Software
Houzz Logo Print
ricksample

Tree Suggestions? Magnolia Maybe?

15 years ago

Hi all,

I'm creating a new mulch bed and I need a small tree that has a canopy that is high enough off ground to allow me to add a bench benieth for shade and also able to walk under. Maybe no more than 10' round, height isn't an issue. I would really like something pink, red, or yellow flowering. I was thinking of some kind of magnolia as I really like their huge bright flowers, but I don't know much about them or if they will form a tree. The few I've seen for sale in person almost look like a rather large shrub.

Another factor is something that doesn't have an invasive root system. This will be planted about 40' from the end of a septic system.

Suggestions welcome

Comments (8)

  • 15 years ago

    There are many tree from magnolias that would work for you. You will have to look for a tree form as you mentioned, many of them are clump form. Elizabeth is a creamy yellow with beautiful flowers. You could place a Saucer Magnolia with it's very large flowers and southern magnolia appearing flowers, there as well. Alexandrina is another Saucer Magnolia that would meet your needs and a bit more on the darker raspberry color.
    All of these have excellent summer foliage with very large green leaves.
    White Stardust is a large magnolia with very large pure white flowers and an outstanding fragrance.
    Lastly, Leonard Messel has a multitude of coral colored flowers and blooms proficiently, covering the entire plant in Spring.
    Good Luck

  • 15 years ago

    Most magnolas grow much broader than 10'. Even the shrubby ones.

  • 15 years ago

    You may be limited on the Magnolia selections if you want 10' wide and be able to sit under it. Royal Star would be one of the few choices. Although white its one of my favorites as it blooms a little later, avoiding late frosts, and is more floracious than most. Would take years and years before it hits 10' and allow room underneath for bench. This would be one of the shrubby ones you probably see.

    Unless you go with a fastigate tree you won't be able to accomplish what you want in my opinion.

    Options will open up if you can go 15' wide.

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks Everyone, I remeasured and can definitely go 15'. It won't have anything in front or on the sides of this tree for about 50'. It does have a row of green giants that are 15-16' behind it. So I should be ok to go up to 15'.

    As for Magnolias, I was looking at Ann or Jane for a couple... these look like they have nice bright flowers.

    I have also read some good reviews about Elizabeth and how it forms a good tree shape instead of the bushy type. But now that I think about it, I'm not to sure about the yellow flower. 50' in front of this tree I have a yellow Skylands spruce. When viewed from my deck, you'll see the yellow spruce, 50' behind the Magnolia. I'm concerned about two identical colors. If it had a pink or dark red flower, it may make the spruce tree "pop" a little more.

  • 15 years ago

    I'm drawing a blank for good, reliable pink flowers...what about a Crabapple? Coralburst is a fruitless variety that has a profuse relaiable showing of pink flowers. It will hit about 12 x 12.

    Jane is a nice one but stays too small and is more shrubby. Galaxy is a good one but its pushing the width range...I don't think it would hit 20' wide for 30 years, unless you have fertile loam/sandy soil.

  • 15 years ago

    CoralBurst may be something to look into. I have a couple different crabapples and really like the bright purple flowers. But I've always wanted a Magnolia after seeing more mature ones in town.

    A yellow one may not look to bad either (Elizabeth or Butterflies). What do the leaves look like on a Magnolia?

    I haven't seen magnolia trees in person up close, but on the internet they look rather interesting being so large and glossy. On the other hand, my crabapple leaves look rather unsightly (redish green, small).

  • 15 years ago

    A+ for Magnolia foliage. Take a look at the link. All the pics were taken very early fall. I had three Magnolias.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Tree Tour

  • 15 years ago

    I think from what you describe that you might like the Jane Magnolia. The color is, I think, one of the brightest of the Mags, and what I would call "purplish". They really are stunning in full bloom.

    However, someone above mentioned a CoralBurst crab. Maybe something you should think about is the whole "nature" of the tree. The magnolia and the coralburst crab are SO different. I actually purchased a Coralburst and returned it because it didn't go with my landscape. In my opinion, it has a very delicate look to it and would look great near a patio. Very, very beautiful in bloom, but very delicate looking.

    Magnolias are a "whole 'nuther thing" entirely. Even a Jane will get to be a substantial tree in your zone; the large leaves casting dense shade.

    Those two things are both quite beautiful, but very different. Just a thought.

Sponsored
Mary Shipley Interiors
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars34 Reviews
Columbus OH Premier Interior Designer 10x Best of Houzz