Software
Houzz Logo Print
birdwoman_gw

Help Selecting Roses for Long Island

13 years ago

I reside on the eastern northshore of Long Island. In the summer it gets hot and "very humid" here. Last summer I bought a number of roses bushes, some of which contacted blackspot (midas touch, midnight blue, scentimental in particular). I am a newbie to roses and am considering the following additions:
Hot Cocoa
Easy Does It
Blueberry Hill
Memorial Day
Molineux
Cherry Parfait
Purple Rain
Tournament of Roses
Cinco de Mayo
Gold Badge CL
John Cabot CL
Night Owl CL
Lady Ashe (Pillar)
I would appreciate any input on the above success rate of these roses.

Comments (14)

  • 13 years ago

    Hi there! I am in a very similar condition to you (high blackspot area, humid, also zone 6). Most of my roses (even my knockouts!) get blackspot. However, some of them don't completely defoliate and those are the ones I look for. From your list I have seen Hot Cocoa and Cinqo de Mayo in my neighborhood and they don't defoliate and don't look too bad. I have them for spring order along with Easy Does it. I also have Molineaux for spring order but I know that one will blackspot, I have not seen an Austin in the area that has not, much less an Austin that has yellow (most yellows blackspot terribly for me). I also have Memorial Day for Spring order but have heard it gets blackspot in the northeast (helpmefind.com reports it getting lots of BS for someone in CT). Once again, I am still looking forward to those and hoping they don't look terrible.

  • 13 years ago

    Hi there! I am in a very similar condition to you (high blackspot area, humid, also zone 6). Most of my roses (even my knockouts!) get blackspot. However, some of them don't completely defoliate and those are the ones I look for. From your list I have seen Hot Cocoa and Cinqo de Mayo in my neighborhood and they don't defoliate and don't look too bad. I have them for spring order along with Easy Does it. I also have Molineaux for spring order but I know that one will blackspot, I have not seen an Austin in the area that has not, much less an Austin that has yellow (most yellows blackspot terribly for me). I also have Memorial Day for Spring order but have heard it gets blackspot in the northeast (helpmefind.com reports it getting lots of BS for someone in CT). Once again, I am still looking forward to those and hoping they don't look terrible.

  • 13 years ago

    Karolina - thanks very much for answering my request - I appreciate the time you took out to write to me. I think I am going to skip Memorial Day and get Tournament of Roses in it's place. I can tell you one thing that helped the blackspot. It's a liquid named BioSafe OxiDate - EPA and OMRI listed - it gets diluted in water and sprayed on. You'll have to google it. Anyway, it seems to work super fast on contact. I guess after purchasing our new roses this coming Spring, we will both have our fingers crossed. Good talking with you. :-)

  • 13 years ago

    Thanks for the tip! Have you used Bayer Advance Disease Control for roses? I was just wondering how the two compare. That's what I am currently using.

  • 13 years ago

    No problem - anytime. Yes, I used the Bayer Advanced Disease Control on my older roses. However, I was leary applying it to my newly planted "own root" roses. When the BS showed up on the own root roses I sprayed them with the Oxidate and they made a quick recovery - new leaves and flowers. the only other thing I applied to the new own root roses twice was a liquid fertilizer - I think it's named Neptune Fish emulsion with Kelp. I plan on using the Oxidate as a preventative as soon as the weather allows - on the plants and the surrounding soil.I don't know how to send you a link - I just joined this rose forum but, if you google and type in: "Biological Fungicides: How does Oxidate Compare? Enviro Strides?" - this might help you.

  • 13 years ago

    Memorial Day from the right source is a big, fat, healthy, prolific rose. I am in a colder zone with very high humidity and she is very clean for me. Fragrance tooooo die for, good repeat, etc. mine is about 7 years old. Cherry parfait is also beautiful but marginal fragrance and struggles thru Chicago winters. Don' t drop Md from your list. She is worth a try.

  • 13 years ago

    O.K. Susan you sold me on Memorial Day - consider it done - LOL - thanks a bunch for your input. Can someone please explain the difference between a repeat blooming and a continual blooming rose? Thanks in advance.

  • 13 years ago

    Memorial Day- the medium pink on the sides...not floppy but the way i have it arranged. One of my largest, best roses. In difficult climate.

  • 13 years ago

    her she is...sorry

  • 13 years ago

    Susan, I can certainly see why you are recommending Memorial Day - wow, what a beauty - beautiful photo - thank you. I would love to see that flower arrangement displayed on my dining room table.
    After much consideration, I have revised my buy list. It now includes the following:
    Westerland CL
    John Cabot CL
    Roberta Bondar CL
    Lady Ashe Pillar
    Memorial Day
    Brothers Grimm Fairy Tale Flor
    Rosemary Harkness
    Hot Cocoa
    Cinco De Mayo
    Julia Childs
    Blueberry Hill flor
    Easy Does It
    Cherry Parfait
    Tournament Of Roses
    Eliza
    Bonica
    I plan on keeping notes as to how well these particular roses do on the northeastern shores of Long Island (7a). I would appreciate any input in regards to my "final" selection.

  • 13 years ago

    I have been growing Cherry Parfait for about 4 years now--and probably will give it away come spring to anyone who passes by. It's an OK rose, but nothing spectacular--it has never made my heart sing, for instance. That is my criteria for roses I will love.

    Mine is not as black spot resistant as some sources claim it should be. No heavy duty BS, but frequently plagued with lightweight BS that made the plant usually look kind of dirty. And I like red and white blooms, but her blooms are rather sloppy looking. I don't like to look at the rose up close, although when I'm across the yard, she looks fine enough.

    Maybe it is just me, but I'm planning on replacing it with a much more disease-resistant rose with the loveliest little bloom clusters: Pomponella.

    Kate

  • 13 years ago

    Kate, thanks for input on Cherry Parfait. Sorry to hear it did not meet your expectations - that's so disappointing. I hope Pomponella becomes one of your favorite roses. I selected most of my roses from the "NY Botanical Peggy Rockefeller Rose Garden" list (same zone as me 7A). Pomponella is on the list too.

  • 13 years ago

    Climate appropriateness is everything. Here Cherry Parfait is a rock star.

  • 13 years ago

    Climate appropriateness is everything. Here Cherry Parfait is a rock star.

Sponsored
Mary Shipley Interiors
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars34 Reviews
Columbus OH Premier Interior Designer 10x Best of Houzz