Software
Houzz Logo Print
linus7_gw

Conifers in this soil?

17 years ago

Hi!

Im having some doubts on choosing which trees to plant in a part of my place where soil is particularly poor, even if there´s lots of falling leaves every autumn and winter and the all area is covered with it.

1.Are there any conifers which do (not so bad) in superficial acidic sandy soil? (Dry summers, shade !!!)...

If any which would you say are more likely to thrive?

2.How about clay soil?

3.Which soil is best for Calocedrus Decurrens?

Thanks

L.

Comments (5)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    (Dry summer, shade you say)
    Picea pungens, should be ok. (all soil types)
    Thuja occidentalis (same)
    Hemlocks, I don't know why not.
    Definitely Microbiota decussata

    Calocedrus, will need well drained soil or it's likely to get Phytopherthora.

    Chamaecyparis obtusa I would think would be OK if well-drained. or if grafted to Thuja occidentalis or Thuja orientalis, then could handle clay.

    Picea orientalis 'Skylands' will grow very well. Won't be as colorful, but will be very full.

    Dax

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I'll see if I can help you a little more:

    "Conifers for Difficult Sites

    Keith Rushforth: Most plants will grow very nicely thank you on good soils but often the need is for effective plants to use in the less desirable situations. Not all conifers will grow on these sites but within the group as a whole there is a sizeable number of species which tolerate or thrive on the problems sites.

    Dry Sandy Sites

    The main constraint on plant growth on these soils is the availability of moisture during the growing season, although on many the soil is also extremely acid. Nutrients are almost always in short supply on these soils as any dissolved chemicals are soon washed out by periodic heavy rainfall. The plants which thrive here need to be capable either of rooting very deeply, or of controlling moisture use. The two groups of plants which on a world-wide scale flourish on these sites are conifers and oaks. In the conifers, it is cypresses and pines which provide the bulk of the species, although other genera in these two families contain useful species.

    Pines are undoubtably the best conifers for these soils. In the wild they are very successful in regions with dry summer climates. The many pine species in Mexico and south-east USA are found in such climates and pines are also characteristic of the Mediterranean basin. They can grow fast on low nutrient levels, can root extensively and have tough needles designed to restrict moisture loss.

    Virtually all species of pine are suited to these sites and teh genus, therefore, gives the greatest opportunity to select plants for different uses, whether the requirement is for large trees or for smaller more shrubby ones like Pinyons (e.g. Pinus edulis) or the Lacebark pine (P. bungeana).

    Cypresses of the genus Cupressus are also very tolerant of drought conditions. The Saharan cypress (Cupressus dupreziana) Grows in a part of Algeria where the rainfall is minimum; several other species are native to the dry south-west of the USA. The range of plant types available from the cypresses is less extensive than in the pines but they include a few choice small trees as well as useful hedging plants.

    Junipers are also drought-tolerant and provide a number of plants of smaller size than found in either the pines or the cypresses. They are useful for offering ground cover and small bush forms.... but do include a few arborescent species from very dry regions. Some other genera in the cypress family such as Tetraclinis, are restricted in the wild to dry conditions but most are too tender for widespread use in temperate parts of the world.

    In the pine family, Western hemlock (Tsuga heterophylla), some species of spruce, particularly Likiang spruce (Picea likiangensis) and it's close allies, and a small number of Silver firs, e.g. White fir (Abies concolor and Vejar fir A. vejari) do very well on these sites. LIkiang spruce will naturally make a smaller tree than normal on such soils but will provide a much better display of flowers and fruits from an earlier age. The true cedars (Cedrus) are also adapted to dry sites, although preferring a higher nutrient supply than is often available on many sandy ones.

    Clay and Waterlogged Soils

    These two are not the same, although many characteristics are similar. Both soil types are poorly drained with low levels of oxygen available to the roots. However, they usually have adequate supplies of nutrients, due in clay soils to the structures of the soil particles and in waterlogged ones from the inflowing of water containing dissolved salts.

    The low level of oxygen available to the roots is the main constraint to plant growth on both soil types. In normal soils, the roots obtain the oxygen essential to life and growth from the air present in the soil but to thrive in conditions where there is no air in the so8il, or where such air as there is contains no oxygen, the trees need to be able to supply the oxygen by some other means. In wtaerlogged soils to a certain extent, the new roots have been found to grow with air spaces running through them. How common this phenomenon is is not known, although it is likely that many species which grow in these soils have a similar mechanism. A unique approach is adopted by the Swamp Cypress (Taxodium distichum) which produces special aerial roots, variously known as 'pneumatophores' or 'knees' when growing on water-logged or swampy sites. These structures used for 'breathing' in the widest sense, as they may be involved in venting harmful gases rather than simply in absorbing oxygen. In practice, poorly aerated soils have an excess of harmful chemicals, largely because there is not the oxygen to allow bacteria present in the soil to break them down.

    One other problem for many trees on these sites is drought. As the soil dries out during the summer the lower levels become aeratd and available for rooting but unless the tree's roots, can grow down fast enough to follow the water table, they may quickly exhaust the water held in the upper soil horizons. During the winter when rain raises the level of the water table, the lower roots may be killed, leaving the tree with an inadequate surface root system. Some species such as several spruces, are capable of growing well with a shallow plate-like root system but the most appropriate species for these soils are ones which can root deeply despite the conditions.

    Most conifers are capable of growing on clay soils, although trees will take longer to get establishe. Their establishment can be speeded-up by planting the young tree on a small mound and keeping an ara around the plant 3 m or more free from all competing vegetation.

    Some of the Silver firs, such as European silver fir (Abies alba), and Lawson cypress and other species of Chamaecyparis will flourish in these conditions once established , appreciating the generally high nutrient status. Amongst the pines, Coulter Pine (Pinus coulteri/I?) and Ponderosa pine (P. ponderosa) both do very well. Swamp cypress and Dawn Redwood also thrive.

    On really waterlogged sites the choice is more restricted. The deciduous conifers do disproportionately well. Swamp cypress and more expecially the reare Chinese swamp cypress (Glyptostrobus pensilis) will both grow in water permanently several centimetres deep. In fact, it is the only reliable way to grow the Chinese swamp cypress, as on drieer sites it is disntinctly tender. Dawn redwood will thrive in very wet conditions and the Olga Bay larch (Larix gmelini olgensis) occurs in bogs in the wild.

    With evergreen species the choice is more limited. Lodgepole pine will tolerate wetter conditions better than many other species but probabaly the best two are Western red cedar (Thuja plicata), which will grow more or less anywhere!, and White Cedar (Chamaecyparis thyoides). Growth will be slower and the time taken to establish longer than on more favourable sites for these evergreen species.

    Group 2 firs: Abies alba, cephalonica, nordmanniana, borisii-regis, bornmuelleriana, nebrodensis, equi-trojani. (Find ones suited to your climate)"

    Rushforth, Keith Conifers (1987); First published in the United States in 1987 by Facts On File, Inc., 460 Park Avenue South, New York, New York 10016; ISBN: 0-8160-1735-2

    Dax

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Sounds a good soil for conifers; the problem is the low overall rainfall and summer drought, which is limiting for trees like most Abies.

    Apart from locally native species like Pinus pinea, P. pinaster, P. halepensis and various junipers, some others that should do well include:
    Abies bracteata
    Cupressus atlantica
    Cupressus dupreziana
    Cupressus forbesii
    Cupressus sargentii
    Cupressus stephensonii
    Keteleeria evelyniana
    Pinus coulteri
    Pinus sabiniana
    Pinus torreyana
    Pseudotsuga macrocarpa
    Tetraclinis articulata

    Dax - climate-wise, think low altitude central California, for nearest equivalent conditions. Somewhere like Fresno or Sacramento.

    Resin

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I understand. Thanks Resin . . .

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    From what I've seen Calocedrus Decurrens grows naturally on volcanic loam at moderately high altitudes (>2000 ft., doing best @ 3,000-4,000 ft.). A friend of mine has some land just west of Mt. Shasta, where the dirt makes the air smell good (especially when you're drinkin' whiskey around a fire!), and the Calocedrus Decurrens up there are HUGE. Saw one that had it's lowest branches probably forty feet up, had to be at least 4 feet DBH. Probably ten times older than any of us.

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting