Software
Houzz Logo Print
fishacura

What do you mean by 'heirloom'?

14 years ago

I had always heard the term "heirloom" in the context of being old. In other words, when people spoke of "heirloom" tomatos they meant it was a variety that was from another time and not the common type you'd find in your grocery store. They also seemed to typicaly be "ugly" lots of wrinkles etc. (but taste great lol!)

More and more now I am seeing the term refer to "reproducability". In other words, due to companies like Monsanto (i.e. THE DEVIL) genetically altering seeds to NOT reproduce, other companies are calling their seed "heirloom" using it as an adjective meaning you can harvest the seeds and replant in the future.

Am I right in there being two uses of this term?

Comments (18)

  • 14 years ago

    They aren't 2 different uses. The ability of the seeds to breed true is just an extension of the fact that they are old open-pollinated varieties.

    Unfortunately some of the confusion comes from the improper use of the label 'heirloom' in garden marketing. There are true Heirlooms - certain named varieties that are 50 years old or more and have a documented history of source etc. and if not cross-pollinated will breed true from their seeds. (Ugly and so forth isn't a criteria. :)

    But there are also 1000s of varieties that aren't that old and/or have no documented history but will still breed true simply because they are open-pollinated varieties that have never cross-pollinated and have stabilized themselves over generations of growth.

    The latter should be marketed as Open-Pollinated, not Heirloom but they aren't. Instead they are also marketed as 'heirloom' even though they don't qualify as such. So thanks to mis-understanding of the terms and lazy marketing the label Heirloom has come to mean something like

    a variety that has been around for some years that may or may not have a documented history, but will usually breed true from seed so you can save the seeds from them for future use.

    Hope this helps.

    Dave

  • 14 years ago

    Thanks! Yes I assumed the marketing folks were at fault. It's actually not their fault as much as Monsanto et. al for doing what they are doing!

  • 14 years ago

    And just to set the record straight, the only seeds that will not reproduce are special interspecies crosses like Sakata's C. moschata x maxima. many commercial seeds are hybrids which do not come true but reproduce without problems. The only GMO vegetables currently on the market is Syngenta's BT sweet corn altho Monsano has announced that they will offer varieties this year. The flack about Monsano seems to be centered around Round- up and Round-up ready field crops.
    Heirloom has become a marketing ploy with as many definitions as there are people.

  • 14 years ago

    Actually, my understanding of Monsanto is that they are buying the rights to many varieties, altering them not to reproduce, and then suing farmers who have kept and are using the reproducing varieties. That's how I am understanding it. In other words, cornering the market on seeds. At least that is my understanding which could be wrong.

  • 14 years ago

    Here is what an heirloom is:-------------

    Definition of HEIRLOOM
    1 : a piece of property that descends to the heir as an inseparable part of an inheritance of real property
    2 : something of special value handed on from one generation to another
    3 : a horticultural variety that has survived for several generations usually due to the efforts of private individuals------------------

    There can be hybrid heirlooms or what ever a person or group really likes and wants to keep on keeping on, long after commercial entities let it go.

  • 14 years ago

    @weirdtrev...my interest in Monsanto (by way of example) is to state that they are the root cause of needing to explicitly state heirloom.

    20 years ago...you planted a tomato...you saved seeds...you planted more next year.

    Now companies NEED to state heirloom BECAUSE many varieties are being specifically engineerd NOT to reproduce in order to force you to buy more...thus the Monsanto comment (unless I completely misunderstand what they are doing which I don't believe I do...but educate me if need be).

  • 14 years ago

    Why the interest in Monsanto? They have nothing to do with the definition of a heirloom or why consumers/marketers mix open-pollinated and heirloom. Also your understanding is misguided.

    Agree. Monsanto has nothing to do with whether a tomato or a squash or a pepper seed is sold/labeled as 'heirloom' or 'hybrid'. Hybrids are not GMOs and 1000s of so-called heirloom (open pollinated) varieties will still be around regardless of Monsanto's existence.

    I'm all for a buyer being aware and informed about the issues but let's not go overboard.

    Dave

  • 14 years ago

    I just did a quick google and here was an example of what I was talking about. May be misguided but there's plenty of info out there on how they're trying to copyright all the seeds, remove reproducability and therefore control the markets.....

  • 14 years ago

    I just did a quick google and here was an example of what I was talking about. May be misguided but there's plenty of info out there on how they're trying to copyright all the seeds, remove reproducability and therefore control the markets.....

  • 14 years ago

    fishacura; 20 years ago most tomatoes were hybrids. Beginning in 1950 with Burpees's Big Boy hybrids became ever increasingly popular. Ditto with Sweet corn but most vegetables that are hybridized have been in place before 1992.
    Even open pollinated varieties intended for commercial use are given Plant Variety Protection (PVP). Like a patent on a new mouse trap it protects the developer for a number of years. If you infringe on the patent, then you get taken to court.

  • 14 years ago

    Monsanto/GMO/etc cannot "buy up" seed lines they don't own. An open pollinated heirloom will survive as long as people save and share seed. What Monstanto/etc are doing is buying up large seed distribution/hybridization companies for their own non-GMO seed work. It's not all about total GMO there. They have their hands in a lot of interests like a lot of multi-national corporations. The selection/variety may thin once a company is taken over, but the new owner is still doing traditional non-GMO hybridization work. A lot of these companies bought out own long-standing genetic stock and produce some of the most popular hybrids. They are nothing more than an attractive "buy" for corporations looking to expand their portfolio and revenue streams.

    They also aren't inserting reproduction-killing genetics into their stuff...they bought a company that owned the patent to do so. It's considered pretty dangerous and very unlikely to be approved if any money was sunk into using the technology. Owning a patent doesn't mean they're actively engaged in it's production...though they're not the most awesome people in the world to hold such a patent.

    Also, if anyone is concerned about GMO garden veggies (aside from sweet corn and to a lesser extent yellow squash), all the real work there is being done by small companies because the "big boys of GMO" are busy putting money where the real profit is...grains, soy, cotton...acreage planting...commercial planting...

  • 14 years ago

    "Monsanto/GMO/etc cannot "buy up" seed lines they don't own. "

    Oops...they can't "buy up" seed lines that NO ONE owns.

    ...that was clear as mud.

  • 14 years ago

    I suppose it is a matter of perspective. One could almost thank Monsanto for creating a reactionary market. As more people are becoming disenchanted with Monsanto, they begin looking for an alternative market and now more people are becoming interested in their food, the varieties offered and how it is grown and providing a business base for small seed companies who can employee people and give me the hope (at least) of growing awesome produce. One could (almost) thank them...

  • 14 years ago

    I just did a quick google and here was an example of what I was talking about. May be misguided but there's plenty of info out there on how they're trying to copyright all the seeds, remove reproducability and therefore control the markets.....

    You posted this twice but provided no link to the info/example you are talking about. So what example?

    Dave

  • 14 years ago

    My preference would be to use the term heirloom in line with what RpR posted. Use the term mainly for varieties which have been passed down through private hands, for a good many years;... perhaps something like 40 or 50. I have grown Sunray VF (tomato), on and off, since 1984. Back then, it was getting dropped from most commercial sources. But I have never called it an heirloom. In my mind, the best thing to call it is an open pollinated variety. "Open pollinated" is the term which most interests me. That tells me, pretty much, what I can do with it.

    I don't much care for the flavor of a fresh Roma paste tomato. But it's a great canner, and it's open pollinated. So I can save seed. Is it an heirloom? Not in my mind, though I believe the variety was introduced in the 70's. It hasn't been passed on, down through private channels, for a good deal of time. Still, it strikes me as a very worthy variety. I like it! It's open pollinated.

    There are some wonderful open pollinated varieties out there
    which came about through commercial plant breeding. They're not really heirlooms. But it would be a shame if they were to disappear, through neglect of growers, because the fashion is to grow only heirlooms.

    George
    Tahlequah, OK

  • 14 years ago

    Right now the "holy grail" for GMO research is aluminum toxicity resistance.

    There's lots of land around the equator region (all over the world) where aluminum toxicity is limiting to plant growth, proper yields, and harvested grain nutrient content.

    The solution we use in most industrialized nations is lowering the pH to make the Al less available (therefore lowering plant toxicity).

    The problem with that solution along the equator is that many farmers not only can't afford proper liming materials...the materials aren't around in large amounts where they're at or they're prohibitively expensive to apply to crop lands.

    All the major GMO companies have been working on sweet corn and some are now making it to market, but I can honestly say that almost every major GMO producer's focus right now is mainly in 2 areas...aluminum toxicity resistance and the ever-present low-water-use-without-effecting-yields properties.

    The major companies are a lot more interested in selling to the farmer planing 100s of acres of grain, cotton, and soy. The home gardener not only doesn't buy as much, they are very vocal and a lot more confrontational about what goes in their fields.

    As far as smaller GMO firms go...those are the ones that are working on the stuff the big boys won't touch...some in hopes a big boy will buy them out once they create something that will sell on a commercial scale. Tree fruit GMOs are going to be very big in the next decade+. The GMO papaya and what it's done to it's industry from a farmer's perspective is hard to ignore...and lessons+loot learned and earned from it makes it hard to ignore for smaller GMO companies.

Sponsored
Custom Home Works
Average rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars10 Reviews
Franklin County's Award-Winning Design, Build and Remodeling Expert