Software
Houzz Logo Print
rosecorgis

Removing a tree and planting another

15 years ago

I could use some advice. The only full size tree in my backyard is an apricot tree. It's starting to fruit now and will continue for about 6 weeks. When the fruit fall, my dogs eat them. Usually it's just a mess but now my elderly dog is quite sick from the arsenic in the pits and that tree must go!!

I've decided to replace it with a Forest Pansy Redbud. They grow well here (my local nursey has three 20 ft ones that are beautiful)and they have the qualities I want - they flower, they don't fruit, they have a graceful growth pattern and they don't get huge.

Since it is the only shade in the yard I want to get one that's fairly big already. What is the best way to do this? Do I use my local nursery? Most of their trees are smaller? Do I find a tree nursery? There are some but then I would think the delivery costs would be bad?

As to removing the current tree, I'll need to hire someone to do that. Any suggestions how to find someone to do a good job and take out the stump so I can replant? Any advice for the replanting?

I know it would be better to replant elsewhere but it's a small yard and that's the only spot - a corner where the tree gives the shade garden it's shade.

I need to make the best out of a bad situation and finally get this done.

Finally, I know someone will suggest that I try picking up the fallen fruit before the dogs do. I can't outrun two adult corgis who go in opposite directions and swallow them whole. I've tried for 3 summers now. They LIKE apricots - rotten, green, unripe, pits included. Doesn't really matter to them.

Any suggestions and advice is appreciated.

Debbie

Comments (10)

  • 15 years ago

    The larger the tree, the longer the establishment period. Studies show smaller ones catch up to larger ones.

    Dan

  • 15 years ago

    Also there's the consideration of paying a lot for a tree that probably won't last all that long. Redbuds tent to be relatively short-lived. I guess maybe the instant gratification could be worth it to some, but I'd sure be hesitant to pay a lot for a redbud.

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks. How big would you get it?

    Any suggestions on removing one tree and planting another in the same spot?

  • 15 years ago

    Make sure you have the stump ground by the people who cut the tree down (ask if that is a service they provide when you are getting estimates) and try to plant at least a few feet away from where the trunk was previously. This help the roots of the new tree establish a little bit better. Get whatever size you want. If instant shade is a necessity, then that is what you will get ;) If you can wait on a smaller tree to get to size, that would be ideal. Just know the larger the tree, the more diligent you have to be with after planting care to help it along.

  • 15 years ago

    you are really pushing the envelope.. asking us.. on the world wide web ... what should be a local decision ...

    you need to get 3 to 5 estimates from reputable, INSURED landscape contractors..

    we can provide a list of questions to answer.. but we can NOT give you the answers you wish ...

    i would not go beyond an 8 foot tree .. and i would NOT place it in the hole from which the other is ground out ...

    it has to go into fresh clean soil.. not soil full of wood chips ...

    good luck

    ken

  • 15 years ago

    Ken does she really need all that for one tree? And a redbud at that?

  • 15 years ago

    No information is given (that I see) about how large the apricot tree is. If it's small, just yank it out. If it's large (for an apricot) and hanging over your house, estimates and insurance are probably important. A small tree can easily be dug out. A large one may have to have its stump ground.

  • 15 years ago

    Ken's right - it will take a pro to remove it. Trunk diameter is about 8 inches. It's a big tree. I'm no good at estimating height. It's probably 15 feet. I'm calling around to get estimates for removal.

    Good though about moving the planting a few feet away from the original hole.

    I wish it were a little tree I could just dig out. Wouldn't you know it's the only real tree on the property!!

  • 15 years ago

    Misread your comment Ken, disregard my reply.

  • 15 years ago

    actually on my 5 acres.. i would cut the tree flush ... treat the cambian layer with roundup or stump killer..

    and then plant the new tree in another spot ...

    the guy who plants the tree .. can probably do that for $100 bucks ..

    rather than the $500 - 1000 for removal and grinding ...

    though an 8 inch tree might seem out of your abilities ... for me and my chainsaw ... that is a 2 minute take down. and 2 hour wood removal ... if you are allowed to burn... a neighbor guy might be able to take care of it ... if you cant burn brush .. then hauling/disposal is an additional cost ...

    as to the tree size.. the larger the tree.. the more roots that have to be cut off.. to get it in your yard ... and the longer it will take to recover ... that is called stress .. and delayed 'establishment'

    a smaller tree ... has less roots to regrow .... and in a given 5 year period.. will PROBABLY get 'established' faster and outgrow a larger transplant ...

    so bigger is not always better ... unless instant gratification and checkbook abuse are the main factors ...

    ken