Software
Houzz Logo Print
lycheeluva

first time grafter- incredibly 4/4 took

18 years ago

I had never tried grafting before I decided to give it a go this spring. I purchased 4 apple scions from Maplevalley orchards (I highly recommend- huge variety of scions and only $3 each with prompt shipping).

After, doing some internet research I grafted two using the cleft method (ashmead's kernal and Bell-De Boskoop)[onto a golden russet), and 2 using the bark flap method (Karmije De Sonnaville and Kidds Orange Red)[onto a cox orange pippin]. The cleft method is far easier. It is now about 6 weeks later, and incredibly, all 4 of them have leafed out. 2 of 4 of the scions even have muliple blossoms on them.

Is it a complete no-no, to allow those blossoms to try and set fruit. While i imagine, it is probably better for the long term vigour of the grafts not to allow the graft to set fruit this year, I am very impatient and it would not bother me if the grafts only gave me a handful of apples each year.

Please advise whether apple scions ever set fruit the first year and if yes, whether it is ok to allow them to do so if I am not concerned with future year's vigour?

Comments (8)

  • 18 years ago

    It's great, ain't it! Apples are among the greatest confidence-boosters that a novice grafter could choose to work with.
    No, don't let those first-year grafts set fruit. Doubtful that the graft union would be strong enough to support the weight of fruit - I have trouble with vigorous grafts blowing out in strong wind, or if a bird lights on them; imagine what might happen with the weight of several fruits.

  • 18 years ago

    I had a similar experience with my apple grafting this year... right down to getting Ashmead's Kernel scions from Maple Valley and grafting onto my eight-year old Cox O. Pippin. I had done eight cleft grafts and six took. Two of those are Calville Blanc D'Hiver on my Spitz and they took forever to leaf out. Very gratifying, indeed. I started eying every wild apple tree in sight and plotting to decapitate them and put them to good use. Also, through my grafting research, I learned that hawthorne can be used as a rootstock for pear and dreams of a Seckel, Savannah, and Maxine grove had me going for weeks. It gave me the confidence and inspiration to order rootstock from Raintree and bed them in to play with in the future. Fun, fun, fun! Now if I can just have similar success with chip budding my plums...
    Herbert

  • 18 years ago

    I topgrafted a Williams Pride on an old apple tree of mine two years ago. I left two buds on the scion. Both buds blossomed and set two apples each. It also grew a new branch 18" long. I think that if you are topworking a tree and cutting a lot of old vegetation off to replace with a new variety you will find that you can get away with letting it fruit because the root system is so much more supportive than if you were grafting to young rootstock.

    I have never had success with bud grafting of stone fruits either. Last year and this year I decided to do whip and tongue grafts earlier in the year (January and February in Tacoma WA). My success rate last year was about 8 out of 10. My success rate this year was 6 out of 7. I use a sharp utility knife to make my cuts, wrap tightly with rubber electrical tape, and then wrap the whole scion (cut to two or three buds long) with parafilm. I slit the electrical tape after about three months to prevent girdling.

  • 18 years ago

    Awesome. Congrats!

  • 18 years ago

    Good going!!

  • 18 years ago

    Congradulations! IsnÂt it a great feeling to see the bare twigs leaf out into branches? All my apple grafts last year took also, but none of them flowered this year. One of my 15-20 citrus grafts sprouted after doing nothing for around eight months.
    However, IÂve had no luck whatsoever with my stone fruit grafts. I do them just like the apple grafts: parafilm, grafting tape, electrical tape, roofing sealer for the bark grafts. IÂve tried bud grafts, cleft grafts, bark grafts, splice grafts using a caliber. Nothing took. I tried to whittle a whip and tongue, but it never lined up the way it looked in the grafting books. Last year I thought the failure might be old scion wood from the scion exchange, and so this year just grafted fresh scions directly off the trees. Still no luck. Decided it was easier to just buy the trees I wanted.

  • 18 years ago

    Does anyone use this "omega grafting tool"? I was thinking about buying one because I would think I would get better luck than I do trying to whittle my own, especially with my peach failures.

    http://www.raintreenursery.com/catalog/productdetails.cfm?ProductID=T245

    Carla in Sac

  • 18 years ago

    Carly,

    I own and have used that Omega grafter that comes with 3 inserts. I used it to do my first grafts. I had good success on Apple, Pear and Plum.

    Grafting really is pretty easy to do with a knife after a little practice, but I found the tool gave me enough of a confidence boost to get over the hump of believing grafting was something I could do.

    If the blades it came with were sharper I would probably warmly recommend it. As it is I'd say it works fine. It works best when stock and scion are reasonably close in size and not too big. If one is slightly bigger than the other make sure you line them up on one side rather than trying to center them.

    I still have mine and have been planning to sell it but haven't gotten around to it. I used it one season to do maybe a couple of dozen grafts with probably greater than 80% success using imperfect scions.

    Part of the reason I haven't sold it yet is because if I had a local buyer I'd just as soon teach him/her to graft with a knife. Check out Joe Real's bark grafting tutorial which I think shows the easiest way to graft for a beginner doing topwork.