Software
Houzz Logo Print
nastydave

Can I divide this echeveria?

13 years ago

Hello everyone, I have a simple question about this pink echeveria I started from a cutting (sorry for picture quality). I have not seen the roots or how they are connected. Can I make 3 plants from this by splitting them? Should i just cut the smaller two out and let the big one grow? Any advice is very appreciated!

Comments (27)

  • 13 years ago

    That soil is horrible for your plants. Remove your plants from it, and plant with something a lot more porous (cut it with 50% perlite, for one suggestion - there are lots of soil mixes, but they need to be porous). Once your plant's healthy and abundant, you can start cuttings from them. Do a search here for cuttings, and you'll get advice on how to do that, too.

  • 13 years ago

    The soil is not an issue. I am using regular cactus potting soil because I started a lot of cuttings, I like to do it in large plastic dishes with no drainage. Once the cuttings take root they need to be kept moist while the baby clones grow. It has been a very successful method. I transplant the clones to better soil for adult plants when they are a good size. I plan on transplanting this particular echeveria tomorrow and my question is should I transplant as is, leaving three plants on one root system? Or should I try to separate them into individual plants? If I leave them as is I will eventually cut the smaller two away so It will be a nice symmetrical plant.

  • 13 years ago

    You're having two cultural problems. One of them is the craptastic soil you have them in - trust me on this, I know what I'm talking about.

    Another is no drainage. It's not a good idea, in fact it's a bad one.

    It's simply not a good idea to propagate succulent plants with those two conditions. If you don't believe me (there actually have been doubters recently!), our colleagues, associates, friends, Rynocaulons and countrywo/men will back me up shortly.

    As I said, I'd not so much transplant that as get it out of that injurious dreck (I guess I've made my opinion known on that by now, eh?) and grow it in much more porous soil. Once it's larger and growing, then you can - I wouldn't worry about individual plant health so much as total plant health, therefore they shouldn't be divided yet.

    And yet, I could be all wrong and you've discovered the perfect method of growing these in your particular growing environment - I'd bet my mortgage payment against it, but there you have it. Cultural conditions and practices, as I've recently written on another thread, play the almost-complete part in how Kamloops grows them differently than Nashua does. It's almost all about whatcha got?.

    This post was edited by cactusmcharris on Fri, May 10, 13 at 13:10

  • 13 years ago

    Sorry but there's a 3rd problem as well.

    That forward most plant is incompatible w/ the rest as it's some kind of jungle cactus & the others are arid land type succulents.

    I'm w/ Jeff on this, more important to fix the mix than transplant. That Echeveria is getting unnaturally tall (etiolated) as it stretches for the light. This stress the plant unnecessarily & puts it at a disadvantage BEFORE you even transplant it. But you seem to think you know better.

    So Jeff, wont' you tell us how you really feel?!

  • 13 years ago

    Karen,

    Sometimes (not in this one, yet) I wonder why I do.

  • 13 years ago

    I suggest separating all of those plants. Those echeverias areetiolated and therefore wont be the shapliest plant even with the best of care. I suggest leaf cuttings

  • 13 years ago

    I'm laughing out loud - you just outed yourself. The ol' in-direct-contradistinction and selectively-good-spelling was what did it. Doppelganger Schnitzengruber, go thee away.

    This post was edited by cactusmcharris on Fri, May 10, 13 at 15:03

  • 13 years ago

    As Jeff knows of what he speaks, I would follow his advice. =)
    Maybe you have been able to keep your plants alive, so you're thinking you don't need to change the way you're doing it. Jeff is pointing out what would make your plants grow better.

    I'm guessing your "regular cactus potting soil" is some pre-mixed stuff from a store. Most of us here have found we need to add something (or lots of somethings) to the mix to make it more porous. Everyone has a bit different environment, so no one way works for all, and additives aren't always available to everyone.

    Your Echeveria 'Perle von Nurnberg' is etiolated (stretched out, looking for light). If you started it from a cutting, was there just one stem? If so, then those 3 are likely the original stem with 2 branches. You could make 2 more cuttings from them. But if you're transplanting them, you might as well behead them all & put 3 heads in their own sm pots with well-draining soil. You should get good, compact growth (leaves closer together)...& symmetrical plants, if grown in good light. I don't know if you're in a part of the country that still has winter conditions, or if you're able to give them more light.

    It is never a good idea to grow succulents in containers with no drain holes. Yes, they can survive (for a while) but it isn't good for healthy root growth & in the end, not good for the plant.

    If, on the other hand, those are 3 separate plants, you could pot them up separately ~let them grow a bit~ before beheading them (cuttings again) to get them growing more compactly.

  • 13 years ago

    If you want three separate plants, cut each stem about two sets of leaves up from the bottom. Pull about two sets of leaves off of each cutting, if possible (those bottom leaves look a bit bowed and mis-shapen anyway, probably from being in soil that's too damp). Let the cutting callus over for a day or two, and stick the cutting into some dry, well-draining soil, burying the stem where you pulled the leaves off. Wait 5-7 days, then water it lightly once a week after. You'll get three separate plants, and the part that's left in the soil after you've cut it will grow more shoots, too.

  • 13 years ago

    What brand of soil would you suggest? I am using miracle grow potting soil. I water sparingly once a week. The soil is dry most of the time. unfortunately this little guy sprouted in the winter and there hasn't been much light. Thanks for the advice. I'm putting together a succulent pot for mothers day, this is one of the plants I'll include.

  • 13 years ago

    Miracle Grow is absolutely to be avoided for succulents, as it is high in peat. Peat is water-retentive, and you want the exact opposite: something very well-draining. What is marketed for most plants will kill what you have in the long run. As Jeff recommended, you could add an extraordinary amount of pumice or perlite or another well-draining ingredient to the mix you have now, or you could re-do your soil mix altogether and create one consisting of things like bark and pumice or perlite (thus avoiding peat completely). We want to mimic the plants' natural habitat, and what type of soil they're most happy with, and Echeveria don't like to stay moist for very long. And unfortunately, no one sells a decent mix you can just buy, so it's not a matter of brand. Picking up some pumice or perlite would be in order.

  • 13 years ago

    Colleen,

    You would be surprised incredibly as to who uses MG soil (and it's not just Little Jeffy)-sieved, it can and is used to great advantage, effect and prosperity. In other news, the sun's coming up in the West tomorrow. I am recanting my blasphemies about it even as I type this.

  • 13 years ago

    I decided to go ahead and divide the plant. It was connected to the same root system. After splitting it up two of the stalks had some roots and one had none. I put some root hormone on them and with any luck I should get three individual plants. Thanks again for the advice!

  • 13 years ago

    Here is a pic of the finished project. There is perlite mixed in but the top half inch of soil has none. I think it looks pretty good I just hope I'm not crowding them. All but one of them I started from cuttings.

  • 13 years ago

    I would beg to disagree (I think, in fact I know you can improve on your setup/mix), but all that really matters is if you're happy with it. If you're happy with it, I'll walk on by and hope your plants grow well.

    {{gwi:528681}}

    {{gwi:528680}}

  • 13 years ago

    Here is a pic of the finished project. There is perlite mixed in but the top half inch of soil has none. I think it looks pretty good I just hope I'm not crowding them. All but one of them I started from cuttings.

    {{!gwi}}

  • 13 years ago

    Jeff,
    If you had those plants in Miracle Grow you wouldn't of killed the "big" leaves on the ground!
    John

  • 13 years ago

    JGW3, The big leaves on the ground are the nursery leaves that are slowly giving their stored nutrients to the baby plants. They didn't just fall off and die. Jeff took them off the mother-plant to make new babies. They did that and now They are giving their insides to the babies as PLANNED.

    Miracle grow is awful stuff unless one cuts it by an equal part of grit. I never use it because once the peat dries it becomes hydrophobic and will not easily accept water.

    This post was edited by wantonamara on Sat, May 11, 13 at 18:09

  • 13 years ago

    Here is a pic of the finished project. There is perlite mixed in but the top half inch of soil has none. I think it looks pretty good I just hope I'm not crowding them. All but one of them I started from cuttings.

    {{!gwi}}

  • 13 years ago

    ND, weird that the forum keeps posting your last post (twice more, anyway) w/o the pic.

    Your mom will be happy with your suxpot gift. I would've put it in a smaller pot (crammed plants), but maybe they will fill in over time. I would tell her to take extra care not to over water them with all that soil to swim in. =)

  • 13 years ago

    Here is a pic of the finished project. There is perlite mixed in but the top half inch of soil has none. I think it looks pretty good I just hope I'm not crowding them. All but one of them I started from cuttings.

    {{!gwi}}

  • 8 years ago

    Good lord. Sifting through all of the unsolicited insult-advice to see the answer to the question was so exhausting I gave up. The know-it-all attitudes are hilarious, because if you really did know as much as y’all think you do, you would know that speaking in absolutes about substrates for growing is pure ignorance. You don’t know where this person lives, their care routine, or the stage of development the succs are in/where they came from. It’s better to let baby succs or developed props grow in a much richer soil than adults. I only post this so some poor soul looking for advice doesn’t take all the incredibly flawed ‘advice’ to heart.

  • 8 years ago
    Yeah Rylee, it was hard to read. But I’m sure cactusmcharris and others are as cool as they think they are. People are usually at their best on the internet haha.
  • 8 years ago

    I miss Cactusmcharris. God I wish he would come back And call idiocy with his idiosyncratic comments. Maybe Mcharris us an acquired taste.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Oh GOD, I did NOT think anyone would ever see that comment since this thread was so old! I’m busted I guess! Sorry guys, I’m not talking smack on anyone, it just all seems so aggressive and rude when someone was genuinely asking for help. Obviously I’m not always on my best behavior (judging from above) and I shouldn’t expect others to be when online either. Mah bad. Just venting.

  • 8 years ago

    ..."Some of my best teachers were not pleasant and told things the way they really were. The tenner of the forum has sank drastically. in recent years"....

    Very true!