Software
Houzz Logo Print
dave_in_nova

Varieties and Sources for Persimmon

I'm interested in planting a non-astringent Asian persimmon in my backyard. Is Fuyu a pretty good variety? What about Jiro? Are they very similar?

Also, is this a hopeless cause because I have squirrels?? Do I need to put netting over the tree to prevent critters from taking fruit?

Comments (11)

  • 18 years ago

    Dave, the persimmons are one of the few fruits my squirrels have not found yet. The deer apparently love them and can be a big problem.

    Below is a past post here on the Fuyu vs Jiro.

    Scott

    Here is a link that might be useful: old post

  • 18 years ago

    Scott, thanks for responding. The deer love the fruit? or the leaves and stems? or both?!!! We do have deer issues. I just noticed my Knockout Rose has been deer-pruned a bit.

    Regarding squirrels --- they are so curious. I set out some potted citrus fruits in July and the squirrels removed about half the unripe fruits (lemons, grapefruit) and took small bites out of them.

  • 18 years ago

    Dave, I don't know about the leaves or stems, its the fruit I was speaking of. I only occasionally get deer and they have thus far not gone after my persimmons in any way.

    Scott

  • 18 years ago

    Scott,

    What kind(s) of persimmons are you growing and which are your favorite??

  • 18 years ago

    Generally, the vegetation of persimmons is unpalatable to browsing animals. I never have damage from deer or rabbits with persimmons. The fruit are like candy for deer, raccoons, possums, and everything else, but only once they are dead ripe. Have you considered putting in any of the american cultivars. While I'm not sure where you would buy the trees, you can start seedlings and they graft as easily as any other tree. Early Golden, Ennis Seedless, Garretson, John Rick, and Prok are all good and sometimes exceedingly good. I would consider these. Good luck.
    Mike

  • 18 years ago

    Mike, if I had the room I'd love to try American persimmons. I really like the crunch of the non-astringents. Also, I like that they are small trees and have nice foliage.

  • 18 years ago

    Appleman178, are you growing Prok? If so, how's the flavor, size, productivty, etc? I planted a Prok whip last year, and can't find any info about it. Also, do you have male persimmons for pollination purposes?

    Thanks
    JB

  • 18 years ago

    Dave, so far I have gotten great fruit off of my Chocolate persimmon, very good Hachiyas (the standard grocery store one), and some OK Great Walls. Ask in a year or two and I will know more. Chocolate needs a pollinator but it is not astringent. I would not call it crunchy, it is somewhere between Fuyu and Hachiya on that scale.

    Scott

  • 18 years ago

    JB-
    My experience with Prok comes from another fellow here in MI, living on the West side of the state. Last year, his prok had excellent fruit. I have it grafted onto one of my seedlings but probably won't have fruit off it for another 3 years or maybe more. I started all of my persimmons from seed so ended up with a good smattering of male trees in the mix. I've thought that you could graft male scionwood onto one side of a tree, but have heard that it can switch to female flowers under some conditions so I've never tried it.
    Mike

  • 18 years ago

    Mike,
    Most male American persimmons are stable and will not 'switch' gender. Exceptions are largely limited to members of the Early Golden/Garretson family which occasionally sport polygamodioecious branches.
    Since persimmons 'self-prune' lower branches, male selections grafted onto side branches often don't persist - they may function for several years until the tree 'sheds' that branch as it becomes shaded by the expanding canopy and becomes senescent.

  • 18 years ago

    Dave, Fuyu and Jiro are similar with Fuyu being the best choice. FuyuÂs go from green, to yellow, to orange, to orange-red, and can be eaten at all stages with orange-red being the best and it ripens around November. When the fruit is green or yellow you can sometimes see teeth impressions from deer in the fruit where they tried it and found it too hard to eat. Birds also peck at them and find them too hard to make much of an impression. By October when the fruit is turning orange and an animal samples them, you can bet they will all be gone in a few days. I have a Tanenashi near by and if anything samples it first, that animal will not bother any of the persimmons. TanenashiÂs must be soft before you can eat them. The biggest problem I have with deer is that they rub their antlers on the trees in winter and completely rub off the bark all around the tree. The tree must then sprout below the rubbing and you have lost all the previous growth.
    For many years I used a Yard Gard high frequency noise maker that seemed to work. The sound it made was too high for me to hear, so I donÂt even know if it was working. All I know is that I harvested fruit. Persimmons will ripen on or off the tree. Some people say the fruit is better if picked early and allowed to ripen on the kitchen cabinet. You can save many fruit by doing this one thing. However, I believe that a tree ripened Fuyu is the best fruit this planet has to offer.