Software
Houzz Logo Print
glacier1093

Hyponex potting soil contamination?

18 years ago

Hi all, I've been using Hyponex potting soil for my veggie seedlings, but the other day when my sister went out to get me another bag at our small local market, one of our neighbors told her that she had heard on the news of somebody's cat drinking the water that had leached out of their house plant which was potted in hyponex mix, and the cat and died, apparently the potting soil contained arsenic. Anyone know if there is any truth to this? I did a google search and couldn't really find anything. It had to have been recalled right? Should I be worried that eating the veggies potted in this soil would be dangerous? Just wondering if anyone knows about it.

Thanks

Glacier.

Comments (13)

  • 18 years ago

    Oh and I forgot to say, the plants in the hyponex don't do as well as the ones in the couple of other mixes I've used. But that might not mean anything, this stuff was really cheap.

  • 18 years ago

    Hyponex is beyond awful in containers. Read this and see for yourself

  • 18 years ago

    Is there a number on the bag to call? IF not, it's owned by the Scott's corporation. Call them and ask

  • 18 years ago

    Both I and a friend had total failures one year using a Schultz potting soil to start seeds. Perhaps the product is suitable for potting, but not for seed starting.

    Since then, I have used only Pro-Mix BX for starting seeds with excellent results.

    Jim

    Here is a link that might be useful: Pro-Mix

  • 18 years ago

    Can't say anything about the cat dying - sounds like some sort of urban myth to me. Arsenic? It would only be in there by accident, not on purpose. I'd be more inclided to think they had used some sort of insecticide or pesticide that got the cat but blamed it on the dirt.

    But that said, Hyponex has a very bad rep. Not much good for growing anything at any time. Chronic problems reported with it.

    Dave

  • 18 years ago

    Yeah, I knew there had to be a downside to the cheapness. And there was. ah well, wont be buying them again, and I hope that the whole arsenic thing was just a rumor or a fluke. Thanks Justaguy, that's good info to have.

    Cheers all.

  • 18 years ago

    It is absolutely true because all soil contains arsenic, the soil isn't contaminated that is just how it is supposed to be. It is normally in the ppm level. I don't know if I believe the levels were high enough to kill a cat though. Even if they were it takes significantly more to harm humans because of our size compared to cats. I don't think there is any safety issue with the soil. That being said hyponex soil is really low quality and not useful for much of anything.

  • 18 years ago

    Lumber used to be treated with arsenic and at high enough levels where it is not allowed anymore. If the house plants were placed on a back deck, and that deck wood was treated lumber, that might be the source of the arsenic.

    I know that Hyponex soil has weed seeds. I used it to try and help my clay soil. Now I have weeds from it (different than my usual weeds.)

  • 18 years ago

    Hyponex is ghastly! I bought two bags for container plants--got it home and put it in my bin to dry out (it had been outside at the store and for once it had rained in Texas). I ended up with clods. I scraped out what I could to fill the most urgent containers and dumped the clods in a low place in the field. Even after driving the lawn tractor over the clods twice, the clods were intact! You could pave the driveway with the stuff! Never again . . . .

  • 18 years ago

    Yeah, the stuff is as hard as clay when it dries out, and it actually stunts veggies that were previously doing very well in a different medium, it does have weed seeds in it, and I've even seen small chunks of brown glass too. IT's awful. imo they shouldn't be allowed to put that stuff out on the market. I planted carrots (I know you're supposed to direct sow carrots but I did it as an experiment) in pure hyponex, it took awhile but they finally germinated, then a week later I planted carots in a differnt medium; the ones planted in hyponex haven't gotten bigger since germ, the ones planted a week later in the other soil are about 3-4 inches now. just trying to get he word out, hyponex bad.

    Cheers all.

  • 18 years ago

    Booberry, that's just pressure-treated wood that was treated with an arsenic compound - not lumber in general. Regular old lumber is just that - lumber, pieces of trees.

  • 18 years ago

    I too have paid the price for cheap potting soil. Natures Best: Never again!

  • 15 years ago

    I see all your previous notes are from 2008. Recently read book "Fateful Harvest" by Duff Wilson, a true account of hazardous waste with heavy metals being added to fertilizers, all legal "product" to add per USDA. I started some tomatoes in Hyponex in 20l0, they germinated, but only had a second set of leaves after 4 weeks. All my other starts were fine, having been started in organic potting mix. This book is out of print, but I got a copy from a used book dealer. Moral of this story is to only use OMRI approved organic mixes and composts.