Software
Houzz Logo Print
northtexas

mystery tree that grows extremely fast

15 years ago

My mom has this tree growing at her house and we have no idea what it is. She estimates that she cut it down two years ago and now it is over 15 feet tall so it grows extremely fast. She has never seen it flower. Any ideas? It just spouted up one day and was not planted by her. I imagine that it can't be good.

{{gwi:380930}}

{{gwi:380935}}

{{gwi:380939}}

Comments (81)

  • 15 years ago

    I refer to french fries as a quick road to a fat ass.

    :D

  • 15 years ago

    That is a nice chart! The correct scientific names would be helpful.

    I agree there is no correct common name. Sometimes I don't even bother learning the common name. It's effort enough to learn and keep up with the changes in scientific names.

  • 15 years ago

    How's this? -- Did I get the names right?

    {{gwi:380945}}

  • 15 years ago

    I think I know what Mr. Resin is talking about.

    Anyhow, If it's north Texas. The Mulberry is one of the number one pest trees. If you don't pull them our when they are small it becomes troublesome. They take on many different leaf forms and shapes when they are growing vigorously.

  • 15 years ago

    Why not list both the scientific and the common name so we can learn?
    It'd be more productive than insult slinging. I have made an effort to learn the scientific names in the three years I've been posting here and others do, too.

    The arguments I've seen here lately are not helping the site. I think we've flat run off some people that came here for help and a few that came here to help. Now, many just come here to get a question answered and won't be back. But some of us genuinely want to learn. Shouldn't we make an effort to be decent to each other in the spirit of information sharing?

    (Now stepping off the soap box).

    Barb

  • 15 years ago

    Barb,

    I don't think anyone was really being offensive or indecent, and I think everything started off completely innocently. Resin honestly believed (whether valid, or not) that the name should be Field Maple. This was confusing to some, especially because Resin's post implied that Hedge Maple was incorrect. While Resin may have expressed feelings about the situation, I think he did so fairly politely (at least reasonably so). I even thought he might just be kidding. Others, including myself, pointed out the logical reasoning behind their position. I do see posts on here that go overboard (especially for those not familiar with various member's personalities and individual ways of expression), but a little disagreement (debate) can often be a good way to learn. Of course, I also agree that we should always try to take our audience's feelings and interpretations into account, as much as possible, anytime we post.

  • 15 years ago

    Sometimes there isn't even any agreement on scientific names. Giant Sequoia is an example. In the US it goes by sequoiadendron gigantea. In a book of recent publication by authors in England they called it wellingtonia. If we follow the native country gets to name it rule, it should go by sequoiadendron.

    To me it's a giant awesome tree that grows in my home state.

  • 15 years ago

    Mulberry tree has been cut down.

  • 15 years ago

    With scientific names, the differences are usually due to either mistakes (as in the Wellingtonia example), lack of knowledge (some information needed for properly naming the plant is not available), or gains in knowledge (future version of the last item). Great effort has been made to ensure that the rules, for giving a scientific name to a plant, prevent duplicate names. When a name has to be changed (due to new information) the old name is no longer really the correct name.

    I can't think of an example that doesn't fit into one of the three categories above, but there may be other reasons for varying scientific names (maybe simultaneous naming or something like that?).

  • 15 years ago

    There are bodies that decide the Latin name (and decide to annoy me and others by changing them). Wellingtonia??

    Nonetheless, excellent that the tree is down. Major roots likely to sprout. Keep ripping them (not cutting) and eventually they'll stop. I still care for one in CA when I go back and I can assure you that tree is a problem.

    Dan

  • 15 years ago

    brandon,
    I agree this was mild. I just didn't want to see it get nasty. I've no problem with disagreements, that is how we learn! Jamie, thanks for the pic. It was very helpful.

    Barb

  • 15 years ago

    Dan beat me to it - the mulberry will probably be back. Their roots have amazing regenerative powers, so be prepared to keep working at it.

  • 15 years ago

    I use a concentrated brush/stump killer when cutting down Morus alba as well as an assortment of other invasive trees and shrubs that are reknown for resprouting from the stump (Norway maple, Buckthorn, etc). Apply to outer edges of stump immediately after cutting.

  • 15 years ago

    The thing about that tree is the root pressure usually is such that it blows the brush killer right off. But you should try anyway, very early morning might work best.

    Dan

  • 15 years ago

    "But Resin, I would say that there is no such thing as a "correct" common name"

    I've heard this claim many times from US people; in most cultures, that is simply not true. Most cultures do have correct (and conversely, incorrect) names for things; it is normal human psychology, that if something is called A, then it is incorrect to call it B.

    "It's not even native here for goodness sakes! I don't know how they could force you to call it what we want to call it when it isn't even a natural occuring tree here. That is crazy"

    Exactly. But it doesn't stop them trying, by spamming their invasive alien renaming into thousands of websites often purporting to be 'international standards', and refusing to recognise any right for us to name our own natives.

    "Sometimes there isn't even any agreement on scientific names. Giant Sequoia is an example. In the US it goes by sequoiadendron gigantea. In a book of recent publication by authors in England they called it wellingtonia. If we follow the native country gets to name it rule, it should go by sequoiadendron"

    It's actually a little more complex than that! The tree was first named Wellingtonia gigantea in 1853, but (fortunately, since I think it a silly name too!) that genus name had already been used for something else a few years earlier (1840; Wellingtonia arnottiana from Indonesia, now treated as a synonym of Meliosma arnottiana), so it couldn't be used for Giant Sequoia. It was then put in the genus Sequoia, and then more recently (1939) split out into its own genus Sequoiadendron. I'm surprised though you found a book using Wellingtonia; every UK book I know uses Sequoiadendron giganteum, just the same as in California.

    Resin

  • 15 years ago

    If there is a "correct" common name in "US English" for Acer campestre, it is Hedge Maple. So, insisting that that shouldn't be the name is insisting that the correct name is incorrect. This is illogical and therefor a completely invalid argument. In fact, none of the argument (the one presented here) against the name Hedge Maple is based on logic.

  • 15 years ago

    I use common names for two reasons:

    -In some circles it is more understandble. Show up around non-tree folks and you better know Acer rubrum is red maple or else ppl will not understand you. In America it is also somehow offensive to sound more intelligent sprouting all that Latin and at the very least you get made fun of.

    -Frequently I do not know the Latin myself. A problem I can work on.

    My dream is eventually we will get past these language barriers. Perhaps a few hundred years. Latin seems as fine a compromise as anything.

    At the very least humans ever get some convenient form of international communication going after this glorified Morse code thing takes off, folks should figure out how to make themselves clear.

  • 15 years ago

    jamie, what did you do!lol!

  • 15 years ago

    I know...

    Sheesh... What a mess I started.

    All I did was read the name off of the tag that is hanging from my tree. Though it would be a nice little comparison of a few different trees. I even added the Latin names to second version.

    Jamie

  • 15 years ago

    Jamie, you really really didn't do anything wrong at all. I hope you know that!

  • 15 years ago

    Jamie, it was indeed sarcasm. Its interesting to see how one post with zero intent can trigger a strong debate.

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks. I was hoping this didn't all happen because I offended someone by using the wrong / slang name for a tree.

    I hope none of those invloved took it too seriously.

  • 15 years ago

    "If there is a "correct" common name in "US English" for Acer campestre, it is Hedge Maple. So, insisting that that shouldn't be the name is insisting that the correct name is incorrect. This is illogical and therefor a completely invalid argument. In fact, none of the argument (the one presented here) against the name Hedge Maple is based on logic"

    Not so - it isn't an American tree that Americans have any right to rename, any more than I have any right to say that the name of the US President should be something other than what you say.

    Resin

  • 15 years ago

    My favorite example is when a woman from England mentioned that "English ivy (Hedera helix)" is something they just called "ivy" there. That is so true!

  • 15 years ago

    "Not so - it isn't an American tree that Americans have any right to rename, any more than I have any right to say that the name of the US President should be something other than what you say."

    Not the same thing at all, and I'm quite sure you realized it! Your method makes the the whole use of common names nonsensical. Can you imagine the difficulties of a native speaker of one of the Chines languages for instance (who has no knowledge of English) having to use YOUR words for plants he wanted to discuss. And, I'd be willing to bet you don't use other languages when referring to plants from areas of other areas. I noticed you skipped my questions about that, earlier. As I've said, your ethnocentric viewpoint here has made your argument completely meaningless and, IMO, just silly.

  • 15 years ago

    Chines = Chinese

    when referring to plants from areas of other areas = when referring to plants from areas with other languages

  • 15 years ago

    Another interesting aspect to this quandary is that many UK sites refer to Acer campestre as Hedge Maple. Field Maple is a more common name there, but Hedge Maple isn't uncommon. It looks like the British haven't completely decided what to call "their" tree. I do hope Resin can straighten them out. (-;

  • 15 years ago

    "Another interesting aspect to this quandary is that many UK sites refer to Acer campestre as Hedge Maple. Field Maple is a more common name there, but Hedge Maple isn't uncommon. It looks like the British haven't completely decided what to call "their" tree. I do hope Resin can straighten them out. (-;"

    People who have been misled and/or succumbed to the US imperialist bullying into changing the name to suit US demands. You won't find it in any UK tree books.

    Resin

  • 15 years ago

    Resistance is futile, resin. We will assimilate all your plant names for the good of the collective

  • 15 years ago

    In the oak world, most of what I've learned as far as world wide sp. comes from the Brits along with the French. They are way ahead of the U.S.

  • 15 years ago

    This made my eyes bleed.

  • 15 years ago

    I think it's kind of funny (although I'm sure not everyone sees the humor in it). I wished I had time to search through a few tree books from the UK. I have a really good feeling I could find many examples of "Hedge Maple". Surely British authors have advanced to the point of using THE correct common name instead of the old outdated "Field Maple" name. If not, they'll come around and join the rest of the world one of these days. ROFL

  • 15 years ago

    In a geographical area as large as the US (and including Canada sometimes), we don't have one single "correct" common name for our natives! There are sometimes 5 or 10 of them, probably more. Last year my sister, who lives 30 miles away, was saying that the "spider plants" are blooming - I said "do you mean Spiderwort?" She described it and yes that's what she was talking about. Then I told her the correct botanical name Tradescantia virginiana - and she called me a plant snob! Haha, no more using latin names with her.

    Resin, does everyone in the UK call every native plant by one common name? I think it's a little ridiculous to expect a common name of a native plant to necessarily be recognized outside of the native range, in an alien country, perhaps even halfway around the globe. This does not mean that US imperialism does not exist in some cases, and I think it's appropriate that the local common name should be used when addressing a particular audience.

    Common names are just plain confusing anyway.

  • 15 years ago

    Wow, mountain out of a mole hill...

    Things take on different names for different reasons. Language barriers being a big one. Not just language but geographic. For resin to say this is because of imperialism is absurd.

    I would imagine those trees came to US long before international telephone or airlines, or email made international discussion common.

    I am not a plant snob, nor do i intend to become one. I am sure 99 percent of the members here know more than me on the subject. But It is not the scientific name being disputed, it is common, meaning common use from common people like me. I don't think they did that with intent of slamming the British. Eventually it spread and stuck.

    I did not join the forum to talk politics, I joined to seek help with plants. .But I could not stay out of this, it pulled me in like a tractor beam.

    I am sure I could find examples of things native to, or created in America that are called something else by the British. And you know what? I could care less. Hey why aren't you beating up the Aussies for using their own name too? Is your need for political correctness towards imperialists only?

    Come on Resin, get over yourself.

  • 15 years ago

    "Resin, does everyone in the UK call every native plant by one common name?"

    Yes; you can see them on the Botanical Society of the British Isles website here (xls file). That's just the same as with virtually everything else except plants in the US; e.g. birds in North America, where a similar standard name list is universally used.

    "I am sure I could find examples of things native to, or created in America that are called something else by the British"

    Yes, true; the big difference is that Britain isn't big, powerful and domineering, so our bad renamings don't have the same high visibility.

    "And you know what? ...."

    You aren't fighting for the survival of your cultural identity, or your right to self-determination. I am. That's the difference. If you were similarly affected by unwelcome alien invasion, you'd be fighting too.

    Resin

  • 15 years ago

    "I am sure I could find examples of things native to, or created in America that are called something else by the British"

    "Yes, true; the big difference is that Britain isn't big, powerful and domineering, so our bad renamings don't have the same high visibility."

    Doesn't change the fact that the pot is calling the kettle black.

    "You aren't fighting for the survival of your cultural identity, or your right to self-determination. I am. That's the difference. If you were similarly affected by unwelcome alien invasion, you'd be fighting too."

    Maybe so, but cultural identity from a tree with a different "common" name by people oceans apart is a bit of a stretch. And is a far cry from an alien invasion trying to steal your identity.

  • 15 years ago

    I'm hoping no one tries to get a last word in as this is going beyond a debate within a tree forum.

  • 15 years ago

    ... a woman from England .... hem,hem. I think that was me.

    I have to say, Resin, that, for once, I'm on the side of our friends the cultural imperialists on this one. My preference is for the botanical name to avoid confusion, but I don't see much point in trying to make other people use our common names. (Which, BTW, do vary, despite the existence of a standard name list, I'm sure you've read Geoffrey Grigson.) I also hang out on other Garden Web forums especially the vegetable ones. I talk about egg plants,zucchini, cilantro, arugula and favas, although I often put aubergine, courgette, coriander, rocket and broad bean in brackets. I use their names out of courtesy while making sure they get to know ours. But it really doesn't bother me. We know we use different words for many things, so why worry about plants? They are not insisting we call the thing hedge maple are they? We know Acer campestre is a direct translation of field maple so can't we just smile benignly and let them continue with their little foibles?

    And don't mention Rose of Sharon.

    p.s. I say 'Botanical' name because they are not all from Latin.

  • 15 years ago

    Yes, flora, that was you! ;)

    Oh yes, I forgot about the whole Rose of Sharon thing ... boy, that was dreadful.

  • 15 years ago

    On many of the forums common names are used predominately. There is a thread going on over at Wintersowing that has confused "blue mist" plant. Others assumed Coryopteris, I assume Eupatorium coelestinum. Another poster wants to know if "love-in-a-mist" is the same plant. I've seen threads go on for 30 replies talking about "lilies" when the poster really meant "daylilies". Ughh.

    In a more specialized forum, and or a more specialized thread about a particular plant or genus, I will tend to use the botanical/scientific names and include the common out of courtesy.

  • 15 years ago

    "Yes, (everyone in the UK calls every native plant by one common name)"

    "That's just the same as with virtually everything else except plants in the US"

    "...birds in North America, where a similar standard name list is universally used."

    None even slightly true, unless today is opposite day! And, BTW, don't you dare (read in an overly-dramatic way) try to rename our birds! We (most US residents) don't use the common names found on your bird-name list. StillROF

  • 15 years ago

    Are we there yet?

    Is it over yet?

    Mom, I need to stop and go to the bathroom!!!

  • 15 years ago

    huh???

  • 15 years ago

    She wants the post to cease.

  • 15 years ago

    Oh, I was wondering if someone should say, "Honey, do you want us to stop and let you out so you can walk the rest of the way?" (-:

  • 15 years ago

    This is what I hear when listening to this thread.

    Here is a link that might be useful: The sounds of gardenweb

  • 15 years ago

    ....just attempted levity...glad you got it whaas

    Sorry brandon, you'll get used to me eventually. lol

  • 15 years ago

    Lkz5ia,

    You got the title of that link wrong! Your title should have read "Lkz5ia's Auto-ethnophobic Music".

    If you really feel the music applies to this situation, you are missing multiple big pieces of the overall picture.

  • 15 years ago

    Oh no, ademink, don't start on 'bathrooms'! We'll be onto 'fenders', 'hoods', 'pants' and 'purses' next ;)

    Not to mention 'gardens' and 'yards'.

  • 15 years ago

    rofl...I especially won't talk about "khaki pants"...I learned that was a no-no from my British best friend as a child!