Software
Houzz Logo Print
latsirkkristal

companion planting

16 years ago

so i have been reading online about companion planting, and noticed that beans and onions shouldn't be planted together. since i have done this in my garden :( what does this mean for my crops.

thanks

Comments (16)

  • 16 years ago

    since you read this on line have searched to see what online sources have say about why beans and onions should not be planted together.

  • 16 years ago

    Their claim is that the onions have an allelopathic effect on the beans. Most gardeners have found this, like many of the companion planting claims, to be unfounded.

    However if you want to learn more about Companion Planting then I'd suggest you check out the Companion Planting forum here for discussions on this and other related issues.

    Dave

    Here is a link that might be useful: Companion Planting

  • 16 years ago

    If you will do a search in this forum with the following words:

    allelopathy onion bean pea, or
    allelopathy onion pea

    -- you will find some discussion of this issue.

    There doesn't seem to be too much experience with adverse effects. I, for one, would appreciate it if you would come back in a month or so and tell us how your bean harvest is up to your expectation.

    digitSteve

  • 16 years ago

    Hey digitSteve,

    Even if the OP has a below-expectation bean harvest this year, it won't tell us anything meaningful about allelopathy between onions and beans, because there are so many other factors that can affect his/her bean harvest - weather, soil prep, pests, watering regime, crop spacing, weed competition and unreasonable expectations, just to name a few.

    Tracey

  • 16 years ago

    Of course there are a number of variables that affect crop yield, Tracey.

    I think that just about ALL companion planting ideas are anecdotal. In fact, I don't see too much "hard science" on GardenWeb on any issue, anyway.

    For me, that's just as well. I appreciate the conversational tone of the forums.

    Steve, with no appropriate degrees

  • 16 years ago

    Since I garden in narrow terraces, my plants are mixed by necessity. The only adverse effect I am sure of is that between radishes and tomatoes. Two tomatoes from same 6 pack planted in different parts of yard. The one near radishes did not thrive as well as the other one.[growth actually stood still] When I removed the radishes, the affected tomato did a rapid spurt of growth. Very dramatic, and PROOF enough for me.

  • 16 years ago

    digit,
    There was really no need for a snarky reply. I see no claim of 'appropriate degrees' or the necessity for such in my post, so not sure why you are defensive.
    Tracey

  • 16 years ago

    Tomatoes and radishes cause problems when planted together? Uh oh. I snuck in a few rows in between my tomato plants. They've still been growing, but not quite as fast at the bed without the radishes... I hadn't even thought about it. Oh well, I guess I'll just let the radishes go and see what happens.

  • 16 years ago

    In my opinion companion planting is not an exact science. Take the advice of those who have given their advice and then see what works for you.

  • 16 years ago

    We gardeners do a lot of "experimenting", nearly all of which is trying something to see what happens. Many of us have enough knowledge about scientific methods to do a proper controlled experiment but we seldom do that, which is a pity because so few resources are needed and it can be fun. I encourage you to do a simple experiment or two each year and report the results on GW. And I need to follow my own advice, I know.

    There is a forum called Garden Experiments. Unfortunately, very little of it is about true experiments, but it's worth a look.

    Jim

    Here is a link that might be useful: Garden Experiments

  • 16 years ago

    The combination of peas/beans planted near onions is that their growth will be stunted and there might be facts to this, who can tell, where the wind blows kind of thing, one part of the yard doesn't reach the other by strange conditions, so who can really tell about what works and what doesn't.

    I can vouch only for the marigold chasing away bunnies. I had problems for 2 years, and no bunnies, bugs of all kinds, but no bunnies. My marigolds are just now blooming and only the early variety, so of 50 or so marigold plants, I have only 7 of the early blooming type, Cracker Jack variety. Still waiting to see one little bud to pop up on the others that were volunteers from a give from last year, don't know what kind, but obviously a hybrid because they never grew over 8 inches last year, their seeds are about 2 to 3 feet high this year.

    There are some truths to them, but you have to try them out. The marigold didn't stop the squirrel, groundhog, or a huge vulture in a tree, but they aren't blooming either. I'm safe from bunnies, that is amazing to me and enough to try again, just plant them earlier under glass to make them bloom faster next year, with flowers I can really put the myth to the test.

    PS. Don't buy the marigolds from the nursery because they are bred to have less odor, the odor of the flower is what's useful.

  • 16 years ago

    The marigold didn't stop the squirrel, groundhog, or a huge vulture in a tree,
    _____________________________________________________________

    LOL, a huge vulture in a tree. LOL. Maybe the marigolds brought the vultures so that they could chase away the rabbits who thought that the vulture was there to eat them.

  • 16 years ago

    I'm gonna get me a few of them beneficial vultures. ;-)

    Jim

  • 16 years ago

    It could have been a hawk. I don't know the difference, but within the same 3 days, a groundhog happily slipped by the hawk/vulture that couldn't see it from the tree top. The groundhog and squirrels in the trees didn't seem to be afraid and the bird didn't seem to be looking at the squirrel who was in plain sight.

    There are about 30 that hang around sometimes, they did for weeks before the garden was planted. They are huge birds, but they haven't attacked anything. Vultures only eat rotting meat, so that is my guess of what they were.

  • 16 years ago

    I have 3 blocks of onions in front of one area of peas, these pea vines are not as big as the peas in the same bed, however they are producing as well and the soil depth is only 6inchs compared to the 12 in the same bed, it is sort of build up half way along with a extra level, but the soil was all added together, so I am more feeling it is the soil depth not the onions, as to the onions they are not near ready yet so can't tell, the only down side, I found was the peas grab hold of onions for support and pull on them :)

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting