Software
Houzz Logo Print
vegtammy

Well water in vegetable

14 years ago

Hello, I have a new vegetable garden at my rural location, and I am using my well to water the garden. The outside water valves bypass the water softner/potassium pump that I use inside the house for drinking water, washing, etc. My garden is not doing so well, I am able to smell metal in my watering can from the water. My well has a heavy iron content that I soften the water inside. I have water barrels outside which are now dry- no rain in over 4 weeks in Ohio just recently. I am sure what to do. I am alway worried about the rain water from my roof due to my asphalt roof shingles, and am now worried about my well water being too hard with iron to irrigate the vegetable garden. Any solutions?

Thank you

Comments (10)

  • 14 years ago

    If your new garden isn't doing well, it could be for many reasons....soil fertility, soil ph, lack of moisture, gardening skill, and choice of crops and varieties suitable for your area.
    I would think that most well water would not be highly harmful unless it has some very high levels of sulfur or other mineral. I have watered from mine a fair amount this month which is unusual.

  • 14 years ago

    I believe my soil is good, I've used my topsoil with organic compost combined in the raised beds. It could be my lack of garden experience, I am using all heirloom vegetables grown from seed. It's just depressing to work so hard, and see so little reward.

  • 14 years ago

    Sorry but I would have to agree that it is very unlikely that the well water is the problem. I too water with well water as do thousands of other gardeners. Iron poses no problems to plants. In fact many add supplemental iron to their gardens to prevent problems.

    So perhaps if you could tell us exactly what sort of problems the plants are having we might be able to help ID the real problem or problems.

    "Topsoil" can mean many different things and without having your soil professionally tested there is no way to know what kind of problems it could be causing. And over-watering plants is also a common source of problem for new gardeners.

    Plus if you have added no supplemental nutrients, nothing but compost, then your plants could easily be starving for nutrients. Compost isn't a fertilizer and can only supplement nutrients if the soil has very active soil bacteria levels. New gardens have not yet developed the soil micro herd that is required.

    So we need much more details please.

    Dave

  • 14 years ago

    If the veggies look yellowish, it is nitrogen deficiency. It is the most common cause of veggies not doing well, specially for those who think that a load of compost is all that is needed. Unless you are willing to collect and use the household urine, you will have to give them some urea or other high N fertilizer. My city water has a pH of 9.3, almost certainly worse than your water, and I still use it without any ill effect.

  • 14 years ago

    My cukes and zinnia are looking rather yellow.

    What would give them a quick shot of Nitrogen?

    Thanks!

  • 14 years ago

    Depends on your threshold for organic and non-organic solutions.

    Non-organic solution would be urea, Miracle Grow or some other synthetic fertilizer, heavy on the first NPK number, like 30 or 40. Side dress the plants with the granular fertilizer or if liquid, add to watering can and saturate the roots or heavy application as a foliar spray.

    Organic solution will take longer to see results but will be just as effective in the long run. Blood meal is your best bet for Nitrogen boost as a side dress, along with a foliar spray of fish emulsion (if you can stand the smell and don't have too many animals in the area). You can also side dress with a seed meal like alfalfa or soybean, and make sure you mix in some phosphorus like bone meal and some potassium (harder to get a good organic source, but kelp meal is a good choice, albeit expensive).

    Absolutely essential to the uptake of slow release organic fertilizers is the addition of calcium. A combination of dolomitic lime and calcium sulfate (or any agricultural lime) applied at the same time as your side dress. No doubt you are going to hear the standard "don't add lime it will change your pH!!!" songs, but it won't change your pH that drastically nor that quickly. Besides, without calcium, the NPK you are adding will not be available to the plants. That's right: NPK should actually be NPKCa because without calcium the true effectiveness of the NPK numbers is a crap shoot.

  • 14 years ago

    Better test your soil. Mine is 0.4% Ca, I doubt it needs anymore.

  • 14 years ago

    My cukes and zinnia are looking rather yellow.
    What would give them a quick shot of Nitrogen?

    Thanks!

    Always best to start your own post rather than drag an existing one off course. But since this one has already gone off track, then follow glib's advice and test your soil before getting carried away with the lime and Ca. Calcium deficient soil may exist for m lorne but for the rest of us it is very rare and skewing our pH with lime would cause more problems than actually having Ca deficient soil does.

    So your original question - if your plants actually need a N boost (yellowing of old leaves is caused by excess watering, not N deficiency as that shows up on new growth) then any fertilizer of your choice from the 100's of brands available - both organic and synthetic - will solve the problem.

    Dave

  • 14 years ago

    I did a non scientific experiment on well versus municipal water. I watered one half with municipal and the other with well water. The side with the well water did much better.

    I guess the plants are a lot like me. I will not drink or cook with municipal water, it tastes bad and I don't think it is as clean.

    I work for a sewer company and can't imagine drinking the water that comes from the sewer plants, no matter how much it has been sanitized! All of the municipal water around here has sewer water in it.

    I prefer the natural filtration that well water gets.

    Another plus is well water is much cheaper.

  • 14 years ago

    I've been gardening with well water for 11 years, no problem!
    I also don't use anything but homegrown compost/aged manure (depending on what is available, goat/horse/llama/cow.) and also dose the plants with some pond water (WATER!fish fornicate in water-WC Fields)from time to time!
    My gardens are wonderful! I don't use any fertilizer at all!
    Good luck and happy gardening! Nancy