Software
Houzz Logo Print
mngardenman

Fish Emulsion?

14 years ago

Can fish emulsion be used on corn, peas and watermelon?

Comments (17)

  • 14 years ago

    I don't know why not...it's just a form of fertilizer. However, keep in mind that some animals, like skunks and raccoons, smell the odor and start digging to get at the "fish." I know someone who lost over 60 large seedlings in one night due to the application of deodorized fish fertilizer that was investigated by a family of skunks.

  • 14 years ago

    An example of what I described...

    Here is a link that might be useful: Fish emulsion...raccoons

  • 14 years ago

    Thanks for that skunk/raccoon tip.

    DL

  • 14 years ago

    That is actually one of the first thoughts I had when I was thinking of using the stuff, do I really want to use something that could possibly attract the critters to my garden?

  • 14 years ago

    I think the bigger problem comes down to heavy metals being present in the emulsion. Alaska fish emulsion says it can't be used for food crops because of this, or at least shouldn't be used because of this.

    Maybe others can chime in as to whether this is a common problem across all brands of fish emulsion because of the inherent nature for fish to accumulate heavy metal toxins in their bodies.

  • 14 years ago

    I use Neptune's Harvest and it works very well for me. I do not have any problems with it attracting animals. The only animals that are bothersome around my way are, groundhogs, skunks and opossums. I spray fish emulsion each week, so either I'm lucky, or the animals just do not care enough to come check it out.

  • 14 years ago

    Apply it right before (or during) a nice rain. My dogs love the smell of it so I would just it when I knew rain was coming. It helps get it in and reduces/eliminates the smell

  • 14 years ago

    Gribble, my bottle of Alaska fish emulsion doesn't say anything about not using it on food crops, in fact it has directions for dilution rates for various types of vegetables. Their website says it can be used on all types of plants.

  • 14 years ago

    I agree with gribble, the heavy metals concern me. Fish tend to be loaded with mercury. I've thought about using it in the past, then thought about the heavy metals in fish and decided to pass. I think the Alaska brand also lost their OMRI cert for the product, I wonder if that is why.

  • 14 years ago

    Is the heavy metals present in every brand or is there any that are safe from it?

  • 14 years ago

    MN,

    Im not sure that heavy metals are definetly present in the fish emulsion, for me it is just a concern as many fish do contain high levels of mecury and other heavy metals. That is why I avoid it, just to err on the safe side. This is why the FDA reccommends limiting fish in your diet to once a week or less (at least I believe that is the current reccommendation)

    Any reputable manufacturer should list the heavy metal content on their label, or provide a number/website where that info can be found.

  • 14 years ago

    Does anyone know what the Fish Emulsions are made of? It's mostly the predator fish (salmon/tuna/etc) that have longer lives/bigger bodies that accumulate significant amounts of mercury. The bottom of the chain (anchovies/sardines/etc) have such short lives in relation to them and are safe to eat because of that. I was under the impression that fish fertilizers were made from the smaller fish for economic reasons.

  • 14 years ago

    I just spoke with Neptune's Harvest about their Hydrolyzed Fish Emulsion. They were very nice on the phone. I was told there is NO mercury in their product. Their fish fertilizer is made from smaller Atlantic fish such as, haddock, flounder and cod. They filet the fish and sell that to restaurants/seafood places and the rest is used to make the fish emulsion. Their product has been tested for this and they are sending me an email with all of the information.

    Here is the information. This is why it is very important to do your own research. People project opinion on baseless information or provide a hunch as fact, all too often.

    {{gwi:65904}}

  • 14 years ago

    Pitcom,

    If you were referring to me, I was not suggesting my opinion to be fact. I was only suggesting that this may be of concern and is why I personally chose not to use that type of fertilizer. In my reply, I also stated that the manufacturers should have data on that, inferring mn may want to research that and make his/her own informed decision.

    Thanks.

  • PRO
    14 years ago

    We live mostly on fish and vegetables, have been growing organic vegetables fertilized with fish emulsion and have caught our own seafood for over 50 years, I'm a recreational scubadiver and fisherman/gardener. I cannot understand the naevity of some responses to this thread.

    What is wrong with people who think this practice is unhealthy? I do also enjoy a good steak now and then, so I'm not a freaken vegan. Point being, get out of that bubble you live in and enjoy what you like!

    Good grief!!