Software
Houzz Logo Print
mauirose_gw

Spinosad/bees

16 years ago

Do you use Spinosad?

i do not want to spark one of those ugly, rock throwing sorts of discussions but i'd like to hear about your experiences if you do.

The reason is that i have a product called GF-120 which is Spinosad in a sweet, vinegary, syrupy product. It is diluted in solution and sprayed on foliage in the roosting areas of fruit flies or brushed full strength on the inside of upturned water bottles which are then hung in the roosting areas. The county extension agent said it does not pose a threat to bees.

A quick internet search indicates Spinosad is 'highly toxic' to bees but much less so after a four hour dry time. The advice is to avoid spraying the product while bees are actively foraging.

i am concerned because i have recently observed a few slow moving/paralyzed bees around the yard and garden. They look like bees that have ingested imidacloprid (Merit). Since i do not use Merit i wonder if the Spinosad might be to blame. i guess another explanation is that one of my neighbors has applied Merit~the product is readily enough available. Don't know how far the bees can travel before becoming symptomatic tho'.

In the meantime i am going to try to screen the bees from entering the bait stations. i use the inverted water bottle method and fruit flies are smaller than bees so it shouldn't be too hard.

Comments (7)

  • 16 years ago

    I use spinosad. I am very careful about following directions. I can say right now I have a thriving bumblebee population, and a wasp population I wish the spinosad would cut down on.

    I've never had a ton of honeybees to begin with, but the more I garden, the more I see. My neighbor next door is almost exclusively into flower gardening. I just assume the honey bees find his place more interesting.

    Some personal rules I follow about using spinosad:
    1) don't use on a windy day, not even a light breeze.
    2) If I am spraying near plants that don't require spinosad, I've gone as far as bringing out a physical barrier, such as a brown paper bag to block the mist from getting on plants that don't need it. This is exceptionally important because I have German chamomile growing next to broccoli and cauliflower. The bumblebees love the chamomile, but don't touch the broccoli and cauliflower.
    3) I also try not to spray on the spinosad first thing in the morning. In part because of dew, but mostly because I don't want it around all day poisoning any helpful insects.

    I have never found a dead bumblebee in my garden except right after a frost in fall. I know that isn't the spinosad's fault. I only use spinosad on brassicas, which don't tend to attract a lot of bumblebees in the first place. I have seen wasps hunting things on my brassica, but I have never found a dead wasp in my garden beds. Overall, I am happy with the product and will continue to use it in the future.

  • 16 years ago

    Thank-you for your thoughtful response veggiefaery. i like your personal rules for using this product and am happy to hear that you have not witnessed any bee problems.

    i do not like to find these distressed bees. i hope Spinosad is not the culprit but i do not know what else could be causing the symptoms.

  • 16 years ago

    mauirose - I really think your neighbor is likely the culprit. I am not sure what kind of relationship you have with your neighbor, but perhaps you could suggest something less lethal to spray on his plants.

    I am in a lucky situation because my neighbor is very respectful about my wishes not to have toxins sprayed everywhere. We live in a condominium duplex (more of a townhouse) so we share the lawn with the neighbor. He has asked in the past if he could spray weed killer on the lawn. I asked him not to because I don't want my dog, my plants or myself near that. He took a weed puller and took all the dandelions out by hand. This year, I did the same. As for my backyard, which is separated from his, he just closes his eyes. There are a lot of weeds back there.

    If it helps in convincing your neighbor, a major study just came out linking pesticides as a potential cause of AD/HD in children. I am a special education teacher so you can already imagine how I feel about that. I included a link below to an article about the study. There is also another link in the article for more information.

    Good luck protecting your bees.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Pesticides & ADHD

  • 16 years ago

    Adult bees have only about 2 weeks of life remaining once they become forgers. That's the normal state of things for bees.

  • 16 years ago

    Mauirose - I use spinosad in my vegetable garden and I have a lot of bees. I use less than the recommended amount and it works for me.

    Silvia

  • 16 years ago

    From the bees' perspective, spraying first thing in the morning isn't so great, because that's when they leave to go out foraging. Late evening would be better. What's even better is to skip the chemicals completely.

    -Diggity

    Here is a link that might be useful: Garden Imperative blog

  • 16 years ago

    I have not used Spinosad, so I can't comment on that. I have made some observations of bees in my garden however. Bumblebees are much more abundant in my garden than honey bees. That may have something to do with the collapse of honey bee populations or it may be because many of the crops I grow are visited by bumblebees but not by honey bees. I suspect it is due more to the latter because, when I have a crop such as mustard in bloom, a lot of honey bees come around.

    Jim