a medium that continually makes available water, air, and nutrients in the right proportions (with our help, of course). ;o)

    If you're growing a plant that you feel should not have the roots disturbed, then why grow in a soil that will begin rapid collapse after a season or before? For trees & other woody plants you wish to leave undisturbed for more than a growth cycle use a gritty mix with a high mineral component which insures structural stability and adequate volumes of air in the root zone.

    If there is any real area that I could call a specialty for me, it's in long term care and energy management of containerized woody plants. I can attest that trees and woody plants that are root-pruned and repotted will, by the end of the growth cycle and in almost every case, exhibit a greater gain in biomass than their counterparts that were not treated so. This is true for yearly repots of plants but especially so for plants that are particularly root-bound.

    Too much water/not enough air in the root zone and being rootbound are both forms of stress. While the latter may promote blooming in some plants through stress, it shouldn't be looked upon as a + from a plant vitality perspective.

    Disturbing roots and even eliminating a portion of them is not necessarily a bad thing. Fat, lignified roots in containerized plants are useless & serve only to connect the top of the tree hydraulically and to its below-the-soil anchoring. Plants also have chemical messengers with distal effects. When roots are disturbed, it sends a chemical signal that causes a surge in growth, above and below ground, that would not normally be seen in undisturbed plants. If you watch a skilled person creating a floral display planting, you see them tearing off the bottom half of bedding plant root masses & even further disturbing the roots before adding them to the planting. This actually causes the plants to establish in the container much, much faster than if the root mass was left intact. I learned this years ago and love to use it to horrify friends when I help them build their containers. ;o) A skilled bonsai practitioner will do much the same to the roots of woody material, year after year. If they can maintain perfectly healthy plants in tiny containers for hundreds of years, they must know something ...

    I'm not sure what pertinent point there was to be made in the air-pruning paragraph. I often use the baskets that water plants are planted in, or colander-like affairs from the dollar store if I want rapid development in a particular plant or if a plant is sick. I use them because they further maximize the air the already air-rich soils I use hold. This is the direct opposite of a "heavier potting mix". It usually causes rampant, but coarse (larger leaves and longer internodes) growth.

    Commercial operations use self pruning pots for three reasons. It saves them time because they don't have to root-prune and they pot up less frequently. It also helps eliminate encircling or girdling roots and keeps fine roots growing closer to the base, hastening establishment once planted out.

    Al

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Paul and Al, I applaude you both for such a sane nonconfrontational exchange!!! Sometimes it is a rarity on some of these sites.
    I was in the compost/manure/perlite side just a year ago and moved over to the mix that Al recommends and my plants are double in size. However watering is very essentioal and I could ignore my plants a little more with the first mix.
    I really notice now at the end of the season the difference. Therefore I do think maybe my soil had decomposed. I have come over to Al's mix.
    Like you said newbies might not be inclined to use Al's
    Gardening is so therapuetic it doesnt really matter. I say just go out and play in the dirt!! (Of course it is so cool when things really grow!)

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Al, Justadncr, we're on the same page. My figs are ripe now and I'm in hog heaven -- eating like a hog. That's the joy of gardening for me -- seeing the beauty in the flowers and foliage, eating the fruits & vegetables and herbs. The process of getting there is therapeutic, but the eating is 'reaching the mountain top' for me. Whatever path gets us to the mountain top is the right one. At the end of the day, gardening is fun and a reminder of the beauty of creation. Enjoy.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I mentioned air root pruning exactly because there are additional reasons and situations where the suggested regular repotting in maintaining optimal growing medium for container culture will not be viable and suitable options to add value to the discussion. Root control bags or air root pruning supposedly utilize all the science and technical advantages known and learned by expert landscape scientists and horticulturalists (and bonsai practioners) without requiring a knowledgeable or inexperienced gardener or business needing to understand or be technical about all the technical unique horticultrual details or the basic needs of a species of a plant, the type and composition of the best potting mix, watering technique, proper moisture retention and aeration ratios, etc, to be successful with their venture and investment or in situations where yearly or frequent repotting would not be an economic or horticultural viable practice, such as ensuring peonies that will bloom or caring for both large and small trees for longevity in containers. One can defy the rules of container culture by using top soil, garden soil, or any potting mixes one chooses in a root control bag because the fabric and material used in a root control bag ensure healthy root growth on multiple technical grounds to compensate for the lack of experience, knowledge (proven or to be determined), or resources in time, labor, and finance of a gardener or business.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    All the best to you, Paul. Enjoy your endeavors. Thank you for the kind words too, E. Take care, both of you. ;o)

    Al

Sponsored
Daniel Home
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars20 Reviews
Premier Interior Design Team Transforming Spaces in Franklin Co, Ohio